7 ms·
What I’ve always found amazing is how cheap dental and eye care is in comparison to other types of medical care. The fact that you can get laser surgery in your
by rayiner 7y ago
What I’ve always found amazing is how cheap dental and eye care is in comparison to other types of medical care. The fact that you can get laser surgery in your eyes for a couple of thousand dollars is incredible, given that a diagnostic test like an MRI can often cost that much. Clearly there is room for competition to reduce costs.
Clearly that doesn’t work for emergency services. But is there room to distinguish emergency from non-emergency services? I had surgery for a deviated septum. I don’t know what it cost, but if I had an incentive I could’ve price shopped for it. There are a lot of non-emergency procedures (colonoscopies, hip replacements, knee surgery, etc.) that could be subject to competition.
Also, the comparison to Singapore’s health outcomes is a bit odd:
> The result is not only 77% less spending than the United States but also, as Bloomberg Businessweek reports, one of the healthiest populations in the world.
Fun fact: Life expectancy for Asians in the US is 86 years (almost 90 in New Jersey!), quite a bit longer than the 82 years in Singapore.
- criddell 7y ago> if I had an incentive I could’ve price shopped for it In my experience hospitals and surgery centers can't or won't tell you what something will cost up front.
- ska 7y agoThat is one of the main points of the article.
- maximente 7y agomost in the US won't, although some do e.g. https://surgerycenterok.com/pricing/ https://surgerycenterok.com/pricing/
- gremlinsinc 7y agoI'm pretty sure though they have to supply an 'itemized' list if you ask for one, which you can contest anything on the list and a lot of times take them to court over if they don't budge. Often they will because they know $35 for an ibuprofin is absurd but most people don't think they can win against a big bad hospital.
- mikequinlan 7y agoIn the United States each provider has up to 12 months to provide a bill and nobody is required to tell you who all of the providers were.
- pfranz 7y agoHere's how it went when I tried to do it upfront. My wife was pregnant, so we had 9 months of routine, scheduled visits. I asked "how much will this cost ignoring any unexpected costs." My insurance had a helpful PDF showing $650 as an out of pocket example with an asterisk saying not to use this number for reference. Reading up, some places offer a "package deal"--our's didn't. I was told to call the doctor's office and write down their itemized list of procedures. Then call their billing office to get an itemized list of billing codes. Then call my insurance to get the out of pocket cost. The final cost was a few multiples of that cited value (although there were additional, unexpected costs).
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoIn my experience during a time when I had no insurance, they often can't even tell you after the fact. Everything has to go through a dozen or more layers of bureaucracy before you get a bill.
- georgeecollins 7y agoI agree with everything this article suggests, but to be fair to hospitals, they can't really tell you what some procedures will cost for obvious reasons. A delivery may ordinarily cost $x, but if a caesarean is required it may be $x + $y.. etc. A car mechanic will give you an estimate for what it will cost you to fix something, and then call you if it turns out to be more expensive. In a delivery (or a surgery) they can't really ask you if you are OK with an additional cost that may be required, they have to just do it. However, a hospital could provide a list of prices that are commonly billed. What a list of prices would do is give you a sense if one hospital costs a lot more than another in general. If you knew you might change which hospital you go to and.. you know markets etc.
- jdmichal 7y agoYour first example is funny, considering that the hospital where my son was delivered sent us a letter about a month before his due date with an estimate of the cost for both normal delivery and caesarean. Of course it didn't cover every possible contingency... That's what an "estimate" means by definition. But that doesn't mean that it's impossible or even unreasonable to provide a baseline price, along with some of the more common events that can modify that price.
- washadjeffmad 7y agoMost billing departments won't provide prices without the billing codes for the procedures. How do you get the billing codes? You have to see a doctor and get a treatment plan. How do you find out how much seeing the doctor is going to cost to get your treatment plan? You call the billing department for a quote. We went through this during a very stressful time when my SO found a lump in her breast, and it took the kindness of a nurse that worked between the doctors and the billing department to give us a possible list to get a ballpark of what to expect. She called us after hours to tell us because she didn't want to get in trouble with her manager. Once we had that information, we called several hospitals for quotes and ended up being offered 40-70% discounts. It went from thousands to hundreds to ultimately having some of the tests comped... all because we had a little information and asked the right questions about the process. This is a disgrace and not how you treat people's health.
- cheald 7y ago> But is there room to distinguish emergency from non-emergency services? There absolutely must be, IMO. Emergency care is what insurance _should_ be for - the stuff you can't plan for, must have, and can't comparison shop for. IIRC, emergency healthcare spending accounts for around 2% of our annual totals. I just don't think we can justify our full medical pricing system on the basis of emergency care needs alone. For everything else, though, I'd be much happier if I could just have a price list up front and shop for the provider of my choice. I did it with Lasik, and it was easily the best medical experience I've ever had, not just in terms of "knowing what I'll pay", but the outfit I had it done by was actually competing to win my business. I felt like a customer they wanted to win, not just an account number that they were going to throw at my insurance company. By means of analogy, we carry car insurance in the case of accidents, but we don't expect car insurance to pay to refill our gas tank (even though gasoline has a lower price elasticity of demand than heathcare!) or pay for oil changes. Food has a lower price elasticity of demand than healthcare, too, but it's still cheap and we don't carry grocery insurance. Insurance makes sense to cover the unforeseen and unexpected. Why do we obfuscate prices and billing practices for routine, elective, and foreseeable care? "Don't have insurance cover routine care" is obviously insane if pricing were to remain unchanged, but I absolutely think the fundamental problem with the affordability of healthcare in the US isn't the availability (or lack thereof) of insurance, but the way we've completely separated services from prices. Hiding the prices doesn't mean they don't exist and don't get charged - they just eliminate the forces that would otherwise exert downwards price pressure. If we could get pricing transparency on everything, and then see providers start competing on uninsured pricing, I think that could open the door to "actual insurance" plans (at far lower cost than exists today), while actually reducing prices for everything else across the board.
- mdorazio 7y agoThe problem with this is in how you classify different types of care. For example, is end of life care voluntary and thus should not be covered by insurance or is it emergency? If you say it’s the former and go to a national healthcare setup, people lose their minds shouting about death panels. If you say it’s the latter, healthcare costs go up 10-12%.
- droithomme 7y ago> a diagnostic test like an MRI can often cost that much In non-emergency situations where you can do advance planning MRIs are cheap. It all started around 15 years ago when some college professor set up a company a2zimaging I think it was called that sold idle MRI capacity to anyone. I believe he eventually shut it down but there's now several other companies willing to do a full MRI for anywhere from $320 to $1500. Google "cheap mri" and choose one. If you are brought into a hospital after a car accident and use their scanner without making arrangements, you can end up paying $10-$20k for the exact same scan.
- jayess 7y agoThere are also state laws requiring a "certificate of need" that artificially limits the number of MRI machines, keeping the cost high.
- nwah1 7y agoBut are "Asians" who live in the US a representative sample? Or might there be some distinguishing characteristics of immigrant families, compared to those in their home countries? Also, Singapore has two main ethnic and socioeconomic groups with different culture, cuisine, genetics, religious habits, and so on, which is almost certainly not the same composition as "Asian-Americans" however that is defined.
- jayess 7y agoThis is why direct primary care is becoming a thing. Doctors are opting out of the insurance system in order to see fewer patients and reduce overhead. For $50-$75 a month, you get unlimited access to your physician, including via video call, access to wholesale meds and labs, and reduced cost diagnostics.
- pfranz 7y agoThese costs and incentives are often ridiculous. I got a Teledoc pamphlet from my insurance last year. Awesome! Often, when something happens or if I'm sick, I never know when to go to the ER, Urgent Care, or make an appointment. If I feel terrible for 5 days, should I wait it out or see someone? Especially with young kids, I've made the wrong call in both directions. It turns out a video/phone appointment is way more than seeing someone in person. I figured my use-case wasn't what they were targeting and couldn't imagine a scenario I would prefer it.
- thrower123 7y agoThe price differential for the same procedures depending on whether I go to an urgent care center, or my primary care, or a hospital ER is what makes me insane. Urgent care is a flat fee $50, whatever they do, whereas the hospital starts at something like $800, and goes up from there. I forget what the primary care costs, although I think it is more than urgent care; I can't get an appointment with my primary care without a couple months of lead time, so it's pretty much moot.
- tsimionescu 7y agoAlternatively, you could have a system like a lot of the rest of the world, where medical care is simply provided as needed, hospitals are public entities, and health-care has no price (since there is no market), just a cost, that is payed for from taxes. This way, all the money going into the system is actually spent on healthcare, instead of having profit extracted from it. You also get rid of the stress of money from the already bad situations of major disease, and the complex bureaucracy that insurance brings with it. Edit: tone and some extra details.
- watertom 7y agoBut then someone can't build a total useless and redundant service and get rich.
- rayiner 7y ago> Alternatively, you could have a system like a lot of the rest of the world, where medical care is simply provided as needed, hospitals are public entities, and health-care has no price (since there is no market), just a cost, that is payed for from taxes. Almost no countries have such a model. The closest one is the UK. But the U.K. still rations care aggressively to control costs. (The government uses formulas to decide whether the benefit from a treatment is worth the cost.) In Germany, where the government subsidizes multi-payer insurance, more than 2/3 of hospitals are private. Even in Sweden, which had a system like you’re describing until 1995, more than a quarter of hospitals are private.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pdoege 7y ago> Clearly there is room for competition to reduce costs Unless you know the average outcomes and standard deviations choosing procedures based on cost is suboptimal. I've never met a pre-op individual that knew how to properly choose LASIK procedures. They all use price signaling and word of mouth from post-ops. The same is true for me in medical areas where I do not have expertise. I think that reducing procedure selection to cost and expecting competition to fix it is an error.