9 ms·
Is that headline damning with faint praise? Mere "thousands" doesn't seem like enough to get critical mass on a social network. For comparison Google+ had som
by jandrese 7y ago
Is that headline damning with faint praise? Mere "thousands" doesn't seem like enough to get critical mass on a social network. For comparison Google+ had something on the order of 300 million users and failed to get traction.
- rbritton 7y agoAnecdotally, Google+ failed for me because I got stuck in an authentication loop for a business page. It wanted to verify the business, but the link to do so always errored out, which made it impossible to ever change the page content beyond what I initially put in. I stopped using both sides of it at that point, and it wouldn’t surprise me if others ran into similar rough edges. In true Google style, there was absolutely no route to support either.
- danielfoster 7y agoRan into a similar issue.
- znpy 7y agoit failed for me because the UI was slow as molasses and the circles functionality, while cool, was not clear in the sense that it was not clear who could see what when "posting to circles"
- workthrowaway 7y agogoogle+ did not fail for me. and many others i know. i enjoyed being part of communities around specific topics. spamming was the only problem i saw. and i just couldn't comprehend that the same company that defeated spams in email couldn't do the same on their social network. someone made a comment earlier about twitter killed vine and now tiktok is being a better vine. maybe someday we will see a social network where the emphasis is on communities and not the self. that's what google+ did better than anything that was out there.
- Tenoke 7y ago>maybe someday we will see a social network where the emphasis is on communities and not the self. that's what google+ did better than anything that was out there. That seems to be filled by irc channels (less now), subreddits and more recently discords.
- dmos62 7y agoAfter a brief recitation of facts it ends on a critical note, on par with the title: > Social media consultant Zoe Cairns said she thought the network would have to grow its numbers quickly in order to prove itself to be a viable alternative to the giants. > "It's going to need a lot of money ploughed into it," she said. > "People are so used to social media being free. I think businesses might pay for it, but people are so used to having news at their fingertips for free."
- organsnyder 7y agoGoogle+ only had that many users because many other Google properties (YouTube being the biggest) were lumped in together. I bet the majority of Google+ "users" weren't even aware that the platform existed.
- vcavallo 7y agoeveryone I knew had a Google+ account and none of them knew it.
- marcoseliziario 7y agoYeah. If you had a google account was more or less impossible not to be on Google+. The thing is that engagement was pathetically low. We used to joke that the best password manager would be to post all your secrets in a google+ posting, because nobody would ever see your post.
- SlowRobotAhead 7y agoBut that right there is why as a fairly strict free market type, I see the need for government intervention in some tech antitrust situations. If Google+ failed with google immediately signing anyone with a gmail account up for it and pushing it fairly hard with all their channels - how extremely unlikely is it for someone to organically take Facebook’s market share away? Oh no problem, you’ll only need someone with more resources than Google!
- zepto 7y agoGoogle plus didn’t do anything significantly better than Facebook
- gaius_baltar 7y agoMaybe not mainly YT: Google forced people to create one account there even for rating Android apps, so I suppose a lot of random Android users were counted too.
- varjag 7y ago
- sylens 7y agoThere are dozens of us! Dozens!
- type0 7y agoNo, no, it's already over 9000!
- ddxxdd 7y agoThat faint praise will transform into real praise once millions of BBC readers feel compelled to join those thousands already in Wikipedia's version of facebook.
- p1esk 7y agoI don’t feel compelled.
- gamblor956 7y agoJust what I've always wanted. A social network where others can edit my posts, competing reversion bots, and all power concentrated in a few super-users with nothing else to do with their time. What a compelling experience...
- nanomonkey 7y agoFrom my experience on Scuttlebutt and other decentralized/alternative social medias, thousands will try something out just to kick the tires; it's staying, contributing and utilizing the tool for things it wasn't intended for that really matters.
- freehunter 7y agoAnd convincing people to use a service named “scuttle butt”.
- tossAfterUsing 7y agoannecdotally, my attention isn't usually held for long by people who are unwilling to engage with a service because of it's weird name... https://scuttlebutt.nz/ https://scuttlebutt.nz/
- freehunter 7y agoAnd that’s fine for you. But it’s not fine for the service. Technically anyone can use the dating service Christian Mingle. But you might not find a lot of atheists or Jewish people on there, simply because of the name and the implication of the people who would use a service with that name.
- type0 7y agoWhat do you mean "Scuttle Butt" is a perfect name for a dating service, "Christian Minglë" is also awesome name, I hope someone start a service like that /s
- kick 7y agoIt's not a "service." They owe you nothing, and they don't need you to use it for them to keep using it. Especially given you aren't the target audience, all that really happens is you become a waste of bandwidth for anyone hosting a public peer.
- 7y ago
- enitihas 7y agoMere thousands are nowhere enough, but even Facebook also should have a very small number of high revenue customers. As long as this new network can draw a good enough amount of those users, they will be fine and will also impact Facebook's bottom line.
- dawg- 7y ago>Mere "thousands" doesn't seem like enough to get critical mass on a social network. It's kind of like running for president of the United States and bragging that you got "hundreds" of votes.
- Barrin92 7y agoI don't think the purpose here is to be the proverbial president of the US but to simply have a community of people who are willing to chip some money in and who want healthier discourse. If you're going to blow up to the size of facebook you're just going to suffer from the very same problems. More diversity and more competition and more alternatives is what this is supposed to be part of. I think the point here is to build an ecosystem of saner social networks, not the next Franken-network.
- beat 7y agoBut will it suffer from the problem of monetizing user data? That seems to be the big thing it's designed to avoid.
- capableweb 7y agoHow many users do you think HN has? No matter how many, I think I would call HN mostly a success (currently/temporary?). Seems that to have a good social network, it's less about quantity of content and more about quality. Most of Twitter is shit, but it contains some average content too, and a small amount of gold nuggets. HN feels to have much better signal/noise ratio and judging by myself and others who hang around here, it's way better here than what other "critical mass" social networks have.
- rafiki6 7y agoI think the key difference is HN doesn't need to make money
- capableweb 7y agoSure, we all choose our incentives. Facebook chose to follow money.
- Uehreka 7y agoI don’t think it makes sense to compare HN to other social networks. It wasn’t started as a business that would need to turn a profit, it was started as a side project by a rich guy (Paul Graham) who wanted to see what smart people thought about things. If HN fails to ever hit 1M users, PG (or Sam Altman) isn’t going to shut it down or cut off its funding, and neither he nor Y Combinator are expecting or relying on it to generate revenue. It continues to exist after over a decade because the Y Combinator folks find the content and discussion interesting. And hey, that’s all well and good. I’m glad that HN sticks around when a more profit-driven site would’ve failed years ago. But it’s important to note that what works for HN likely wouldn’t work for anyone else.
- ForHackernews 7y ago> The platform says it will never sell user data and relies on "the generosity of individual donors" rather than ads. Sounds like this isn't envisioned as a profit-making business, either. I'd happily donate some money to have a place my friends and family can easily hang out online that isn't trying to sell us to anything.
- a0zU 7y agoGoogle+ users only had to make a gmail account to be signed up for Google+, the amount of people actually actively using Google+ was far lower than 300 million.
- rgbrenner 7y agoThat's because Google tried to be the network for everyone. There are a lot of people.. several billion, and if that's your market, then 300m doesn't cut it. (They also forced it onto everyone.. there was little community there.) On the other hand, being the social network for a smaller audience is very do-able. Even Facebook started locally at Zuckerbergs college, then expanded to other colleges, before eventually opening up. Being the social network for a single school only requires a few thousand people.. then you're the social network everyone (in that school) wants to be on to discuss events relevant to the school... and you've created your foothold. Google was never interested in a creating a foothold in a small niche. They said "We're google.. basic marketing rules don't apply" and they learned they were wrong.
- Kye 7y agoSomehow I doubt they learned the lesson it should have taught them.
- gnode 7y ago> doesn't seem like enough to get critical mass on a social network. I'm not sure it matters for this social network. It's positioning as a news-based platform doesn't require people you know personally to use the site in order for it to have value. Perhaps conversely, too many people on a social network may be detrimental to these aims, as ever more narrow-minded echo chambers or factions can achieve critical mass.
- MBCook 7y agoBut G+ users didn’t choose it (by and large) it just happened TO them. In this case at least the users had agency and actually signed up. Still a small number in the grand scheme, but G+ was a bit of a different beast due to how Google launched it.
- xchaotic 7y agoThe size of the network didn’t doom Google+. It was the product management
- mc3 7y agoAnd Facebook had something like a college dorm, and did get traction.