14 ms·
The Innocent Pleasure of Trespassing
- sandoooo 7y agoI hope a bunch of stoned teenagers show up in the author's office to explore the pleasures of trespassing. (Owned by evil corporations! Private not personal property! Fair game!)
- GuiA 7y agoTrespassing != breaking and entering
- sandoooo 7y agoare you assuming that the author is suggesting the former while I am suggesting the latter? I even explicitly used the word trespassing!
- marricks 7y agoTheir first example is entering a hotel meant for the uber wealthy and going to the top floor, but go ahead and build you straw man I guess...
- sandoooo 7y ago"According to Forbes, not only is Brookfield the biggest office landlord in London and Los Angeles, it “quietly owns entire city skylines in places like Toronto and Sydney.” In New York, it owns the massive World Financial Center complex (whose real name is Brookfield Place) in Manhattan, along with the enormous skyscraper at One Liberty Plaza (which was built atop the bones of the Singer Building, the tallest building ever torn down)."
- casefields 7y ago*Other than the 2 World Trade Center towers.
- BLKNSLVR 7y agoSpecifically addressed in the article: "I’m not talking about breaking into your neighbor’s house at 3:00 a.m. to rummage through their stuff for drugs or money. This is the mental image that most of us probably associate with trespassing—" However if you were making a "tragedy of the commons" reference, then I'd be more inclined to agree. Edited to add: But, yes, the article's headline and intro is a front for the author's argument against growing corporate ownership of the planet. I tend to agree with the point being made, so I'm less likely to get snarky about "evil corporations" etc.
- sandoooo 7y agoThe author specifically differentiates between personal (neighbour-owned and not ok to trespass) and private (corporate-owned and fair game) property. Presumably his office is in the latter category.
- meej 7y agoRealize, you are talking about a publication that was started by a Kickstarter campaign that raised $16,000 [1], which is assembled in the living room of the EiC's apartment [2], and has a handful of full-time employees at most. The author doesn't have the sort of office you presume he does. [1] https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/804992239/current-affairs-a-colorful-political-magazine https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/804992239/current-affai... [2] https://www.theringer.com/2017/3/23/16044958/new-left-media-current-affairs-chapo-trap-house-crooked-media-9cb016070532 https://www.theringer.com/2017/3/23/16044958/new-left-media-...
- sandoooo 7y agoWell I do have an office of the sort that you're presuming that I'm presuming that he does, and so does most of the people in this thread, even the ones railing against the evils of The System. Unless he's doing this thing out of his mom's basement, I'm sticking with my wish for stoner teens.
- 7y ago
- zeba22 7y agoWhoosh
- pietroglyph 7y agoYou are attacking something the author did not say. I will assume that this strawman was unintentional (if I were to instead assume that you were acting in bad faith then there would no point responding to you; if you are in fact acting in bad faith, please take a moment to consider why it is that your argument requires a distortion of the truth to be defensible). The author does say that trespassing on private property, owned by corporations, is not wrong like other forms of "trespass" may be. His argument has one critical nuance that you ignore, however: he says that trespass is not wrong when it is an act that reclaims fundamentally public spaces from private ownership to make them accessible to everyone. A park, a corner between two buildings, and even a view of the city are deeply public things. Your office (especially the specific area in which you work and the items there) are not, and have never been, public spaces. These specific areas and items are also (by most interpretations) private property, which is another criterion that author has for property that should not be violated. To say that the author suggests that your office should be trespassed upon is an assertion ignorant of these components of the author's argument.
- sandoooo 7y agoThe author also singles out a corporation for owning a large number of prestigious offices (quote below). Why do you think that is?
- terryf 7y agoQuote from the article: "Needless to say, this kind of trespassing is usually bad, unless you’re breaking into one of Jeff Bezos’ homes." So it's ok to break into your house as long as you are very rich?
- cerberusss 7y agoRumor has it, that Jeff Bezos has homes that are being renovated for years on end, and that aren't used for living in. I think that's what the author meant.
- sandoooo 7y ago
- leggomylibro 7y agoYes, we all like breaking into places in ways that 'nobody cares about', and we all like beholding beautiful scenes which a majority of people don't think to look for. But there's a reason why most places discourage this sort of freewheeling exploration; when you visit a place and disrespect its boundaries, you often end up damaging it for the people who come after you. Even footsteps will eventually wear away stones, knock things loose, and disturb delicate habitats/ecosystems such as fungi. As the old saying goes, "plants grow by inches, but they die by feet." And if you play confidence games like the author, you're making it more likely for other people seeking the same location to get caught and punished. Yes, the sunbeams that cut through the jagged broken windows of an abandoned train station are gorgeous, and the view from the top of a palatial tower is hard to beat. But it's also sort of like driving through a wetland or ignoring 'please stay on trail' signs in the wild; if we derive pleasure from these places and consider them special, showing them off and visiting them regularly without regard for conservation seems like a poor way to honor them. Honestly, I have trouble seeing the views espoused in this article as anything other than selfish. Even publicly-owned lands have limits on their use, because we all share these spaces. They don't belong to you, they belong to all of us, and that includes future generations who will have the same yearnings that we do. I'd be interested to hear other takes, but as an occasional trespasser, this manifesto feels disrespectful and I feel like it might paint the community of urban (and natural) explorers in a bad light.
- larnmar 7y agoIndeed. Even the relatively harmless example of going up to a hotel floor to look at the view out of (I assume) the lift lobby is something that only works if you’re the only one doing it. If a bunch of people start doing it then all of a sudden guests start noticing crowds of people outside their rooms, the hotel is obliged to post security guards to stop it happening, and bingo, suddenly life is slightly worse for everyone. If you find yourself saying “it’s okay that I break the rules” with a full awareness that if everyone broke the same rules it would be terrible, then you are exactly the kind of selfish asshole that is the usual answer to the question of “why we can’t have nice things”.
- 7y ago
- djrobstep 7y agoIt's truly amazing to me that people accept landlording as legitimate. Nobody made land, so why should some people be allowed to make money out of it at the expense of others?
- jdnenej 7y agoBy that logic you have to reject all property ownership entirely and modern society becomes totally unable to function since no one could ever build a building. I think the vast majority of us find the ability to own land to be more useful than everyone living in grass tents that someone else could knock over because they want to sleep there.
- djrobstep 7y agoYou talk as though the concept of public property doesn't exist. It's also possible eliminate land rents from private property ownership, by charging 100% tax on the land portion (as opposed to the facilities on it). Perhaps your political preferences close your eyes to the practical possibilities?
- pietroglyph 7y agoI think the GP is drawing a distinction between private and personal property. If you outlaw private property (e.g. things owned in absentee by entities, usually to seek rent, like landlording) then you are not outlawing people owning the places in which they work or sleep. It is only when you outlaw personal property (e.g. your clothes, your home) that you encounter the problematic scenario that you suggest. When Marx says he wants to abolish private property (i.e. the means of production), he does not mean to abolish personal property. I think this nuance is often ignored or unknown, which is unfortunate.
- jdnenej 7y agoSo you are saying that people may only own land if they work or live on the land? This is not desirable for most businesses where renting property makes much more sense since it gives them the flexability to expand or downsize. It is also not desirable for people who are living somewhere temporarily.
- robben1234 7y agoOther than the legal side that is only relevant to EU and NA countries, there's a practical side of "trespassing". When you enter an abandoned building you take a huge risk. It's called abandoned for a reason - it's not maintained. Steps you step on may collapse. Plastering may fall on your head. Some drug addict may leave a used syringe on the floor for you to step on. Same goes for undeveloped areas outside of cities no one cares about (that are owned by some private entity and are not public). You may stumble upon on a wild animal, spider, snake. Find a poisonous fruit or berry. Ground may be unstable, some river may overflow. I've done a lot of wondering around of different areas in different countries but every time I enter an abandoned structure I hope today is not the day it collapses.
- riffraff 7y agoI see the parent post downvoted, but I don't see why. Indeed, that was my first thought when I saw the title, and since it's a very long read, I just ctrl+f "danger", which doesn't come up once. When I was a kid, I went into abandoned houses, churches, private land, and on a few occasions I crawled into old etruscan tombs looking for interesting bits (bits of broken vases, coins and such). It was very fun, and also very stupid, and I count myself lucky that nothing ever happened to me. One should be mindful when deciding to break into unmaintained areas, rather than charge in with a the hope of getting a nice instagram picture yelling "YOLO!".
- jandrese 7y agoI'm actually curious how many people are injured during "urbex" type activities? It might be a little harder to figure this out than you'd expect because the statistics would also likely count the homeless person that breaks into a warehouse and ODs. While the people are definitely in a more dangerous environment than usual, they are also likely to be on guard for hazards so I'm guessing the number of people actually hurt/killed doing these activities is very small.
- slavik81 7y agoThere was quite a sad case here recently. A midnight bobsled run. They'd done it before. It was great fun and relatively safe. What they didn't know was that this time the track had been set up for luge. The luge entrance blocked the bobsled track with a big metal gate, and they slammed into it at high speed. I occasionally went places I shouldn't have when I was a kid, but there's definitely risks to doing so. It's pretty hard to know what you're getting yourself into. https://calgary.ctvnews.ca/mobile/trespassing-tobogganing-teens-perish-on-canada-olympic-park-s-bobsled-track-1.2767457 https://calgary.ctvnews.ca/mobile/trespassing-tobogganing-te...
- archi42 7y agoIt's important to note that the author seems to be an anticapitalist; hence trespassing becomes a non-violent form of protest against the system he despises. Which is ironic, because he seems to be on the richer end of it (eg a white westerner who can afford intercontinental travel, on a job with a healthy work/life balance).
- BLKNSLVR 7y ago"Which is ironic, because he seems to be on the richer end of it (eg a white westerner who can afford intercontinental travel, on a job with a healthy work/life balance)" Which means they're exactly the sort of person who SHOULD be protesting the system. It's easy to criticize when you're not on the inside. I suggested an article to a colleague of mine. He was recently complaining about stale wage growth, and the article I suggested was showing reasons for of wage growth stagnation. He simply dismissed it by saying "yeah, but the person who wrote it is probably on $200k". End of story, point invalidated by privilege... WTF is that attitude? The overwhelming majority of voices you can hear are those in a position of privilege, even in the age of the Internet. A long-form article like this one isn't going to come out of rando ne'er-do-well xchan channel. Speak out from a non-privileged position: Pfft, work harder slacker Speak out from a position of privilege: Pfft, your words mean nothing from that ivory tower. Zero sum. That is not the way forward.
- 65267ddc 7y agoNo. Poor people want capital. Any rich asshole who criticize capitalism (not corporatism or state capitalism) is utterly despised by the poor -- and rightly so.
- BLKNSLVR 7y agoPoor capitalists want capital. To be fair to the -ism's, and unhelpfully flippant: Poor socialists want capitalism or actual socialism Poor communists want bread
- oceanplexian 7y ago
- mwill 7y agoThis is incredible curious, an upvoted post where (at the time of my comment) every top level comment is downvoted, possibly the most polarizing post I've ever seen on HN
- sandoooo 7y agoAs one of the posters of a TLC, I can tell you that the scores of all my posts are going up and down like a yoyo. Or it might be spiking up at irregular intervals then steadily decreasing over time. I haven't instrumented.
- ryandrake 7y agoIt's a recent phenomenon as far as I can tell. Within the last few months or so, every comment I post (especially at the top level) gets immediately, sometimes within seconds, downvoted to -1 or -2, then throughout the day stabilizes back up to some equilibrium value. I also wonder what the cause is.
- PhasmaFelis 7y agoSounds like someone may be downvote-botting you. Or just brigading. You might report it to HN. I've definitely seen the latter recently. Last week there was a post about Snopes' current legal troubles, and an argument started about whether Snopes was politically neutral or not. For the first hour or so, everyone who implied that Snopes was anything but rabidly left-wing was downvoted well into the grey, then mostly rose back up with time. It very much looked like someone had multiple accounts, or multiple friends with accounts, and was downvote-bombing everyone who disagreed with them.
- archi42 7y agoMaybe it's just that people have strong opinions and/or feel lightly triggered for some topics? (Also TLC here; and no, did not downvote you:P)
- kstenerud 7y agoI've done this all throughout my life. From exploring abandoned buildings & sites to going into "restricted against lowlifes" areas, it's amazing the cool stuff you can see! I've camped in ghost towns in Oregon. I've visited uncleared temples in Cambodia, covered in underbrush deep in the jungle. I've been in abandoned factories & hospitals, crashed a few gala affairs, visited beautiful beaches... you name it! And now, living in the former DDR (East Germany), there are so many abandoned places that you can visit a new one every weekend :)
- mihaifm 7y agoHow do you spot these places or find out about them, in general?
- et-al 7y agoEasy access to satellite imagery helps, along with always keeping an open eye and ear out for these things. That being said, Germany has a lots of abandoned factories and warehouses to explore once one gets out of the major cities. You're looking for places with large former industrial activity. That's why Detroit had so many photos coming out of it in the early 2010s. I'm sure Poland is also rife with buildings to explore.
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 7y agowalk/bike around aimlessly .. you'll find them soon enough.
- crispyambulance 7y agoIn the 80's and 90's, trespassing was a kind of hipster sport in Pittsburgh. There were numerous abandoned steel mills and factories-- these were huge facilities that had stopped operating years ago and were left to the elements. Since many of us lived near these structures, it was irresistible to explore them and see what's inside. Photographically, they're amazing subjects. They're also a dream-canvas for graffiti artists. It was also cool to just be there in the middle of the night with your friends, in a place that was so alien from everyplace else in the city. That said, property management doesn't see it that way. For them, it's a liability. These places are dangerous, there are often no lights and steep drops without guard rails. Sometimes the floor is just missing in places. Sharp objects everywhere and no easy way to get help if there's an accident. And if something did happen, who is to blame if a hipster falls down a chute 50 feet onto concrete? Not easy to say (regardless of what you may think). Security guards patrolled the area and would investigate any flashlights or people sightings. Worst case scenario you would get a citation, though our crew never got caught (in steel mills). In less dangerous buildings, things were more loose. If you had a camera and were there to take cool shots, security was apt to just kick you out. A camera was like a kind of "passport" for trespassers. Graffiti artists got a much harder response.
- anodyne33 7y agoI'm in the Law and Finance building on 4th. For years our elevator access was secured by a hasp and had direct access to the roof. That was a fun place to check out the 250th anniversary fireworks with a 6 pack.
- naringas 7y ago> who is to blame if a hipster falls down a chute 50 feet onto concrete? Why wouldn't it be the hipster's fault?
- ww520 7y agoMoney.
- oskapt 7y agoNot in the US. The property owner is liable for injury in the property even if the person was trespassing or committing a crime. People have legally shot intruders in their home and then been successfully sued in civil court for the injuries to the intruder. I had a freight elevator door pin my hand and damage a bunch of nerves while I was helping someone move furniture into his illegal Brooklyn loft. I got $50k for it. I carried $1M liability insurance on my Brooklyn townhouse because some visitor could slip and fall and sue me for all sorts of hardship. The system is broken. On the flip side I now live in a country where the law guarantees public access to the river running alongside of my property. The locals don’t actually know how the law works, only that they are supposed to have river access. So they jump fences, walk through my property, steal things on their way by, cut down my trees to make smokey fires for their bbq, piss and shit all over, leave empty beer cans and bottles and trash on the riverbank or in the river, and then swear that it’s their right to do so. So when they enter my property, they get a shotgun in their face and they are encouraged to find one of the myriad of other points of entry to the river. The law says they can access the river, but not that they can trespass to do it. Enter from the abandoned field on the other side. It’s the same river. The public don’t respect public places. They treat them as private places they can destroy and leave. The article talks about the place where homeless people would shelter from the wind but fails to mention that they also piss there until the spot reeks from 3 meters away. Is that their right too?
- pontifier 7y agoI've lamented the lack of true public property for a long time. I'm thinking about buying abandoned property in various places, at very low cost, and opening them up to public use. It would be done through a non-profit land holding company with the stated mission of opening land and abandoned structures to public use. Enter at your own risk signs, and a brief description that this property is now open for any legal use would be the only changes. (Barring removal of true death traps)
- GhostVII 7y agoI don't think an "enter at your own risk" sign would be enough to protect you from lawsuits. Even if you win the lawsuit, it is still expensive.
- vorpalhex 7y agoAnd do you intend to do the regular cleanup and maintenance these areas need when they're opened to the public? Do you intend to clean up the literal human waste and trash on a regular basis? It's a nice idea to have truly public property, but the reality is that people destroy land, especially when it's not their own, and upkeep isn't free or even cheap. Add to that things like zoning, land use codes and restrictions, and taxes, and it's easy to understand why we've lost so much public land. It still exists, but it's hard to find now.
- pontifier 7y agoNo, any activity on the property would be done by whoever was there. With no restriction, each person would be responsible for their own actions on the property.
- baud147258 7y agoAnd then you'd fall in the issue of the tragedy of (unmanaged) commons. Trash everywhere.
- carapace 7y agoWhat about National Forests? Would you consider that true public property? > National Forest is a classification of protected and managed federal lands in the United States. National Forests are largely forest and woodland areas owned collectively by the American people through the federal government, and managed by the United States Forest Service, a division of the United States Department of Agriculture. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_National_Forest https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_National_Forest Also, consider Slab City: > Slab City, also called The Slabs, is a largely snowbird community in the Sonoran Desert located in Imperial County, California, 100 miles (161 km) northeast of San Diego and 169 miles (272 km) southeast of Los Angeles within the California Badlands, and used by recreational vehicle owners and squatters from across North America. > The site is both decommissioned and uncontrolled, and there is no charge for parking. The site has no official electricity, running water, sewers, toilets or trash pickup service.[3] Many residents use generators or solar panels to generate electricity. The closest body of civilization with proper law enforcement is approximately four miles southwest of Slab City in Niland where the residents often go to do basic shopping. As a result, the site is described by its inhabitants and news outlets like Vice News as a miniature de facto enclave of anarchy. It might be considered a kind of Temporary Autonomous Zone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Temporary_Autonomous_Zone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Temporary_Autonomous_Zone
- pjmorris 7y ago"There was a big high wall there that tried to stop me; The sign was painted, it said private property; But on the back side it didn’t say nothing; That side was made for you and me." - Woody Guthrie, 'This Land is Your Land' (sometimes this verse goes missing)
- klyrs 7y agoI literally got in trouble for knowing this verse in elementary school. Dad came down with a tape cassette to show the principal what was up. :eyeroll: Funny how Guthrie's communist, anti-borders, anthem got co-opted by nationalists so far that they don't even understand the meaning... this verse couldn't make that cut, though.
- lukifer 7y ago> Funny how Guthrie's communist, anti-borders, anthem got co-opted by nationalists so far that they don't even understand the meaning There is a rich tradition in classical liberalism on the universality of land, predating the ideas of communism/Marxism. For instance, see Thomas Paine's advocacy for a tax on ground rent [0]; so-called "absentee landlords" were associated with royal aristocracies and enclosure [1]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agrarian_Justice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agrarian_Justice [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enclosure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enclosure
- nostrademons 7y agoAlso Georgism and the modern geolibertarian movement: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geolibertarianism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geolibertarianism
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoI am a tad incensed. My farm has been broken into..trespassed and squatted upon(literally and figuratively) ..my creek polluted and decades old trees topped off by not so innocent trespassers. And I was told by my insurance that it was my responsibility to install gates and fences as protection against liability. It costs thousands. How do you fence off creek banks and abutting wilderness for the bird life and wildlife? The law enforcement’s hands are tied as they declare themselves homeless and they have advocates and activists. I pay taxes and I have no rights. Except to ask them to leave and they keep coming back after dismantling their tents. And when they leave, they destroy my farm a little more out of spite..tractor and trailer stolen,Metal arches pulled away and placed as tents just outside my property line to throw it at my face because I can’t complain about property that isn’t mine and power lines running zig zag in my orchard stealing my electricity...greenhouse panels pulled out to build a bridge to cross the creek...trees with nesting birds topped off for campfires. Fences that I put up repeatedly run over by visitors of said homeless camp dwellers. I could go on..but this is what I surmised: when one thinks it’s ok to break one rule(trespassing), it becomes easier to break others. I consider unrepentant trespassing as character flaw and am wary of those who exhibit it.
- cmurf 7y agoWhat about shooting at them?
- iamthirsty 7y agoI would consult a lawyer. Depending on the state, I would personally be walking the perimeter of my farm with a gun, shooting at anyone who's stealing my property/power on sight. Homeless people have advocates, sure, but this is basically home invasion, burglary, and probably many other things that are just plain unacceptable by &/or from anyone.
- yourbandsucks 7y agoHow.. how many people have you shot on sight?
- jelliclesfarm 7y ago
- carapace 7y agoThere's so much wrong with this article that I'm lit. twitching, but I don't have time to write up a big thing on it. Let me just say, speaking as someone who was homeless for about four and a half years and who did a little bit of non-destructive trespassing out of necessity, that, generally speaking, trespassing is dangerous and disrespectful. You should avoid it if possible. It's not "a radical expression of freedom, hope, and humanity." You are not "striking a blow against hierarchy and capitalism and uptight motherfuckers everywhere." You're risking your life, jail time, or fines, for a cheap thrill. Trespassing only seems like fun if you're really really jaded, naive, or literally cannot afford to do anything better. You don't go to the amusement park and stand in line to throw rocks through the windows of an abandoned warehouse, do you? If you want to be radical, feed someone.
- baud147258 7y agoThe only time I trespassed was in Croatia, close to the Serbian border. We had taken the wrong road and ended up on a dead-end. A Serbian living there explained that the road ended up at a summer house of Tito, which was also intended to be used in case of Nuclear war, as it's built above a spring. We went to visit the building, which had been thoroughly trashed since the break-up of Yugoslavia. I also wonder why it hasn't been converted in a hotel, since it's close to one of the natural park of Croatia.