4 ms·
Once a new plant is already constructed, shutting it down early would only make sense if the average generation price fell below the operating cost, excluding t
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
Once a new plant is already constructed, shutting it down early would only make sense if the average generation price fell below the operating cost, excluding the construction and decommissioning costs which by that point are already historical costs. Solar panels could be free and not be able to match that price, because they still require land and energy storage and labor to install and maintain, so the nuclear plant would still operate the full 40+ years and have that long to amortize the construction.
- pfdietz 7y agoAt least in the US, land is an negligible part of the cost of PV in most of the country. And here, many reactors have been having trouble meeting their operating costs, particularly if they encounter a major maintenance issue, or if they are smaller or not paired with other reactors to save on staffing. The remaining reactor at TMI was cash flow negative for six years before it was retired for being unprofitable. There is some reluctance on the part of utilities to shut down nuclear power plants because continuing to operate them allows decommissioning (and its costs) to be delayed.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> At least in the US, land is an negligible part of the cost of PV in most of the country. If you pick any one component of the overall cost it's small, but the panels themselves are already less than half the overall cost. Everything else adds up. And the everything else has stickier prices than the panels -- the price of the panels may get cut in half but the price per acre of land or the hourly wage for labor doesn't. > And here, many reactors have been having trouble meeting their operating costs, particularly if they encounter a major maintenance issue, or if they are smaller or not paired with other reactors to save on staffing. The remaining reactor at TMI was cash flow negative for six years before it was retired for being unprofitable. TMI is hardly the typical case. It's the one site to have screwed the pooch and lost a reactor. That harms their reputation and makes it cost more to buy insurance and borrow money, and doesn't lend itself to receiving any sympathy or leniency from the public or regulators etc. Their operating cost correspondingly exceeded the average. And it's true that operating multiple reactors on the same site significantly reduces operating costs, but that just argues in favor of opening new plants with multiple reactors on the same site. > There is some reluctance on the part of utilities to shut down nuclear power plants because continuing to operate them allows decommissioning (and its costs) to be delayed. Feature not bug. The net present cost of decommissioning goes down by a lot when you can push it out 40 years and collect interest on the money in the meantime.
- pfdietz 7y agoAll of what you say aside, nuclear still loses when compared to what solar and storage can reasonably be expected to cost. It makes absolutely no sense to build a new nuclear power plant now. It would be a way of destroying billions of dollars for no good reason.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoEven if solar and storage do actually turn out to be cheaper in the long term, that isn't the same thing as destroying the full amount of money you put into a nuclear plant. The amount of money you're out is only the difference between the initial cost and the price you can sell electricity at in competition with solar and storage. You could plausibly get back less than you put in but still get back 90% of it. And if that does happen, there is a good reason for it, which is that we're not actually sure that solar and storage will make it to that point, and there's a non-trivial chance that they don't. Or even if they do eventually, that they don't do so quickly. If we get a significant carbon tax before the existing fossil fuel generating plants are decommissioned then the price of electricity is going to rise significantly until their capacity is replaced. That could take 20 years or more. In the meantime that nuclear plant is more than paying for itself -- it could pay off its full capital cost in that time at the higher generation price -- so that by the time solar and storage gets cheaper the nuclear plant only has to cover its operating cost and continues to be cost competitive for the remainder of its operating life. It's basically a speculative investment against the chance that solar and storage don't get cheaper fast enough. You could lose some money, or you could win big if we get a carbon tax and the storage technology comes up short for a long period of time. Which also makes it a good hedge against investments in storage technologies.
- imtringued 7y agoI think you are not properly emphasizing the differences. A nuclear powerplant MUST run for more than 40 years. Renewable energy CAN run for more than 20 years but since costs are going down and efficiencies going up it makes more sense to upgrade your infrastructure. This is not a bug it's a feature.
- pfdietz 7y agoThis also means that when PV costs finally flatten out, there's a final cost reduction to be had from uncompressing their lifespan to the 40+ years nuclear is already counting on.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoNeither of those things are true. The reason you replace solar panels after 20 years rather than 40 is that they degrade and stop producing as much power. There is no option to run them for 40 years at their original generation capacity. The alternative is to keep using the old panels but add more panels on top of that to make up the difference. But then you still have to buy some new panels and on top of that you need to use more land instead of reusing the existing land, which may not be any cheaper than reusing the existing land by replacing all of the old panels. And the cheaper the panels get the shorter their lifespan gets because the point when the generation loss from older/degraded panels exceeds the replacement cost comes sooner. It doesn't suddenly get longer when the price flattens out, it just stops getting any shorter than it already is by that point.