7 ms·
Child protection should be treated much more as a "local" than "global" issue. If it's "scale" they want, to really protect children, then local boots on the g
by BLKNSLVR 7y ago
Child protection should be treated much more as a "local" than "global" issue. If it's "scale" they want, to really protect children, then local boots on the ground is still the best defense.
Rather than talking about encryption, Interpol should be espousing the benefits of local investigation and intervention based on mandatory reporting.
Removing child abuse content from the Internet is a digital issue. Protecting children from harm is a meatspace issue, and exponentially more important (but also more difficult and fraught with subjectivity).
- jacquesm 7y ago> Child protection should be treated much more as a "local" than "global" issue. That, unfortunately, is no longer an option. Pedophile rings including the content producers have realized long ago that going international gives them an extra layer of protection.
- BLKNSLVR 7y agoYou can't physically abuse over the internet though, that's my point and that's why I separated the two concepts of "removing content from the Internet" and "Protecting children from harm". The digital is an after-effect of the physical.
- jacquesm 7y agoNo, but you can order physical abuse over the internet. I really don't want to bother you with how dark some of the darker stuff on the internet is but you're going to have to trust me on this without having to become more explicit or you risk losing your breakfast and then some. The digital can definitely be a pre-cursor and active element in the physical.
- Freak_NL 7y agoSure, but then we're not talking about the vast majority of digital transgressions are we? That is, the simple (re)distribution of child pornography — ghastly enough as that is — not the few who actively seek out and order new abusive material from those who actually produce the stuff. This debate is about proportionality. How many children can live a marginally better live by giving up strong encryption and privacy worldwide? Because with the exception of the few cases in countries with a strong and well-functioning legal system, the abuse doesn't stop when the on-line orders stop coming in. How many activists and oppressed minorities will lose out (livelihoods and/or lives) by doing this? And even then, you're not addressing the real problem with this anti-encryption stance: how are you going to prevent the bad guys from using encryption? Encryption is here, right now, and it exists as a mathematical fact. Introduce a government (incidentally, which?) backdoor in WhatsApp or whichever major platform, and you catch some low-hanging fruit, until they wise up and use the vetted tools without a backdoor that already exist to hide their activities. This significantly impacts the proportionality balance. If you want to prevent child abuse, investing in education, welfare, economic equality, respect for basic human rights, and boots-on-the-ground police capacity will net you a vastly better return on investment.
- jacquesm 7y agoI'm not at all trying to pull this into the 'think of the children' domain, I'm just pointing out that what you think is going on is probably not nearly as bad as what is really going on. It goes a lot further than just child pornography, think snuff movies involving children made to order and other 'creative' idiocy. I'm all for people having access to encryption, I'm also for stamping out these criminals. The two are not mutually exclusive.
- Freak_NL 7y agoI have no doubts that whatever depravity a child can be submitted to that I can think up has or will have happened, and worse. There is certainly no god that prevents it, there is only us humans, and there are a handful of very sick individuals among the seven billion — that's just a statistical surety. > The two are not mutually exclusive. There we agree. But politicians worldwide do keep turning this into a 'think-of-the-children' fight. Only this month the Dutch minister of justice and security came up with exactly that argument for forcing Facebook to include a backdoor in WhatsApp — a plea indubitably neatly prompted by his colleagues in the US (cf. attorney general Barr's position on this topic).
- jacquesm 7y ago> and there are a handful of very sick individuals among the seven billion This is where you're wrong. Child porn is a substantial market, estimated to be in the billions of $ per year. It's a disproportionate amount compared to 'regular' porn because of the criminal element and the risks involved, just like illegal drugs are far more expensive than legal ones (in most parts of the world, anyway). Politicians abusing this to push their own agenda's are effectively also abusing these children... it's a fucked up world, that's for sure.
- zozbot234 7y agoBillions of dollars per year? On a world basis, that's quite insubstantial. And child abuse has always been around, unfortunately. Much of it probably goes unrecorded. Indeed, we only became aware of how bad the problem really was in the 1980s, due to the very fact that media of it was now being created and exchanged.
- concordDance 7y ago> No, but you can order physical abuse over the internet Is this actually taking place at a non-negligible scale?
- jacquesm 7y agoLarge enough that it bothers me. The Philippines is particularly problematic, the unofficial figures are that you're looking at roundabout 700K perps world-wide and an (obviously) smaller number of producers, how accurate those are I have no idea. Fortunately my exposure to this stuff has diminished drastically over the last couple of years because I stay a mile away from anything associated with webcams but when ww.com was still up it was a regular occurrence that we had to step in and shut down feeds and alert the authorities. And that was with a published policy of going after the originators and giving full cooperation to LE. So yes, that is happening at a non-negligible scale. In fact it is happening at a scale that is incredible (to me, at least).
- concordDance 7y ago> 700K perps world-wide and an (obviously) smaller number of producers The figures I'd want are not consumers or producers but numbers of children. A child being abused 1000 times is obviously awful but its not as bad as 1000 being abused once.
- jacquesm 7y ago> A child being abused 1000 times is obviously awful but its not as bad as 1000 being abused once. Obvious to you. The problem with this sort of reasoning is that children are not mathematical objects. It is also the sort of reasoning that ultimately leads to the rest of society deciding that us tech people are incapable of setting things up in such a way that abuse potential is minimized. Then you get reactive stuff like this article.
- BLKNSLVR 7y agoThanks for your continued replies and balanced counterpoints to various statements (including my own). Maybe I've gone the wrong direction, but I'm almost convinced now that it may actually be worse to make public statements linking encryption to child abuse because it potentially paints backdoors as a solution in the minds of the non-technical folks, and potentially makes child abuse closer to appearing to be a "solved problem" and distracts further from progress towards a real solution. I'm aware now (thanks to you and some others who have horrid coalface experience) that the digital realm is indeed more of a problem than I'd considered. I can't bring myself to accept, however, that mandated encryption backdoors are worth the attention they're being given by law enforcement for the purposes they're trying to align it with.
- SkyBelow 7y agoFor starters, we can't globally protect children from poverty. This in turn opens up parents in extreme poverty (such as having to choose which kid gets enough resources to survive) to be willing to make exchanges that we cannot fathom.
- jstarfish 7y agoWe cant globally protect children from shitty parents. Abuse and exploitation happens even in households where the parents are literally given stipends to pay for the child's care and upbringing-- be it in foster care or post-divorce. Some people just lack humanity.
- SkyBelow 7y agoYes, abuse still happens, but is it the same rate?
- n0rbwah 7y agoYes, giving access to all communications worldwide to the cops still won't help them catch the abusers that don't record and post their abuse online. Which I assume is the majority of child abuse cases.
- jacquesm 7y agoThe bigger problem the police have is not that they don't have enough cases go after, it is that they already are overwhelmed by the cases they do have and the fact that those departments are typically understaffed and overworked. It takes a special kind of person to be exposed to this crap on a daily basis and still be able to function, employee turnover is - not surprisingly - high and the effectiveness is relatively low because of the overwhelming caseload.
- mikece 7y agoThis cannot be emphasized enough. Normal humans can’t imagine the depravity to which child predators descend. I’ve heard stories from the teams who review content uploaded to YouTube to remove this filth and people who were just looking for a paying job end up alcoholic, suicidal and psychologically messed up for life after Only a few weeks of encountering this this stuff as part of the flagged content review process for places like YouTube and Facebook. I can only imagine the counseling required for law enforcement agents working these crimes is intense... as well as the temptation to shoot all suspects they arrest merely out of disgust. That said: banning encryption is not the answer to this.
- zozbot234 7y agoYup, my guess is that child predators, by and large, are basically criminal psychopaths. I wonder how many of them only prey on kids because they're such a convenient, vulnerable target.
- jacquesm 7y agoHere is one particularly shocking example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amsterdam_sex_crimes_case https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amsterdam_sex_crimes_case