3 ms·
You seem to be talking about Mt. Gox, based on https://bitcoinomics.net/if-youre-going-to-get-into-bitcoin-avoid-doing-business-with-this-man/ https://bitcoinom
by sillysaurusx 7y ago
You seem to be talking about Mt. Gox, based on https://bitcoinomics.net/if-youre-going-to-get-into-bitcoin-avoid-doing-business-with-this-man/ https://bitcoinomics.net/if-youre-going-to-get-into-bitcoin-...
I am one of those fools who "lost their life savings": $11k, that my father worked diligently to gather for me over many years. It still haunts me today that I squandered years of a person's life with such a decision. And yes, I would be happy to recover some of the money -- I supposedly am owed 7.7 BTC if Mt. Gox pays out.
Now, all that said, I am really not happy to see your comment here. And since I paid $11 thousand dollars to be in a position to reply to you, I think I will: it wouldn't matter if he murdered someone. You can't just come up on a completely unrelated thread and be like "It makes me sick to see you here on HN."
Ultimately, we have all made our choices, and part of those choices involved taking risks. That's why it's called a risk. I theoretically would have gained some ~$100k from my risk, but instead I lost my father's hard work. But I consider myself much richer for the lesson: I can pass this knowledge on to my own children so that they will be better positioned not to make similar mistakes.
As someone who has spent countless nights agonizing over such things, my advice is this: make peace with yourself. Externalizing like this only makes everything worse. If Satan himself wanted to leave a thoughtful, relevant HN comment, Satan should be permitted to do so without being harassed. There are very few communities where such an important rule is the norm, and it's worth preserving that culture.
- wodenokoto 7y ago> And since I paid $11 thousand dollars to be in a position to reply to you, I think I will: Is there a list of top HN quotes, because I would like to add this one!
- givinguflac 7y agoIt’s a pubic forum. If someone decides to be a shady scam artist, people have a right to point that out regardless of the thread context. I’d sure agree that Satan is allowed to comment, but other commenters are certainly allowed to point out that the freaking devil showed up.
- balfirevic 7y agoIt’s a public forum with particular guidelines. Personal attacks that have nothing to do with the topic at hand are very explicitly against those guidelines.
- givinguflac 7y agoStatements of fact about a person's previous behavior and actions are not personal attacks.
- tinco 7y agoHey sillysaurus, I've seen you around for years on here so I knew you're one of the people who lost a lot and I'm happy you're at peace with it. I'm someone who only lost a little so I'm not losing sleep over it. That's not why I'm attacking Peter even while that's against my favorite forum's rules and I might get banned for it. I don't think Peter is comparable to Satan. Peter also hasn't murdered someone, he's not committed an act that stemmed out of emotion, or a great need, or that he regrets. Peter is a human being that has made the decision to put his greed ahead of tens of thousands of people. At any moment could he say, "ok I'm sorry this was a bad idea" and stop and still gain millions of dollars. He doesn't. He is consciously hurting people for a possibility to make this absurd amount of money. In my frame of ethics, I can't just let him go around unharassed. If he goes unharassed it means that I, or we as a community, are ok with people behaving in an unethical manner. I'm sorry you had to witness my comment, I know it hurts the thread, but I just can't not make it.
- koheripbal 7y agoI think I speak for many people on here when I say, we don't care about your drama and don't want this forum to turn into another failed Reddit social justice crusade forum. If the poster above has an informative post, I'll upvote it regardless of who he is. It's about the content, not the people.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- vessenes 7y agoI usually don’t respond to comments like this because they tend to inflame the conversation; I can tell you care, so I’ll take a shot here at saying my perspective in hopes that it might help add some understanding. I’m sorry you both lost money and had it locked off for years; many people in the world, including me have had the same experience. I’m not the cause of your loss, and I’m not in control of its return. Some longer thoughts on the case below; if it expands your perspective all good. What we have asked for in the six years since we sounded the warning on mt gox insolvency with our suit (a full year of public warning for everyone who used gox) is a fair trial. The trustee repeatedly slowed or stopped that process, including going to the extraordinary measure of helping get Tibanne into bankruptcy six weeks before our US trial so that the case would be stayed. Before then Mark avoided the suit so aggressively that we had to go through The Hague convention to even serve him papers. That was many many years ago. We have never slowed a single court date or asked for a single extension. We just believe we are owed a fair adjudication of our contract and have proceeded both in confidence on the merits of our case and with the fundamental confidence that a party harmed by breach of a contract has the right to have damages determined. The narrative that we are the hold up is absolutely not true. In fact, we have never even been offered a settlement from the trustee which we could accept or reject. The trustee cheerfully went to court in venues he thought he could win, even negotiating for a return of some of mutum sigillums seized funds in the US; he could have had a ruling years ago from a US proceeding if he had wanted it. He clearly did not want that. We just want a ruling from an independent court on our 2012 contract, a contract made during an era of $10 bitcoin with a man who ended up committing US federal money laundering crimes, ‘lost’ 500k+ of the public’s bitcoin and has since been imprisoned. Public tweets or essays speculating we want something else come from two places - either from those who have decided, a priori, that our contract must not have been valid and therefore doesn’t even deserve due process and ergo is just a form of petulant spoiling, or are funded by VERY large claim holders in a sort of PR based pressure process. All that said, I would be very happy to continue to talk with you about this in person or on a live chat; my email is vessenes@gmail.com: feel free to reach out to me to continue this dialogue. As to who has a right to be where online, I will say over the years I have left some of my own thoughts about my career here and benefited immensely from others doing the same. I’d like for there to be places like this that aren’t gate-kept even if people are fighting. If you look back in my post history you will see one of my first posts/comments is about deciding not to go into business with Jed Mccaleb when he was running gox out of his bedroom in Costa Rica, long before either of us had heard of Mark Karpeles; I think that’s a cool bit of history! I liked and appreciated the HN community 10 years ago, and hope to be appreciating it in another 10.
- meowface 7y agoWhile the breach/fraud/mix of both/whatever happened was basically out of your control (though should've been considered as a risk; paper wallets have been around as a much more secure storage mechanism for a while), a similar scenario could've occurred if Bitcoin crashed and you sold low, or if it crashed and never recovered. I don't understand why someone would put 100% of something into a highly volatile and risky investment. Even if this were the ordinary stock market and it was 100% of your savings invested into one or two companies, it'd seem just as absurd.