4 ms·
Not to nitpick, but the failure mechanism in the crash and what Walter was testing are slightly different. Fatigue failures like the one in the crash are from
by bumby 7y ago
Not to nitpick, but the failure mechanism in the crash and what Walter was testing are slightly different.
Fatigue failures like the one in the crash are from multiple sub-maximal loads (look up "S-N" curves for more info). In other words, fatigue comes from cycling lower loads many times on a part. Buckling calculations look for maximal load failures on a column (i.e. a single larger load event that can make it fail).
The link is a great example of a real world case study (and thank you for finding it!), and no doubt somebody was doing fatigue calculations on the jackscrew at Boeing as well. I just wanted to add a bit of nuance
- beerandt 7y ago>no doubt somebody was doing fatigue calculations I'm always surprised by the general publics' lack of awareness and understanding of fatigue. And then seeing the figurative lightbulb illuminate after asking them how they would break a metal clotheshanger, without any tools. Anyway, it may not have been his personal responsibility, but certainly fatigue must have been a significant consideration during design, since (afaik) it's most often the controlling factor in lifetime estimates for structural components in airframes. I would strongly assume the same would apply to a component who's expected failure mode might be buckling.
- digikata 7y agoTrue, the design is one important part, but the design can be 100% on, but the manufacturing and the operational inspections are important to present failures too. Variance from controlled manufacturing conditions can result in parts that basically look and perform ok at first, but are at risk of failing early, that's why aircraft have inspection schedules - that are sometimes increased due to increased cycles on some routes/airports. (and of course there is the case of the part being damaged somehow, where some of the other comments have linked cases where this happened catasropically).
- beerandt 7y agoHmmm... I'm not real familiar with that mass production qaqc. Is there a term that describes a minimum design spec (or similar aspect), that takes into account the actual manufacturing (and other) variances? I'm thinking that in construction, a rough equivalent would be a designs constructability / bidability review.
- bumby 7y agoI'm not sure what you're asking but there is term in manufacturing called DFM or design for manufacturability. Otherwise, design drawings are loaded with specs that call out design tolerances etc. QA and process control are used ensure these tolerances are met
- digikata 7y agoThe design may call out a specific material and how to manufacture it, say make this part out of 6061 Aluminum, and. mill it in this way. You can look up the standard properties of that material. But depending on how that material is worked, cut, bent etc, you would expect in come cases some changes in the material properties or just sensitivities to fatigue. E.g. if you cut a sharp corner into that metal, fatigue will increase in that corner over the life of the part, so maybe you specify rounded corner - but how much it makes a difference you won't do necessarily a whole specific detailed study on it unless its a critical part or corner. If it's milled, if the machine that day has a duller bit, maybe it heats up the part more, and the material properties shift a bit more due to the heating. All these and are controlled in the process, but are still little things lead to variation, and maybe the controls fail one day and some slightly different aluminum makes in into the process. For critical parts on the aircraft, there is the backup of inspecting for aspects like accelerated fatigue just for variation of manufacturing, of environmental contributors, etc. It's a lot like security defense in depth - many layers of protection for lives (and aircraft industry trustability linked to profitability too) at stake.
- WalterBright 7y ago> no doubt somebody was doing fatigue calculations on the jackscrew at Boeing as well. Yes, they were (the stress group). The airframe was designed for 62,000 hours of operation, then scrapped due to fatigue considerations. Fatigue was a bit of a black art at the time, with rules based on extensive testing and experience. It's much better understood today. Take a paper clip and bend it back and forth. Eventually, it will break. That's fatigue.
- lordnacho 7y ago> It's much better understood today. When I studied this it seemed to just be empirical, as in you calibrate some law to some measurements and use that to tell you when it is likely to fail. Has this changed?
- WalterBright 7y agoI simply heard it had gotten much better. I don't know the details, as I pivoted to programming.