12 ms·
U.S. Workers Show Little Improvement in 21st Century Skills
- phenkdo 7y agoThis might be an unpopular thing to say on this forum, but it needs to be said: 1. The average US worker is entitled and arrogant. The "everything is belong to me" attitude is rampant. 2. "There is no shortage if you pay enough" argument - especially in high-tech - is a bunch of BS. You could be paying 200-250K salaries and still you end up with bunch of incompetents.
- rublev 7y agoWow hot take watch out everyone.
- arcticbull 7y agoIMO that's more of a symptom than it is a cause. Re 1: Mid-western/"fly-over" state folks have been hit by large amounts of change in the last few decades. The "white working class" (especially male) was overthrown by globalization, immigration, by a renewed push for women's rights, LGBTQ rights and so-on. Wages went down, social rank went down and opportunities dwindled. No training programs, no social programs, no healthcare, nothing. This has led to a reactionary position of "returning to the good old days" of manufacturing, of mining, and conservative ideologies. To when they could pursue the American dream. I think it can come across the way you describe but it's driven more by fear and lack of opportunity than by some intrinsic arrogance characteristic. These are the folks who were left behind by the Democrats in 2016. The status quo genuinely wasn't working for them. Not that the alternative was better, but it was an alternative to a system that wasn't working and from their perspective they had nothing to lose. That's why we find ourselves where we do. Re 2: "There is no shortage if you pay enough" has more to do with the zero marginal cost business models that yield staggering quantities of revenue and profit per worker. Apple makes ~$40B per year in net profit off of 123,000 employees. That means could give each of them (including FTE geniuses and sales people) a $350,000 per year raise and still break even. There's tons of head-room here.
- cycrutchfield 7y ago> These are the folks who were left behind by the Democrats in 2016 Left behind? Wasn’t it their official party platform to offer social programs to help retrain these “left behind” workers for new opportunities? Instead they decided to vote for the party that promised them they would bring back 19th century industry, like coal mining.
- frockington1 7y agoThe midwest is region that values hardwork and personal responsibility. The government offering retraining programs was not going to win any proud midwestern workers. I am not arguing against retraining the workers, just the view of it over here in fly over country
- _delirium 7y agoBoth the Republicans and Democrats support job-retraining programs, and some do already exist for a few decades now. It's not clear they have much of a track record of success, though, and they've gotten a pretty bad reputation as a result. Proposing "more job retraining" nowadays as your solution is just met by cynicism. The Democrats did lean for a bit towards offering something stronger, but proposals like universal health insurance were voted down by the centrist/neoliberal faction in internal party politics, and didn't make it into the 2016 platform. It definitely wasn't a focus of the campaign either, which somewhat infamously chose to write off blue-collar voters and try to win by flipping moderate Republicans in affluent suburbs instead (Chuck Schumer articulated the strategy as, "For every blue-collar Democrat we lose in western Pennsylvania, we will pick up two moderate Republicans in the suburbs in Philadelphia").
- cycrutchfield 7y ago>Both the Republicans and Democrats support job-retraining programs Care to point me to campaign promises in 2016 to this effect? Or perhaps actions by the current administration in this direction? All I've seen or heard is pining for "clean coal" in various forms. >The Democrats did lean for a bit towards offering something stronger, but proposals like universal health insurance were voted down by the centrist/neoliberal faction in internal party politics, and didn't make it into the 2016 platform So these voters were so distressed by this that they decided to vote for the party whose stated goal was to remove health insurance from the poor and sick? This argument doesn't seem to hold water.
- Goronmon 7y ago1. The average US employer is entitled and arrogant. The "everything is belong to me" attitude is rampant. 2. The idea that "There is no shortage if you pay enough" is BS is just whining because employers just really want to underpay and overwork people and are defensive anytime they aren't able to accomplish exactly that.
- phenkdo 7y ago100% agreed. sauce for the goose == sauce for the gander. Hence, I find the argument that "there There is no shortage if you pay enough" so entitled and arrogant. The high-tech industry is already paying salaries, that most any other professions would kill for. So what is that "magic number" when your blue-collar guy will hang up his hard-hat and switch to coding? I am not aware of any untapped geniuses now toiling as coal miners, truck drivers or construction workers waiting for the salaries to hit a magic number for them to unleash their talents.
- majormajor 7y ago> I am not aware of any untapped geniuses now toiling as coal miners, truck drivers or construction workers waiting for the salaries to hit a magic number for them to unleash their talents. That's not who would be most affected by a long term trend of high salaries. It's the kids who would go to biz school or wall street or law school (or med school, but that's less of a positive, hah) instead because that's where the money has been in the past.
- phenkdo 7y agoYou are arguing against yourself there. Please define "high salaries". Wall st, Doctors, IT Professionals are already the highest paid professionals, and paid anywhere between 3x to many x more than your typical blue-collar salary. Are you saying this multiple needs be even more for the "kids" to work hard and become scientists, doctors or programmers? I think we all know the answer to that.
- spamizbad 7y ago
- hanniabu 7y agoI think this comes from an over correction in views of work. The younger generation has seen their parents enslaved their entire lives and know they don't want to live that life. I believe this is where the entitlement comes from, it's not that they think they deserve to be paid for nothing, but that if they're going to be forced to be imprisoned in an office all day then they want to be compensated handsomely for that sacrifice. Values are changing. Corporate American is stuck on a 60 hour work week that pays you for 40 hours and the youngest generation values life more (after seeing their parents give up everything for work) and they're also more in tune with the 3 day work week or 5 hour work day schedule. The younger generation values a healthy lifestyle while corporate America wants to work you to your death. Eventually there will be some swing back from the younger population, but I suspect most of the correction will appear on the corporate side.
- somurzakov 7y ago+ compare US work schedule to european - fewer paid vacation days, nonexistent maternity leave, expensive health insurance
- arcticbull 7y agoThat's a good point; the default is a realistic work-life balance, and American folks are willing to sacrifice for the company but only if they're compensated appropriately. This hits close to home for sure.
- Ancalagon 7y agoI disagree. Quality of life with regards to access to a lot of important things has been decreasing dramatically. While the cost of a television has gone down significantly in the last few decades, the things that matter: education, healthcare, housing, have all skyrocketed in price. If Americans seem "entitled" or "arrogant", I imagine its simply because its become much harder access these basic necessities.
- Miner49er 7y agoI think the opposite. The average US worker is not entitled or arrogant enough. The GDP has skyrocketed since the 70s, but wages have remained the same. All the wealth should be going to workers, but it's not and they don't feel entitled enough to fight for it.
- qntty 7y agoNote that this research was done in 2017. You can see the press release here: https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/piaac/current_results.asp https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/piaac/current_results.asp Sample questions from the test are available here: https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/piaac/sample_lit.asp https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/piaac/sample_lit.asp https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/piaac/sample_num.asp https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/piaac/sample_num.asp https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/piaac/sample_pstre.asp https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/piaac/sample_pstre.asp https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/piaac/sample_reading.asp https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/piaac/sample_reading.asp
- ksdale 7y agoMy wife and I are in the early stages of homeschooling our kids and one thing I've noticed in all my reading about education is that there seems to be one side that argues for more job training in school, and there's another side that argues that a well-rounded life includes much more than just job skills, and then there are articles like these, that seem to indicate that a ton of people are making it through the education system without learning anything at all. That seems like a much bigger problem than what should be on the curriculum, but it doesn't seem to be much talked about. On the professional side of things, I've come to expect that most 18 year olds won't know anything about anything, which is fine, 18 is quite young, after all, but it seems at odds with the tremendous amount of time and money that's been spent on the average 18 year old's education.
- bhupy 7y agoWhat makes it so difficult to change/improve the syllabi?
- ksdale 7y agoI don't think it's that difficult, but I think people spend way too much time arguing about the last half of the syllabus (what we should be teaching high schoolers) and ignoring the fact that a quarter or a third of students aren't even making it past the very beginning of the syllabus. It's like, arguing whether a kid should focus on computer science or Shakespeare, when the kid can't read. And obviously, there are tons of kids who are at the point of choosing between CS and Shakespeare, but it just seems like such enormous low hanging fruit to just make sure that everyone in the world can read and do basic arithmetic.
- potta_coffee 7y agoThe problem is, for the education system to work, students need to be faceless cogs. The reality is that we're all interested in different things and would be better suited by an individualized education.
- qntty 7y agoYou might argue that kids not knowing anything when they graduate is a symptom of the focus on professional skills. I found that the more people tried to teach me what they thought I "needed" to know rather than the things I was interested in, the less I learned and the less useful the stuff I learned was.
- gscott 7y agoThe real challenge is that it is nearly impossible to get hired for work even when you are qualified for it.
- have_faith 7y agoPart of the problem I have noticed is people being brought up with the idea that a qualification is what is required to get a job when reality is usually far from the truth. It certainly might get you into the door more often that someone without but a common mindset is if I tick the qualifications boxes I will be given a job. Tangentially related, this effects wage equality dissuasions as people get into the habit of comparing wages based on title and qualifications as opposed to value added to the company from your work. Some roles this happens to work ok for, but for lots of roles it just makes no sense, developers being a prime example.
- non-entity 7y agoSo what's the alternative? Kmowing the right people? That seems 100x harder than than getting qualifications sometimes.
- have_faith 7y agoThe alternative is learning what value you add to a company, what others are earning while providing similar value and learning how to communicate that value proposition effectively. These skills are much harder to learn than getting a qualification because they are subtle and not taught at school. Schools teach you how to get qualifications. Knowing the right people is the same as having a qualification, it's a stat boost.
- commandlinefan 7y ago> when you are qualified Ah, but you’re confused about what “qualified” means. In addition to having the educational background and the experience, you have to be qualified to work for a third or a fourth the pay you want, be available 24/7 (and physically in the office from 7 AM to 8 PM), and never complain. Fortunately for employers, they’re recruiting from all over the world, and there’s always somebody desperate enough to be more “qualified” than you.
- jays 7y agoIt's because the average American doesn't value education like they once use to. American's IMO value entertainment far more. We're living in a time when information and the ability to gain skills is easier than ever. Google, YouTube, Public Libraries, etc. It's all there, available for anyone. But American's have it in the their mind that the only way to gain skills is by going to a school and sitting in a classroom. Perhaps, the institution is to blame for that? Until Americans start realizing that education and being a lifetime learner is one of the most critical aspects of an economy, I'm afraid we won't see much in terms of improvements.
- dominotw 7y ago> American's IMO value entertainment far more. is there a country where this ins't true?
- anthonypasq 7y agoObviously not. But gotta reinforce the fat and lazy American stereotype
- jays 7y agoI'd actually hate to reinforce that stereotype. Certainly not my intent, but I can see how what I wrote certainly could paint that picture. I'll do better next time to clarify my thoughts and learn from this. Our entertainment options are crazy addictive today compared to the past. Our standard of living has also increased significantly post-WWII. If we do in fact value entertainment over education, it's not a knock on our society. We're just comfortable. When you get comfortable while being a dominate superpower, it's only a matter of time that another country will take your place.
- LeftHandPath 7y agoThere's a mix of both. There are hardworking Americans - usually first- and second-generation immigrants and the older, wealthier families - that value education and hard work. And then there is the middle class, who was raised on entertainment, music, and media that romanticized apathy and disdain for education and the workplace. And there is the lower class, which has enough of its own struggles that I don't want to try to summarize their problems in just a sentence or two. Either way, I do think that platforms like YouTube and Instagram give lots of influence to entrepreneurs - enough that Shark Tank started labeling some contestants as 'wanntrepreneurs' (wannabes) - and that the perceived value of self-driven diligence and the desire for intellect might become popular again. Actually, I think they already are starting to be popular again, especially among younger people. > But American's have it in the their mind that the only way to gain skills is by going to a school and sitting in a classroom. Ivory towers will come crumbling down in time.
- pram 7y agoAnecdote: In high school (2004) I got a CCNA after a year of networking classes. That was pretty useful. Or would have been, had I not been into Linux as a hobby already. I’ve been in IT since then but ended up never touching a switch or router in my entire professional life.
- keeganjw 7y agoWhat bugs me about this is reading the comments. Instead reading this news and thinking that when large swathes of the population are doing poorly there must be something wrong with the system, they turn around and just blame people for being stupid and lazy. There are tons of people in this country that grow up poor, in bad neighborhoods, with bad schools, and no hope of going to college and when things don't turn out well for them, we blame them for it. It may come as a shock to people from other countries but in the US school funding is extremely local. If you're from a rich neighborhood, your school has tons of money and resources. If you grow up in a poor neighborhood, some barely have enough money to keep the roof from leaking. And we've all just accepted this as normal and OK. We have the power to change this but we choose not to.
- BBalzagn 7y agoI also want to add that it can get even more complicated than simply rich vs poor districts. I feel that public education is not the HIGHEST priority in many districts around the nation. One example, Hillsborough county in Florida recently voted to raise taxes to assist with providing public high schools with proper access to air conditioning. Their schools do not have proper public transportation (school buses) or access to proper HVAC across one of the larger counties here in Florida.
- yardie 7y agoIt gets worse. In a few years they won't even have access to teachers nor a properly functioning classroom. There is an entire demographic of teachers approaching retirement and we don't have enough qualified teachers entering, and staying, in the field to replace them.
- magduf 7y ago>In a few years they won't even have access to teachers nor a properly functioning classroom. There is an entire demographic of teachers approaching retirement and we don't have enough qualified teachers entering, and staying, in the field to replace them. Yeah, for good reason: the career is terrible, so it shouldn't be a big surprise that no quality people want to go into it, and when someone good does get into it, they burn out quickly and leave. But government and society don't want to do anything about that. Teachers in this country face lousy pay, uninterested, disrespectful, and sometimes violent students, occasional school mass shootings, incompetent coworkers and administration, etc. Why would a well-educated person want to go into this field?
- commandlinefan 7y agoOne thing I’ve noticed is that as more things “advance”, there’s more that you’re supposed to already know - and an expectation (especially among people who themselves don’t really understand it) that it should somehow take _less_ time to get up to speed than it took in the past. Take machine learning, for example. You can work through a tensor flow tutorial in a day and understand how to use tensor flow to solve the problem in the tutorial or another problem close to it. If you actually want to understand how machine learning works - when it does or doesn’t apply, how to make it efficient enough to be usable, how to figure out where it went wrong when it does go wrong - you need to actually understand the statistics that’s behind it and the calculus that’s behind _that_. And that can take months or years, just to learn what you’re already “supposed” to know. I’m picking on machine learning, but I see this everywhere: I work with people who struggle to get Hibernate working because they don’t understand SQL joins, and they don’t have the time to go back and pick up “the basics” or people who can’t get Angular to work right because they don’t understand Javascript closures. As technology is made “simpler” it actually takes _longer_ to master while everybody on the outside looking in expects it to be easier to learn than before.
- non-entity 7y ago> Americans struggle with the most basic of math skills,” NCES Associate Commissioner Peggy Carr said in a statement. “We need to better equip Americans with the numeracy skills that they need for success, starting in middle and high school.” I can resonate with this. After starting sken projects that were going to require more CS knowledge than I have, I found in a rabbit hole completely ignorant of most things. Even simple things like doing division by hand and multivariable equations? I had completely forgotten hownto do. I was never particularly fond of math in school. Not sure why tbh, whenever I would get stuck on something the teacher was unable to explain things in a way I couldnt understand. I dont think I was stupid, hell throughout middle and high school I started programming andn hacking stuff, often finding ways out of classes to go do that instead. But by the time I was in HS, I found myself ending up in pre-calculus and calculus classes (ended up picking thats over stays because colleges would prefer it for any engineering discipline). And do to a mix of teachers who would generally pass anyone + technology ready available for me to plug in the problem in. I was constantly digesting articles that claimed this stuff would never be of use to me, that traditional education was useless for programmers and that of could slap together CRUD apps would be hired for six figures easily. I ended up deciding I wasnt going to bother with college as it was useless (in retrospect theres a lot of mixed truth to all that and I really wish I had gone to school) And of course fast forward and I dont hardly remember simple algebra, and could flat out tell you nothing about trig, or calc. It sucks, but I dont have time to relearn all that now.
- neonate 7y agohttps://outline.com/AZfPcW https://outline.com/AZfPcW
- credit_guy 7y agoWhat a negative spin on a pretty neutral result. Here's the actual link [1]. The latest results are for 2017 and the prior ones for 2012/14. The government's conclusion is: "Between 2012/14 and 2017, there were no statistically significant changes in the percentages of adults performing at each proficiency level in any of the three PIAAC domains" So, how can you spin "no statistically significant changes" into something more click-friendly? You say U.S. workers show little improvement. Nevermind that this was in no way restricted to "workers"; the survey covers all adults ages 16 to 65, in a representative fashion. How's the US compared to the rest of world? Here's the relevant documents: [2] for 2012/14 and [3] for 2019. Note that the format is slightly different, the first doc contains only OECD countries, while the second some more countries. * literacy. before: the US well below OECD average, just below England and Germany and above Poland and France. Now: the US slightly above average, still just below England and Germany, and just above Poland, but well above France * numeracy. before: well below average, only Italy and Spain worse than the US. Now: exactly the same. * computer numeracy. before: a notch below average, wedged between Japan and Korea. Now: well above average, well above both Korea and Japan. So, overall, either neutral (numeracy), or slight improvement (literacy) or substantial improvements (computers). Should I dare to conclude that the most improvement the US workers have shown was in the area most relevant for 21st century? [1] https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/piaac/current_results.asp https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/piaac/current_results.asp [2] http://www.oecd.org/skills/piaac/Country%20note%20-%20United%20States.pdf http://www.oecd.org/skills/piaac/Country%20note%20-%20United... [3] https://www.oecd.org/skills/piaac/publications/countryspecificmaterial/PIAAC_Country_Note_USA.pdf https://www.oecd.org/skills/piaac/publications/countryspecif...