8 ms·
How Fritzing is killing itself
- allan_golds 7y agoGot a warning about this link from two browsers.
- mikl 7y agoA button labelled “Download” that is in actuality a “Donate” button that takes you to PayPal, that’s pretty scummy, probably even illegal some places. Glad I don’t use Fritzing.
- tptacek 7y agoWhere exactly do you think a button labeled "Download" that detours you through a Donation flow is illegal?
- glofish 7y agoWould you feel the same way if the site implemented a feature where if you clicked any link it would first detour you through a donation flow? Say the link said Tutorial or Documentation but when clicked it would go to Donate instead... The point the OP makes is that when you ask for donation the button should say Donate and not Download.
- tptacek 7y agoI didn't ask how the parent comment felt. I asked where exactly this flow might be illegal. If you want the subtext laid bare, I think it's pretty clear that I doubt it's illegal anywhere.
- glofish 7y agoIncidentally, I was asking you specifically how you felt about it, not the parent or the OP. Also, in addition, the "how you feel about it" does not really mean emotionally, it means what is your opinion on systematically mislabeling links. In my opinion, trying to hide the freely available version of open-source code is not a "crime" but it is unethical and very likely breaks the spirit as well as the requirements of the open-source license. Thus I think what the OP means is that it is "illegal" in the sense of breaking the license and it is unethical in how it misleads you.
- tptacek 7y ago"Probably even illegal some places" clearly means that it's actually illegal somewhere. I'd like to know where they think that is. That's my entire engagement with this thread.
- myrryr 7y agoIt could be in New Zealand. The Consumer Guarantee act may trip it up, as could our advertising laws. Ah, it is the fair trading act. here it is.... https://www.consumerprotection.govt.nz/general-help/common-consumer-issues/misleading-prices-or-advertising/ https://www.consumerprotection.govt.nz/general-help/common-c... NZ has a LOT more protection than the US does. This may fall under bait advertising.
- jiofih 7y agoIt’s not a stretch to imagine it being framed as fraud for false representation, or at a minimum infringing customer protection laws (not a crime). What bugs you?
- EricE 7y ago>I didn't ask how the parent comment felt. There's your problem - expecting people to be rational and not emotional :/
- mikl 7y agoClicking this button tricks the user into visiting PayPal, sending along that the user came from Fritzing.org, without the user’s consent. That could be construed as a GDPR violation. Additionally, it might be against some consumer protection laws, false advertising and somesuch. IANAL, obviously.
- tptacek 7y agoI guess I'm not seeing how that logic doesn't make almost every <a> tag a possible GDPR violation.
- bootloop 7y agoIs it a bug maybe? When you go to the page and select an amount of money it will change the button text to "Pay&Download" instead of just "Download". So maybe the default was just meant to send you to the file.
- teraflop 7y agoThe option to download without paying was deliberately removed: https://github.com/fritzing/fritzing-app/issues/3548#issuecomment-545421808 https://github.com/fritzing/fritzing-app/issues/3548#issueco...
- bootloop 7y agoThanks! For sure a list of real problems but I am wondering if one time donations vs a solid income stream can solve this.
- JohnFen 7y agoFritzing and I never got along very well, but if we did, this sort of nonsense would change that.
- justinjlynn 7y agoI've never understood software engineers and organisations who contribute their code to the open source and free software worlds and then think they're owed compensation for it. We're writing this code because we need this code and think others might also need it and we have empathy for them and we benefit from their empathy for us - that's why we share. That's why we're here. Why do you share? Why are you here? It might be an unpopular opinion but - to all you disgruntled open source/free software developers threatening to take their code closed via licencing shitfuckery ala "Commons Clause" nonsense and/or engaged in shady shit like this: If you feel you're owed compensation for your time beyond other people using and building on your code - this is not the place for you and your toxicity makes the open source and free software world a worse place. Please leave quietly and quickly. Stop saying "uncompensated time" - nobody owes you anything. You don't owe anyone else anything either - leave and let other, more reasonable, people maintain and carry on with the code you once freely gave - just as they should, if they find it useful. That's how it's supposed to work - that's how it should work. Thank you very much for your time and code. It is deeply appreciated; now go away and stop being an asshole.
- JohnFen 7y agoYeah, I'm ambivalent about this issue. I've been significantly contributing to the OSS world for a very, very long time. I never did so with the expectation that I would see a dime from that activity -- that's not the reason I put the effort in. So, my instinct is to say that OSS devs knew what deal was from the very start, and if they're not OK with "unpaid work", then they should stop doing it rather than complain. On the other hand, OSS has become critical infrastructure, and as such, the stability that comes with people being able to earn a living with it seems like a desirable thing. So, I don't know. I think there are valid points all around on this. That said, I also think that what happened with Fritzing is simply wrong regardless.
- kiba 7y agoOpen source does not have to be charity. You are allowed to sell OSS. It's not even against the spirit.
- lwb 7y agoNot sure how others are viewing this page -- I get NET::ERR_CERT_AUTHORITY_INVALID and a big warning page.
- kohtatsu 7y agoYour certificate trust store doesn't have Lets Encrypt yet.
- lwb 7y agoThat's not it, I can access my personal site that uses Let's Encrypt.
- dredmorbius 7y agoSome older UAs / OSs seem to be lacking certs being used in recent days. I ran into this accessing Wikipedia from Chrome / Android 5.0.2 a few days ago (posted on HN). Wikipedia chained in an older cert to address this. Android's failure to update older clients is catching up with it. Devices remain usable, but are not supported. Mine was obsolete at purchase, and never had an OS upgrade, fuck you very much, Samsung. (Unlike free software, this was a bought-and-paid-for device. I still got screwed.)
- crazypython 7y agoEh-- this is completely allowed by open-source licenses. If you don't need the library, don't use it. If you do need the library, download it another way (it's legal) or pay for it.