6 ms·
Ontario police warn of SIM swapping fraud
- robertelder 7y ago'a relatively new kind of fraud calling "SIM swapping"'
- zik 7y ago...which has been happening for years and is well known to telcos who seem to be doing very little about it despite the fact that it's their security flaw.
- mifreewil 7y agoIt’s hilarious how all these articles are about how to protect yourself instead of talking about why the carriers don’t better protect against this
- mifreewil 7y agoIt’s the same as the credit industry creating identity theft instead of protecting against attacks on their own systems
- kjaftaedi 7y agoIMHO governments should be doing more to provide modern identity verification solutions so there isn't a need to rely on more or less decentralized systems that can be so easily gamed.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- brenden2 7y agoThere are 2 distinct but compounding issues here: 1) Consumers are largely at the mercy of platforms (Google, Apple, FB, etc) and they don't _really_ control their data. 2) Phone companies don't care enough to perform adequate due diligence, and regulation hasn't caught up. The phone companies lean toward making changes easy to prevent customer backlash. Issue 1 can be improved slightly by not placing your entire digital life in the hands of one or two companies. Additionally, don't link your phone with these accounts if possible (although many, if not all, now require a phone number). Even better, store your data on your own computers instead of "the cloud" (which just means giving your data to someone else). Issue 2, I suspect, can only be resolved if there's a change in regulation. Phone companies aren't going to go out of their way unless it starts to hurt them in their pocket books, which it would if they were fined when this happens.
- tomComb 7y agoI'm not clear on how #1 is related to the SIM swapping problem. Yes, I encounter a lot of services that put way too much weight on phone number (maybe because phone number has some legal status) but not the big platforms. For Google, at least, they go well beyond making other methods available - they really seem to encourage/push users to use better second factors. In my experience the big platforms are the least guilty. My Google account/data is by far the most secure account I have online or off.
- iudqnolq 7y agoI'm not sure if - given my threat model - it makes sense for me to disable phone based 2FA on my Google account. I'm not prominent at all, so I don't expect to be individually targeted. I store 2FA tokens in my password manager (1Password) so that I could recover from my phone being stolen or damaged. However, I don't have a printout of my 1Password backup code stored under my mattress (or in my desk) because I don't completely trust my roommates. If I had my phone and laptop with me and was mugged, or if both were damaged at the same time, I would be locked out of everything if I didn't have phone-based 2FA. With it I could get a replacement SIM card, regain access to my Google account, and then use that to bootstrap password resets to everything else. (For the same reason, my only duplicate passwords are memorized randomly generated passwords for phone, primary Google account, and laptop (and there is some duplication between them))
- deanmoriarty 7y agoWhy not simply save the backup codes on a couple usb keys encrypted with a reasonably long password that you can remember, and leave one at home and one in another geographical area (e.g. parents house)? I do that and feel pretty good in completely ditching SMS 2fa. Once a year or so I plug the USB keys to check they still work. I, like you, don’t expect to be a target and have a very minimal social media/web presence with my real name.
- iudqnolq 7y ago
- 37 7y agoIs this something that 2FA would protect against? Doesn't seem like it...
- taysix 7y agoCorrect, if it's 2FA with a phone number. Avoid 2FA with a phone number if possible and use any other method (OTP, YubiKey's, etc.)
- TheChaplain 7y agoIf a sites uses the phone number as a 2FA, no it will not...
- analog31 7y agoI'm not a security expert, but it would seem to make sense, to have the password reset 2fa come to an account that your phone isn't attached to.
- mmahemoff 7y agoPhone number is already a 2FA for regular logins in many services. The problem is their processes also allow it to used in a 1FA reset scenario, so it's not true 2FA.
- nayuki 7y agoThe consequences of SIM swapping fraud can be severe, like this example of getting thousands of dollars stolen from an online bitcoin account: https://medium.com/coinmonks/the-most-expensive-lesson-of-my-life-details-of-sim-port-hack-35de11517124 https://medium.com/coinmonks/the-most-expensive-lesson-of-my...
- Jd 7y agoFriend of mine lost $24mm : https://www.wsj.com/articles/he-thought-his-phone-was-secure-then-he-lost-24-million-to-hackers-11573221600 https://www.wsj.com/articles/he-thought-his-phone-was-secure...
- Narkov 7y ago> a relatively new kind of fraud calling "SIM swapping" Either the journalist has misinterpreted information given to them or the Ontario police are at least a decade behind current scams. SIM swapping or port-fraud is at least a decade old problem.
- upofadown 7y agoIt's sort of odd that the list of precautions omitted the most obvious one: don't link online accounts to your phone number if that account can be reset with access to that phone number. Yeah, using a password manager is great, but not if it can be trivially bypassed. The phone companies should not be expected to be some sort of security gateway service.
- Scoundreller 7y agoIt also doesn’t help that Canadian cell phone plans usually include no roaming at all or horribly expensive roaming. So if an attacker knows you’re making a day trip to go to one of the malls that dot the border, they can pounce and you won’t know until damage is done. Meanwhile, T-Mobile plans include so much Canadian roaming that your plan is better than local Canadians’.
- na85 7y ago>Meanwhile, T-Mobile plans include so much Canadian roaming that your plan is better than local Canadians’. Truth. I know a guy who works for NORAD and his (US-based) data plan is 60/month and includes unlimited data anywhere in Mexico, Canada, or the US. No roaming, no nothing. How the Canadian telcos haven't been prosecuted for price-fixing is beyond me.
- bonestamp2 7y agoCan confirm. I pay $45/line and my mom (in Canada) has been one of the lines on my account for about 5 years now. The only downside is that she has a US number, but she now has unlimited data/texts in over 150 countries and unlimited calling to/from Canada/US/Mexico.
- Scoundreller 7y agoYou could set up a local access number for her on voip.ms that just forwards to her T-Mob number. Would cost a few dollars a month, but can’t receive SMS to it.
- bonestamp2 7y agoThat's a good idea. I'm not sure how much calling she does but I'll run it by her to see if she wants a local number. Thanks!
- Scoundreller 7y ago
- Scoundreller 7y agoThe article confuses SIM Swapping and Phone Porting Fraud. The latter may be harder to undo given that it cancels your account. And providers always claim it’s impossible to give people their old plans back.
- tekstar 7y agoOk, so, how does a paranoid individual protect themselves from this attack? Aside from "don't link your phone to these accounts" which isn't always possible as many banks in Canada only recently added SMS based 2FA. Some ideas: - separate phone for 2FA. This seems quite annoying in practice. - a daily twilio script that SMS's your number as an indication that you've still got it. Easy to implement, but also easy to ignore and would only indicate after the fact that you lost your account.
- pmoriarty 7y agoFastmail once offered as part of their mail service a list of random numbers you could print out and then use as a second factor, one at a time, when you logged in. I really miss that feature, and wish more online services supported something like it.
- nine_k 7y agoGitHub does this; I remember Google offering this, too.
- geforce 7y agoMaybe you could use VOIP numbers for 2FA? Many VOIP providers (i.e. voip.ms) can forward SMS to e-mail, SIP client, callback URL or an other phone number. There's a cost, but I guess it's minimal, all considerations done. Your second scenario is like a dead man's switch. It's interesting, as it could prompt you with a daily challenge that only you can answer. But I don't see how it could be implemented in a normal person's life?
- tekstar 7y agoI guess then the risk is whether or not the VOIP provider is more secure than my phone provider? I need to think that one through. With the second scenario I was just thinking that, if I personally didn't receive the text on a given morning, I would know that my number has been ported and I would begin to freak out and try to race the attacker.
- rb808 7y agoActually I'm starting to think the cell phone operators are doing a smart thing on this. In an ideal world you could trust the cell phone operators to diligently protect your number and you could rely on this to help Google/Chase/GoDaddy identify your account. The problem is this makes it complicated for the cell phone operators and why should they be the ones to have to enforce your identity protection to benefit FANGs/Banks/etc? It always seemed a bit dumb to me that you need a phone number for most accounts in this internet age. Maybe they could offer a service for a fee where they will be stricter and you have to show a passport to the office to get a new sim issue. In the meantime I'm sure they've figured out its more benefical in the long term that they just sell cell phone plans that are flexible and we need a better solution to identify people and their accounts.
- thewarpaint 7y agoNo one should be able to receive a text message meant for my number, regardless of the specific purpose of the message. That should be a basic security feature of the service, not something that comes for an extra fee.
- tmikaeld 7y agoThis was a common occurrence in Sweden a few years ago, they would target small businesses by changing their address by sending in an address change, then take over the phones and then order a ton of stuff online for which they are never cought. It could go up to millions of SEK in debt before it was discovered by the victim, because invoice time is usually 30 days and credit score will be perfect until after the scam. Since BankID (identity verification) became a norm, this has essentially stopped.
- 2rsf 7y agoYou can now lock your address using BankID
- dzhiurgis 7y agoThe whole dependency on phone line/number is staggering. You can't do anything nowadays without a number. Can't apply for a visa, buy anything online or do your taxes. All of this while phone calls are anti-feature - they are low quality, abused by scammers and (at least on iOS) - no way to disable entirely. What's even more weird - if you happen not own a phone - there's no digital service/website where you can call 911 (or local equivalent). You can't even text 911 in most countries.
- cgriswald 7y agoWhen I was a child, we didn’t have a phone for awhile. I don’t know why. People would ask for our number and their responses to finding out we didn’t have one ranged from blank confusion to assuming we were trying to scam them somehow. But once we got past that, we could still get what we needed because we were dealing with people (and frequently pen and paper). (This was also back when, “Our system doesn’t let us do that” wasn’t an economically or socially acceptable response from someone representing a business or agency.) Now we deal with machines for good and for bad.
- chewyland 7y agoInteresting. Here I am 6 years without a phone number and probably make 3 calls a year. Only thing I have is an Android tablet with a data plan and an old iPhone SE, only a data plan.
- pluma 7y agoThis is funny to read as where I live (Germany) banks have been slowly migrating away from SMS-based verification to app-based code generators that in turn require one-time authorization via physical mail. And we're generally lagging behind when it comes to digital solutions, so I would expect other countries to be ahead of the curve and no longer using SMS for anything important.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoBanks are a great use case for TOTP or other 2FA auth methods that aren't SMS, as if you need to verify identity in person, you can require the user come to a physical branch (in the US, you can get something called a "medallion signature guarantee" [1], which is typically required to verify your identity if you're moving more than $250k in assets between financial service firms). Services that can't provide identity verification services in meatspace are at a disadvantage, which is why they fall back to SMS as identity verification and management. ID cards that support cryptographic functions (such as Estonia's National ID [2], or in the US, DoD CACs [3]) would go a long way to fixing these problems. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medallion_signature_guarantee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medallion_signature_guarantee [2] https://e-estonia.com/solutions/e-identity/id-card/ https://e-estonia.com/solutions/e-identity/id-card/ [3] https://www.cac.mil/ https://www.cac.mil/