4 ms·
Ask HN: Googlers on HN, Why Does GOOG Let Pinterest, Quora and Yelp Ruin Search?
Title says it all. Why does Google continue to let Pinterest dominate search results on Google images? Similarly, why does Google allow Yelp and Quora dominate search results while heavily penalizing almost all other results which are behind pay/sign in walls? Further, Google seems to have decimated forum results (unless you append "forum" or "reddit" to your search), but how do forum results differ from Quora, Pinterest, and Yelp, which are crowdsourced, user generated content?
- dylz 7y agoPinterest absolutely should be completely deindexed everywhere.
- justaguyhere 7y agoI've never used it, can you explain why you don't like them?
- dylz 7y agoIt's basically a spam blog that hijacks inbound referrers from search engines to throw up full page sign in screens and nothing else. The vast majority of it is effectively stolen and rehosted content.
- jtloong 7y agoIs it that much different than Redditors rehosting images on Reddit/Imgur? I find the functional design of the site terrible but there's tons of popular sites that are based on hijacked content.
- adventured 7y agoAt least in the case of Reddit it's quite different. The primary value by a huge margin on Reddit is the text content, the comment / discussion section in each thread. Pinterest is basically entirely built around the rehosted images they pull in. It's by far and away the primary value on the platform. A distant second is the typically small amount of associated text with a given post.
- dylz 7y agoImgur is (IMO) turning into the same thing. Banning direct links, forcefully redirecting direct linked images to their ad packed pages of mostly stolen content.
- maps7 7y agoBeing so popular and serving images directly seems like a path to losing money
- hodder 7y agoNot really much different, but Imgur doesn't dominate Google Image results. Why does Google make the exception for Pinterest?
- njovin 7y agoEveryone else’s complaints are valid (forced signin, stolen content) but my main issue is it’s just completely useless. For example, I have a project or product in mind and search for something like “pink string lights”. The top three results will be pictures of EXACTLY WHAT I WANT on Pinterest. I follow the link and the URL is just...a picture. No link to a store where I can buy them. No link to a blog talking about building them. No discussion. No question. It’s just a picture somebody saw somewhere and posted to Pinterest (I still don’t understand why anyone does this as there seems to be no community). I’ve never had Pinterest lead me anywhere interesting or help me in any way. It is the black hole, Debbie Downer, dead end of the Internet.
- buboard 7y agothey hijack other people's images and when you click you are taken to a pinterest page which is obviously fake (not curated by a human). If that isn't spam , what is, really?
- tracer4201 7y agoPinterest always wants me to sign in before allowing me to see anything at all. To me, that should be enough to certainly never show them on the first few pages.
- AftHurrahWinch 7y agoHah! Indeed. I add -quora -pinterest -yelp to my searches by default, and it often reduces my results by 60% or more (for the better, in my opinion).
- rajacombinator 7y agoOf all the offenders in bad search quality these are hardly the worst offenders. The throwaway SEO’d affiliate blogspam and factory produced Medium articles are much worse.
- notahacker 7y agoSay what you like about blogspam, but at least you generally get to the awful content you click on, rather than being greeted by a signup process that will leave you with little chance of finding the image Pinterest served Googlebot even if you complete it. Plus penalising a single domain whose growth strategy is based on flagrantly violating Google's guidelines with deceptive search results ought to be a lot easier than playing whack-a-mole with SEOers.
- rajacombinator 7y agoOk that’s fair. Bait n switching gated content is BS.
- buboard 7y agothey are objectively worse, because they are a single entity , unlike those 1000s of tiny blogs.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- maps7 7y agoIt's like googlers don't dogfood their own product.. but they obviously must since I doubt they use any other search engine.
- seattle_spring 7y agoGoogle's algorithm actively promotes shitty content. Want proof? Go search for a tuna salad recipe.