4 ms·
So then T-Mob calls the NOC at C. Tells them to get this stopped and they have 24 hours, or they'll depeer. 6 hour later, C's NOC calls B's NOC, saying to knoc
by Scoundreller 7y ago
So then T-Mob calls the NOC at C. Tells them to get this stopped and they have 24 hours, or they'll depeer.
6 hour later, C's NOC calls B's NOC, saying to knock it off, and they have 18 hours or they're getting booted.
6 hours later, B's NOC calls A's NOC, saying to knock it off, and they have 12 hours to figure it out or they're getting booted.
In under 12 more hours, A cuts off 111-1111.
If peeringDB is to be believed, big providers all require their peers to have a 24/7 NOC number to call.
- EB66 7y agoI agree completely. I work for a small ISP and we sometimes do the same thing for significant bad actors abusing our network. A phone call to the NOC of the ISP hosting the abuser or the NOC of their upstream transit providers usually gets the ball rolling pretty quickly. That approach is obviously not very effective in a DDoS scenario, but as I understand it these robocalls typically originate from a handful of different VoIP termination services -- as opposed to tens of thousands of hosts in a DDoS scenario.
- Scoundreller 7y agoExactly. Creating a proactive system might be difficult, but the apparatus is all there for being reactive. Yet this has been going on for years, so I suspect shenanigans by providers too happy to continue charging their Tier7 peers for access.
- wpskidd 7y agoI think this a great challenge to propose to the HN crowd. Who wouldn’t pay for a system that truly eliminates the annoyance of spam calls? What about a private network that people could subscribe to that uses a decentralized social credit system? Or one that uses a monitoring gateway to track the number of calls originating from a number (either internal or external to the subscriber group), and treats mass callers with extreme prejudice. A blacklist of known spammers could be applied first as a default (rather than as an add-on app). If you wanted to get really creative, you could give subscribers the tools to add numbers to their own black list far more easily than they now can, and maybe even block whole geographic regions.
- dao- 7y ago> Who wouldn’t pay for a system that truly eliminates the annoyance of spam calls? Anyone in a region with sensible legislation.
- closeparen 7y agoHow does T-Mobile know there's a problem worth calling the C NOC about? One way is to see the frequency and duration of calls. Lots of very short calls indicate spammy behavior. So if you are B, you offer SIP trunking at below cost to legitimate customers, so that you can mix their call flow with the much more lucrative, 100% robocall traffic from A, and thereby stay on favorable terms with C. I worked in this business briefly, the economics are fascinating. Your average mom and pop restaurant is very likely buying its VoIP transit from an entity like "B" in this story.
- EB66 7y ago> How does T-Mobile know there's a problem worth calling the C NOC about? One way is to see the frequency and duration of calls. Or make it easier for consumers to report spam calls. For example, dial *666 after hanging up on the spammer and it reports the last call as spam. Enough abuse reports originating from a particular carrier and T-Mobile knows there's a problem. That's basically how it works for email spam and other forms of Internet abuse.