6 ms·
I've worked in government, late startup and corporate roles. There isn't anything fundamentally broken about government. The difference is operate vs. build. G
by Spooky23 7y ago
I've worked in government, late startup and corporate roles. There isn't anything fundamentally broken about government. The difference is operate vs. build.
Government is usually optimized around operational activity, and it usually does so very well from the perspective of how the organization is designed. Things get weird because priorities are driven by external mandate. DMV issues licenses, taxes are collected, social services are delivered. The downside of scaled operations is that changes are difficult and expensive. The exception is when there is growth -- the government is good at borrowing money and good at building stuff.
Large corporations aren't that much different. If anything, the average medium/large corporation has fewer controls and is less competent at a given task that a .gov organization would be, but delivers each marginal task at a lower cost and less red tape. (aka compliance requirements)
Startups are different. They are built to build and tend to do the minimum viable activity and are usually a big mess operationally.
- xkde 7y ago> the government is good at borrowing money and good at building stuff MNLARS: “Hold my beer.”
- chongli 7y agoI think where people get frustrated about government is that they expect it to respond to changes in society and technology. They see inertia and think inefficiency. I think that’s missing the point entirely. What governments offer is stability. “Inertia” is a feature. If governments swung around rapidly the way tech trends change then it would cause tremendous damage to people’s lives and to the economy as a whole.
- seph-reed 7y agoWell, it's not a zero sum thing. Backwards compatibility can mean stability without inertia. We can get pretty much all the best features from start-ups, gov, capitalism, and socialism at the same time. Too often we focus on the outsides of a venn diagram, and fail to invest proper effort where the overlap is. IMO, the part in the middle done well is more than enough for a good world, and the bits on the outside are just flavors.
- wvenable 7y agoGovernments, especially in some areas, are also often starved. They're trying to do work without the sufficient resources to do their work effectively. Companies in that state usually end up in a death spiral and fail. Often this ineffectiveness is misconstrued as incompetence and used as evidence to further decrease the resources available.
- tabtab 7y agoIndeed! Voters want great gov't services but also hate paying taxes. These are often contradictory. Sometimes you get what you pay for and can't vote for a magic lunch. People complain about how slow the DMV is, but if you ask them if they want their car registration fees increased to reduce waits, most will say "no".
- mcrad 7y agoHate is a strong word - perhaps these voters you speak of simply don't feel there is a very strong correlation between amount of taxes/fees paid, and services rendered.
- stretchwithme 7y agoAnd many who talk about how we should gladly pay our taxes get or figure they would get more than they pay in if everybody would happily pay as much as they possibly could. Not that the amount of taxes paid ever stopped a government from trying borrow and spend way more than that.
- tabtab 7y agoRe: Not that the amount of taxes paid ever stopped a government from trying borrow and spend way more than that. Government, taxes, and private industry are all tools of civilization. Tools are imperfect and the human managers & users are imperfect. One has to monitor all of them to keep them in decent working order. They won't just automatically run in an optimum mode if citizens don't keep a critical eye on them all.
- Invictus0 7y agoWhy can't both be true? Stability in some things, rapid response to change in others?
- chongli 7y agoThey are in some ways. Governments can respond very quickly to natural disasters or wars, for example. Sometimes they don’t, of course, and they’re roundly criticized for it. And sometimes governments respond rapidly in very negative ways, such as when the Nazis passed the Reichstag fire decree [1]. This was the first major step to elevate Hitler to dictatorship. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reichstag_Fire_Decree https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reichstag_Fire_Decree
- gry 7y agoThis is captured in the Layers of Time diagram[1]. The tension fashion to nature is at diametric odds with time and responsibility; governance is squarely inbetwixt. https://media.longnow.org/files/2/LayersOfTime-simplNEW.jpg https://media.longnow.org/files/2/LayersOfTime-simplNEW.jpg [1] http://longnow.org/about/ http://longnow.org/about/
- inciampati 7y agoAt many scales, nature outpaces any human activity. Even fashion isn't as rapid as a plague of locusts. I think this figure inappropriately separates humans from nature.
- kiliantics 7y agoInertia is far from a feature when it comes to our biggest problems today, particularly climate change. This is going to cause a lot of damage, it already has.
- paulddraper 7y ago> There isn't anything fundamentally broken about government. The government is simply the extreme version of "too big to fail." And governments should be treated as "too big to fail" entities; a failed government is a very, very bad thing. But it's also inevitable that government has the same problems as any organization with that label: misalignment of incentives, stagnation, tendency to corruption, reduced customer choice, inefficiency, etc.
- hanniabu 7y agoWould be great if there was an efficiency task force directed at digitizing, streamlining, and optimizing government functions, communication, and programs.
- danhon 7y agoYep, please check out: http://codeforamerica.org http://codeforamerica.org https://18f.gsa.gov/ https://18f.gsa.gov/ https://usds.gov/ https://usds.gov/
- motohagiography 7y ago> The difference is operate vs. build. This is so key. I do a lot of government consulting and one of the iceberg issues right now is how to reconcile devops, whose economics are designed to facilitate revenue growth, with fixed budget public service horizons of a decade or more. The whole public enterprise model was up front costs for expensive developers, then offload it to cheaper operations teams on shared production infrastructure for long haul. The unspoken implication of devops/CICD/cloud/agile, etc, is that you have developers available to roll out patches and features, which sends the long term cost of the service multiplying. Imagine retaining your development consultants and a product team past the 2-3 dev years through the 10+ years of production, with no revenue growth and more probably, budget cuts. The table in the article provides a good overview, with the caveat that defence is not normal public services in government. Even many bank architects aren't close enough to the code of their services to meaningfully reason about what's going on. Tech is necessarily the expression of economic relationship models, where if you don't have a grasp of them, implementing tech without a view to the economics is going to sink some ships.
- secabeen 7y agoThe other big issue I see in government projects is that government and other public sector organizations have a mandate to serve all citizens, even the expensive ones. Startups can choose to ignore the 20% of their potential market that is expensive to serve.
- motohagiography 7y agoThe 80/20 ratio is a huge thing, good call. Often, no service at all, or unusable crap service for everyone is politically preferable to leaving anyone out. That play of getting those %80 features into production and leaving the %20 people to fight it out afterwards as tech and feature debt is standard product management, but it takes extra finesse in govt. I have seen some great success stories. Seemingly simple things like QR codes for game tags, federated logins for citizens, online license and permit renewals, a city parking app, pothole reporting. This project is really interesting to me: https://www.open311.org/learn/ https://www.open311.org/learn/
- pdonis 7y ago> Government is usually optimized around operational activity, and it usually does so very well from the perspective of how the organization is designed. First, I think this depends a lot on your locality. I think you'll find a lot of places where people are nowhere near as complimentary about basic government services like DMV as you seem to be. Second, I think this depends a lot on the type of service and how large a segment of the population needs it. Everybody gets driver's licenses, so there is a limit to how much suckitude the DMV can have before it becomes a political issue. But many social services are only used by a small fraction of the population, so unless you are one of those people or know one of them closely enough, you won't be aware of how much those services suck, and if you are aware of it, you will have a very hard time getting other people, who don't use the services and don't know anyone who does, to care. And the people who do need those services are usually those who have little if any ability to push back at suckitude. Finally, I think you are ignoring the huge difference in how the incentives of a government organization are determined, as compared with those of a corporation. A corporation is a business: its fundamental incentive is to make money. Corporations that don't do that go out of business. A government organization, however, has whatever incentives were put in place by the political process that created it (and those incentives can gradually change as the political process changes); and the one constant about government organizations is that, once they're created, they never go away.
- testvox 7y agoDo those services suck because of operational problems or were they designed to suck? Its not clear from your answer how much blame you are putting on operational issues and how much blame (if any) you are putting on the misaligned incentives between governments and the people who use their services.
- pdonis 7y ago> Do those services suck because of operational problems or were they designed to suck? For the worst ones (the ones that only a small fraction of people, most of whom are indigent, use), neither. They suck because of misaligned incentives, but the systems were not "designed" to suck; they were designed in response to political pressure from voters, who are mostly ignorant of the misaligned incentives and believe that, if they vote for a system that will "help the poor", for example, that the system that results will actually do that. And since most of them never have to interact with the system directly, they don't realize that in fact it is not doing what they voted for.
- ngcc_hk 7y agoMight be and might be not. Many revolution started on country level. In fact the whole word “revolution” are from that. And some change like Roland and Margaret started or even Chrysler or may be Apple 2nd life is how a large org can change course. It is by definition larger. But may be not so different when an idea caught up, you do not know the end but still try. There are many government process, role, citizen ... within one Gov Read the 3 lens approach.
- Janeman544 7y agoThe big difference between Government and Startups is the fact that Governments by definition are monopolies. You gotta totally leave the country/state/city if you are unhappy with them. Startups die pretty quickly creating signals as to what one needs to do to stay alive. Governments on other hand can even kill people and nothing much changes. Of course you can see bad government vs good governments at national level and judge them by migration of people.