4 ms·
This would be a good time to check old HN and Reddit threads for all of the hysteria and “we told you” stuff being spread after this originally hit the news. I
by dmix 7y ago
This would be a good time to check old HN and Reddit threads for all of the hysteria and “we told you” stuff being spread after this originally hit the news. I also noticed a bunch of health agencies took advantage of the headlines to stir up fear around using them, they never specified what types to watch out for.
I was immediately suspicious that after a decade (or longer) of vaping being popular that all of a sudden people started dying out of nowhere. If it was caused by standard e-cigarettes it there would have been a gradual increase in cases.
The early warning signs that it was strictly a small subset of shady black market THC cartridges also wasn’t a big surprise (they even look shady [1]). The vendor I’ve used in the past for (actual) THC cartridges posts lab tests for all of their vape products to show there was zero adulterants and they were doing it before the big scare.
Now we see that it was 100% vitamin E all along (which was used as a thickening agents for the lowest-quality THC, something glycol-based nicotine liquids wouldn't need).
[1] https://hempherbalshop.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/5899D1BA-66BD-4032-A1D4-B26769792734.jpeg https://hempherbalshop.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/5899D1...
- gpm 7y agoWould you please stop spouting this bullshit? > But Dr. Schuchat left open the possibility that other chemicals or toxins from vaping fluids or devices could also be causing the severe respiratory ailments. > Some patients say they vaped only nicotine, and state health officials consider some of those reports reliable, Dr. Schuchat said. > Because there is still uncertainty about what is causing the illness, the C.D.C. is continuing to urge people to avoid vaping anything, including e-cigarettes. Just because we have identified one thing that is almost definitely killing people doesn't mean we have identified the only thing. In fact we have good reason to think that we haven't identified the only thing.
- dmix 7y agoSo we shouldn't wait for actual evidence to worry is what you're saying? Just be perma-scared because "maybe". The number of deaths and hospital visits have largely stopped since Vitamin-E was identified, all data is pointing to one thing. This has always been about Vitamin-E being added as a thickening agent to low-quality THC cartridges which would be needless in any glycol based nicotine cartridges and 100% not needed for any real CO2 filtered THC cartridge that used proper marijuana sourcing. Done right it's as safe or unsafe as it's always been.
- gpm 7y agoWhat do you consider actual evidence if not > Some patients say they vaped only nicotine, and state health officials consider some of those reports reliable, Dr. Schuchat said. And no, we shouldn't. Common sense should tell you that inhaling large amount of steam mixed with other chemicals is a great way to mess up your lungs.
- dmix 7y agoI don't consider that solid evidence sorry, it's speculation and all evidence is 100% limited to Vitamin-E. I've never heard any reason to add Vitamin-E to a substance that is already thick. Nicotine e-cigarettes don't need thickening agents to be thick. It's like 95%+ glycol which is already thick. Why the hell would they need to add a thickening agent? The problem has always been there was a shortage of quality weed and instead of waiting they reprocessed "shake" (the lowest quality part of the plant) and added a thickening agent. The fact some kids won't admit they smoked THC to their parents, which put them in the hospital, also wouldn't surprise me. The numbers are very small at that. If anything the risks with nicotine are with the various flavouring agents (which shady companies like Juul already acknowledged, another company I'd never use). I'm not saying there's zero risk or that it's entirely safe. But dying and hospital visits over Vitamin-E are in a totally different league and not something I'm not worried about with nicotine e-cigarettes. I am still worried about THC pens in general, which are way harsher than e-cigarettes, but that's not what I'm defending.
- Scoundreller 7y ago> I've never heard any reason to add Vitamin-E to a substance that is already thick. It's an antioxidant. So it should reduce breakdown of what it's mixed into. And it's fat-soluble. Since it's a vitamin, it might have been seen as something that's "safe" because it's naturally occurring. But that's easily a myth.
- dmix 7y agoYeah, I don't see any way for THC pens to get safer unless they get legalized and regulated like other food/consumption industries. I personally use THC pens once and a while from reputable sources but even they still scare me. The experience of smoking it is significantly harsher than even the strongest nicotine vape devices I've used and results in sometimes scary coughing fits for most people I've seen use them, typically from taking too much. I could see that level of heat and inflammatory reaction combined with some bad ingredients result in some serious harm to the breathing passageways. I wouldn't be surprised if smoking Vitamin-E normally without the heat/harshness of shitty THC vape pens turns out to be harmless. That's purely anecdotal though - besides some study I read where constant-heating of the throat and mouth was connected to higher infections rates with a particular drugs, even though the drug itself wasnt dangerous. (Note: temperatures are typically far lower with glycol based nicotine vape devices which doesn't require heat/burn levels that THC requires). For some reason the Canadian government (where I live) has refused to add vape pens to the legal list which has helped keep grey market retail stores and online websites flourishing regardless of the law. It would be silly to expect THC pen's popularity will somehow stop - it really is the best way to smoke weed, hands down, and will continue to grow in popularity. Fortunately most of the reputable [1] Canadian grey market weed sites post medical lab results and unlike the legal shops in Canada have zero issues with supply management. Meanwhile the legal shops are constantly out of stock as supply from legal grow-ops outpaces demand because the licensing system (like all gov processes) is extremely slow, backlogged, and full of highly questionable road blocks. [1] There are tons of forums, review sites, and Reddit threads where consumers can share information about good grey market stores. That plus whether they post lab tests on their websites... which typically come from the same labs who test the gov licensed grow ops products.
- cmdshiftf4 7y ago>I also noticed a bunch of health agencies took advantage of the headlines to stir up fear around using them, they never specified what types to watch out for. They'd no early insight into what was causing the issues, only that it appeared en masse at a time where vaping suddenly got very popular, especially among teenagers. It would have been negligent of them to try and throw darts at a root cause without having done the due diligence to research the cases and results thoroughly, and so it's fair that their warning was about vaping in general.
- rudedogg 7y agoIt was pretty clear looking at the numbers from the beginning. A high percentage (I think it was 88%) of the people admitted to using black market THC vape cartridges. The other people were probably teens too afraid to admit it. I understand they can't give the all clear, but the headlines and statements by the CDC were vague and pointed toward nicotine products. As an example, look at https://cdc.gov https://cdc.gov. The hero points to https://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/basic_information/e-cigarettes/severe-lung-disease.html https://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/basic_information/e-cigarettes/s.... Why is "THC" buried here? The way this entire thing was handled makes me not trust the CDC. The fear-mongering was/is on par with clickbait farms.