4 ms·
There is no way that digital maps are anywhere near as practical, let alone more practical, yet. Digital maps: * rely on precious battery charge and weight *
by chrisseaton 7y ago
There is no way that digital maps are anywhere near as practical, let alone more practical, yet.
Digital maps:
* rely on precious battery charge and weight
* aren't very robust
* are extremely hard to use in the dark or with night vision
* can't be cut and folded into something small and light enough to hold in a hand
* when portable aren't large enough for displaying on a table or wall for people to gather around
- jacquesm 7y agoI was with you until the 'extremely hard to use in the dark or with night vision' because that is just about the only time they work much better than paper ones. But maps of all sorts are a dying breed, the bulk of the uses for maps were to find directions and turn-by-turn voice navigation has made the map component pretty much optional.
- chrisseaton 7y agoWhat displays do you use for in the dark? For paper you can shine a pin-point of green light and read it. That works for old-style LCD like a CASIO watch but I've not seen it work for a display designed to be backlit like a tablet. And you'd need a specially adapted display that used an IR backlight to use with night vision - I haven't seen something like that in practice. My smart watch has a night vision mode, but that's an LCD.
- jacquesm 7y agoAnything with a backlight. As for night vision, you mean when wearing vision enhancement optics? I did not fully understand you the first time, I thought you meant night vision as in 'night adapted eyes', where you'd lower the intensity as much as possible not to ruin your night vision. Not sure what the implications would be for electronically enhanced optics but if they use a display you could of course put the map straight on the display?
- chrisseaton 7y agoYeah I meant image intensifying optics. They're usually not digital unfortunately - they're analog - so you can't easily use them to look at digital image. And how are you going to take a compass bearing off an image being beamed straight into your eyes? And the problem with a digital map with a backlight is it lights you up like a beacon!
- jacquesm 7y agoOk, so in that situation something like e-ink might work?
- chrisseaton 7y agoYeah I guess so... apart from all the other downsides about size and robustness and things.
- jacquesm 7y agoE-ink is used in the Amazon Kindle's which take quite a bit of abuse and run just about forever on a battery charge. Of course all the usual comparisons between paper and technology still hold. There was a cartoon on that subject where they re-invented paper as an improvement on the laptop. 'Can be read in full sunlight', 'lasts for 100's of years on a single charge', 'can be burned safely in a pinch' and so on.
- rtkwe 7y agoI'd hate to try to pan and zoom on a map to try to navigate using an e-ink kindle with the refresh rate and flashing it's just barely usable as an ebook reader with page flips but anything interactive like scrolling on a page is pretty bad the few times I've tried.
- jacquesm 7y agoTry panning and zooming on a piece of paper... that's the benchmark here. I've had the pleasure of toting along a couple of kilos of maps of all the roads in Europe for years, I would not part with my TomTom for the best set of maps and the most elegant of night lights.
- coldtea 7y ago>What displays do you use for in the dark? For paper you can shine a pin-point of green light and read it. That works for old-style LCD like a CASIO watch but I've not seen it work for a display designed to be backlit like a tablet. Why do you need to shine light on a backlight? You can read it directly at night. >And you'd need a specially adapted display that used an IR backlight to use with night vision - I haven't seen something like that in practice. My smart watch has a night vision mode, but that's an LCD. Who, aside the army uses night vision?
- chrisseaton 7y ago> Why do you need to shine light on a backlight? You can read it directly at night. You can't use a backlight at night - you'd light yourself up like a beacon, and destroy your night vision adaptation.
- coldtea 7y agoIf it's about reading the map while navigating through the night in unknown territory in some emergency situation (lost in the woods?), I'd see where that would be a problem. Otherwise, I wouldn't go trekking/hiking at night either. Who does, so that that "map reading at night while maintaining night vision adaptation" to be a real non-outlier concern? If the use case is reading a map at a campsite, e.g. to prepare for tomorrow's hike, then the "night vision adaptation" should not be that important, and a backlit map device would do just fine. And you can have the screen at low brightness and not mess (or not mess much) with your night vision adaptation. Where do you napkin-estimate the percentage of people in the venn diagram AND of "uses maps", "need to read them at night", "need to maintain night vision adaptation while doing so", "has some night vision contraption to be able to read things they shine light on"?
- fabi2607 7y ago> Who does, so that that "map reading at night while maintaining night vision adaptation" to be a real non-outlier concern? Anyone doing alpine climbing will at some point start in the dark and/or return in the dark.
- r00fus 7y agoAre you in or simulating tactical conditions (to not give away your position)? If so - definitely paper + low intensity light. Otherwise, why is backlit an issue?
- allovernow 7y agoYou also can't trivially write on them. And imo it's easier to unfold a full sized map which immediately displays a wide area, to get your bearings, as opposed to having to zoom/pan on a digital map. Minor inconveniences but arguably a smoother experience. Of course when I sat digital map I'm pretty much referring to Google maps on a phone.
- growlist 7y agoI'd dispute this. I built a vector tile package out of OpenStreetMap a couple of years ago. This gives you offline building level mapping for the entire globe on an SD card, and can be displayed on a smartphone app. Whilst OSM isn't perfect and coverage is variable, one would have to get pretty far off the beaten track for it not to be of at least some practical use. So with this capability all you need is a charged phone and you can travel anywhere in the world knowing you have at least some sort of mapping even without a network connection. I suspect one would need a truck to transport the equivalent in paper maps.
- chrisseaton 7y agoWhat are you disputing about the arguments I made though? There's no point having the whole world on an SD card if you can't see the device at night, can't see it through your optics, and you can't display the map on a wall or a table for everyone to get around.
- growlist 7y agoOk but I'd say your headline isn't supported, i.e. 'There is no way that digital maps are anywhere near as practical, let alone more practical, yet.' - it's possible that all of the things you said are true, and that it is still more practical to use a digital map due to the disadvantages of paper maps i.e. fixed scale, inability to restyle or interrogate data on the fly, data currency, etc. And I think the example I gave is pretty compelling - put a dataset like the one I created on your phone, and all you have to worry about is keeping your phone charged in order to have mapping anywhere in the world, or carry a battery charging brick. There's a pretty huge gulf between the inconvenience of having to carry a battery brick versus a truck full of paper maps. The range of activities where the arguments you made hold versus those in which they are not of concern is becoming ever narrower - I'd struggle to think of much beyond recreation/extreme environments/military examples, and these are very much a minority compared to the rest of the digital mapping world. Don't get me wrong, I love paper maps too and have seen some pretty amazing examples - in the atrium of one facility I visited they had a two-storey high printed OS style map that was quite something - but the world has moved on. Perhaps e-ink displays will marry the two back together at some point.
- marcosdumay 7y agoPaper maps: * weight a lot more than digital * aren't robust to water, dirty, or even manipulation * require extra equipment to read on the dark * can be cut and folded, but lose usefulness on the process (I really don't get your claim that cell phones can't be hold in a hand) But that last point is spot on. Ditto for the people talking about writing on the map (digital could improve on this front). Anyway navigating a paper map requires some careful folding and unfolding that is quite slow, and you must carefully select what maps you'll bring every time, while for digital maps you just bring the entire continent. I don't see how one can declare any of them a clear win. The answer depends too much on your use case.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> aren't robust to water, dirty, or even manipulation You just laminate them.
- JustSomeNobody 7y agoAnd while they're at it, they should laminate their phone because it's not robust to water, dirt or even manipulation either. I know, I know, IP ratings. Okay... good luck.
- altec3 7y agoThe paper maps we use for multiday rafting trips are all waterproof. The thing will sit in the water in the bottom of your boat all day, then you throw it in the sand. It gets a little patina but has no problem with dirt/sand/water. Totally agree that neither digital nor paper maps is a clear winner. Each use case has different requirements and sometimes digital is better and sometimes paper is.
- potta_coffee 7y agoLaminate your map and use dry-erase map pens. I did it for years in the dirtiest, wettest environments possible. A typical cell phone wouldn't last hours, much less a day.
- hadlock 7y agoBoats have been carrying waterproof paper maps for decades, and for thousands of years before that carried vellum maps with waterproof ink. I have waterproof maps on my boat, the physical maps are required by the US Coast Guard. You do not need extra equipment to read in the dark, you just need to not be standing next to a street lamp. Your eyes adjust quite well. If the moon is out you can read a map with sunglasses on. The moon is plenty bright enough to cast shadows and read by if there are no external light sources nearby. If you use paper maps for any period of time, folding them becomes second nature, this is like saying that reading books takes too long compared to watching movies because you have to learn to read. On boats, navigational maps are rolled and there is dedicated space for unrolling them. Not all maps are used in the backcountry. Also maps come in bound formats called atlases which are quite convenient. Also Mapscos. I feel like this post was written by someone who grew up in a post google maps world.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> Boats have been carrying waterproof paper maps for decades I didn't argue that they weren't waterproof. I laminate all my maps. I know they can be waterproof. > You do not need extra equipment to read in the dark Fundamentally, you're going to need a torch or image intensification on occasion. There can be not enough moonlight to read a map to any extent. > If you use paper maps for any period of time, folding them becomes second nature Yes that's what I argued was a benefit of them - that they can be folded easily. > On boats, navigational maps are rolled and there is dedicated space for unrolling them Yes that's what I argued was a benefit of them - that they can be displayed on a table. > Not all maps are used in the backcountry. Yes, I argued an advantage is being able to put them on the wall. > I feel like this post was written by someone who grew up in a post google maps world. I've spent hundreds of days operating by map alone all around the world. So, no. I feel like you read my comment and somehow got the opposite understanding of every aspect. I was arguing that paper is better, and you've come in said no actually paper is better?