9 ms·
Extreme Nationalism was and is the symptom of the time. Plus Nationalism is perfectly normal as long as it doesn't go extreme.
by markus_zhang 7y ago
Extreme Nationalism was and is the symptom of the time. Plus Nationalism is perfectly normal as long as it doesn't go extreme.
- bduerst 7y agoPatriotism is perfectly normal, nationalism is not. You could argue that nationalism is an extreme version of patriotism, being that it takes a love and faith for one's country and uses it at the expense of others.
- incompatible 7y agoWhen you look at human history, I don't think that there's anything particularly bad about the present. You could even argue that times have rarely been better, as far as the historical record goes.
- PavlovsCat 7y agoI don't compare with (our stories of) the past, I compare with the faint inkling I have of what ought to be, the injustice and squandered potential I see right now. Furthermore there is the road we're on and the cliff it ends at: the concentration of wealth doesn't let up, the ability to think and even feel seems to drastically decline before our eyes, the research for control and destruction of humans goes on, and all of that can come home to roost in a very short amount of time. I think it's a bit like sitting on the Titanic and saying "the nice meal and the music we enjoy now is so much better than when we stood at the harbour in pouring rain, before we boarded this ship". edit: Heh, I guess some people thing pretending that isn't so will get them a seat at the table. There won't even be a table. > The frightening coincidence of the modern population explosion with the discovery of technical devices that, through automation, will make large sections of the population 'superfluous' even in terms of labor, and that, through nuclear energy, make it possible to deal with this twofold threat by the use of instruments beside which Hitler's gassing installations look like an evil child's fumbling toys, should be enough to make us tremble. -- Hannah Arendt, "Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil" > Now the police dreams that one look at the gigantic map on the office wall should suffice at any given moment to establish who is related to whom and in what degree of intimacy; and, theoretically, this dream is not unrealizable although its technical execution is bound to be somewhat difficult. If this map really did exist, not even memory would stand in the way of the totalitarian claim to domination; such a map might make it possible to obliterate people without any traces, as if they had never existed at all. -- Hannah Arendt, "The Origins of Totalitarianism" > If machines produce everything we need, the outcome will depend on how things are distributed. Everyone can enjoy a life of luxurious leisure if the machine-produced wealth is shared, or most people can end up miserably poor if the machine-owners successfully lobby against wealth redistribution. So far, the trend seems to be toward the second option, with technology driving ever-increasing inequality. -- Stephen Hawking
- jacquesm 7y agoNationalism isn't normal, countries are a completely artificial construct. But it serves well as a way to get people to assign all kinds of emotions, positive ones to their flag and negative to everybody else's.
- maps 7y ago> Nationalism isn't normal, countries are a completely artificial construct. Compared to what? Being a primitive mammal? Sure you could claim that the 'nation' didn't exist long enough to support this but devotion to a local city or tribe feels the same to me.
- nostrademons 7y agoIf devotion to a local city or tribe is the same, then why is the Federal government at loggerheads with California over environmental regulations and immigration, and California is at loggerheads with SF over zoning policy and homelessness?
- shantly 7y agoIt does not follow from the assertion that devotion to a political unit of any size is a similar mindset or activity, that devotion to any one such thing means precisely identical devotion to all parts of whatever political hierarchy it may be a part of. Your objection doesn't make sense.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deogeo 7y agoMany things we hold very dear are artificial/somewhat arbitrary - that doesn't make them less valuable.
- mistermann 7y agoIt also allows a group of people to choose, to some degree, to live life in a certain way. Thinking negatively of other countries is not necessary, but if you personally choose to be my guest.
- thundergolfer 7y agoHaving read Orwell’s “Notes on Nationalism” essays literally yesterday, his voice is quite forcefully poking my brain as I read your comment. Orwell agreed that Nationalistic thinking was almost totally widespread through different peoples and times, but you appear to be saying that a “normal” amount is Ok which he would have fought passionately. Orwell wanted us to contend with the Nationalist inside us, and push them out. Just as we wouldn’t accept a “perfectly normal” amount of racism, don’t accept Nationalist feeling as in any way healthy.
- mistermann 7y agoRacism and nationalism seem extremely dissimilar to me.
- Spooky23 7y agoThey both boil down to “my tribe is better than yours”.
- mistermann 7y agoFor you perhaps, not for me. Are we just making up meanings for words on the fly now? It would be rather ironic if I was being downvoted for a lack of hate.
- Spooky23 7y agoMore lack of understanding I would guess. I upvoted your comment as it’s important to understand. Racism and nationalism aren’t about hate. They are about pride and superiority. Nationalism is often confused or manipulated as patriotism. Racism is often confused or manipulated as pride in culture or the past. The feeling of superiority enables other behaviors — people feel justified to take negative actions against other humans because they are lesser than them on some axis. These aren’t made up meanings.
- mistermann 7y ago
- squarefoot 7y agoThere's no such thing as normal nationalism, as nationalism is a form of extremism by itself, more accurately what the perfectly natural love everyone of us feels for his/hers own country becomes once filtered and distorted by propaganda with the purpose of making people do nasty things under the belief they're necessary for a bigger good. Try this test with some of the less extreme nationalists you know: show them a photo of planet Earth taken from space and tell them "this is my homeland. I love it and you should too", then watch their reaction. Some of them may agree, but most won't. The point is that planet Earth does indeed contain their entire homeland, but includes other countries too, which is what many people don't accept. This plain stupid test demonstrates how nationalism isn't about loving one's country rather than not loving other people ones.
- naxerda876 7y ago>this is my homeland Only an imperialist with global ambitions would claim the entire planet as his homeland. >includes other countries too, which is what many people don't accept You seem to be the one who cant accept that there are other countries that are not for you. Nationalists understand this quite well actually >nationalism isn't about loving one's country rather than not loving other people ones Wanting your nation to be sovereign and free of foreign influence is not the same thing as hating other countries like you insinuate. Was Gandhi evil because he was a nationalist? Was Nelsen Mandela? Was Crazy Horse?
- mistermann 7y ago> nationalism is a form of extremism by itself This doesn't make sense to me. Would a desire to paint my own house rather than my neighbor's be a form of extremism, or are you thinking about it on some other way than this? > more accurately what the perfectly natural love everyone of us feels for his/hers own country becomes once filtered and distorted by propaganda with the purpose of making people do nasty things under the belief they're necessary for a bigger good I accept that this is possible and has historical precedent, but I challenge you to produce any convincing evidence this is always the case. > Try this test with some of the less extreme nationalists you know: show them a photo of planet Earth taken from space and tell them "this is my homeland. I love it and you should too", then watch their reaction. Some of them may agree, but most won't. The point is that planet Earth does indeed contain their entire homeland, but includes other countries too, which is what many people don't accept. Have you literally done this, and literally observed that most people don't love planet Earth? I would pay money to see a performance like that in real life, it sounds utterly bizarre and fantastical. > This plain stupid test demonstrates how nationalism isn't about loving one's country rather than not loving other people ones. Even if you actually have conducted this test, saying this demonstrates your point is a stretch. I can easily think of a reason I would have a negative reaction to such a "test", my strong dislike for globalism advocates with their poorly thought out reasons for demanding I behave in a certain way - if I got an intuitive feel that this is what your game was, you would likely get an intuitive feel that I was displeased, but be careful what you attribute that feeling to. I would actually consider this a reasonably good example of a poorly thought out idea that I find annoying.