5 ms·
Uh, this imho sheds light onto another completely different but bigger issue: Certain people or organizations, due to their size (organizations) or influence (
by znpy 7y ago
Uh, this imho sheds light onto another completely different but bigger issue:
Certain people or organizations, due to their size (organizations) or influence (people/organizations) become some sort of judges in moral topics and the problem here is that they usually have backgrounds in other stuff, have not been elected by anyone (often times they just start screaming louder, and people follow) and do not apply any form of fairness to the accused.
There is no form of due process, no hearings, just attacks.
This is not justice.
And let me be clear: this problem is beyond the specific political tone of this specific case, and happens on both sides of the political spectrum.
People just start throwing accusations at each other, and who screams the louder and/or manages to get more attention wins.
It's scary.
- lliamander 7y ago> Certain people or organizations, due to their size (organizations) or influence (people/organizations) become some sort of judges in moral topics and the problem here is that they usually have backgrounds in other stuff, have not been elected by anyone (often times they just start screaming louder, and people follow) and do not apply any form of fairness to the accused. Indeed. And how far does this go? What if banks, or grocery stores, start denying someone services because they were the subject of social opprobrium? A conference is not quite the same thing, but it is still a means by which some people are able to derive their livelihoods.
- cryptonector 7y agoThey already do. Some, for example, refuse to allow gun shops to use their clearance networks.
- psweber 7y agoI heard an interesting idea today. "Boomers" have been criticizing "young people today" for being "snowflakes". It might be the case that with their fresher perspective on technology and culture, the younger people realized the perilous path involved in taking action now. Older, less savvy people are being caught unaware of the ramifications of certain types of speech and action in the modern world.
- busterarm 7y agoNew ideas come and go. Most of the "free love" generation came along thinking their parents were squares and that they were creating a new, better society. Drug overdoses and HIV turned that ship around quick. Maybe it's more accurate to say that the better ideas resist change.
- Doingmything123 7y agoEntrenched ideas resist change. Some of the worst ideas in human history have been the ones that have stuck around the longest. It took over a century to adopt the heliocentric model which was centuries after Aristarchus of Samos first proposed the idea.
- lliamander 7y agoPtolemaic cosmology was hardly a bad idea. It was the simplest model that fit the available evidence for a long time. The Heliocentric model didn't really make sense until Newton's theory of gravitation was developed. https://tofspot.blogspot.com/2013/10/the-great-ptolemaic-smackdown-table-of.html https://tofspot.blogspot.com/2013/10/the-great-ptolemaic-sma...
- api 7y agoMakes me wonder if there are any nutty ideas today that are right but seem to not make sense because we are missing a vital piece of theory that would explain how they work.
- krapp 7y agoDark matter and dark energy come to mind.
- api 7y agoThose are more like the crazy complex epicycles in Ptolemaic cosmology. They point to something seriously wrong. I'm on the fence about the revisionist view that the Ptolemaics were rational at the time, but in a way its optimistic. I have always been suspicious of the "only people in the last 500 years had brains" bias. I wonder if all ages have had that bias?
- jonbronson 7y agoIt's a mistake to classify ethical norms as politics. We just happen to be living in an of era populism where rampant unethical normalization is masquerading as politics.
- lliamander 7y agoA honest look at society forces us to recognize the trade-offs that exist between values. Politics is how we negotiate conflicting values.
- yourbandsucks 7y agoFighting over ethical norms is actually a pretty good definition of politics. Or one key aspect of it, at least.
- jonbronson 7y agoSure with respect to norms of Governance and policy style, not over whether a woman or a minority deserves to be treated with the same decency as any other human being.
- yourbandsucks 7y agoAlso very much part of politics, although not actually at issue anywhere near this debate, as nobody is arguing against those things.
- jonbronson 7y agoOn the contrary, that's the exact issue at the heart of what happened here.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lliamander 7y ago
- tootahe45 7y ago>happens on both sides of the political spectrum Can you provide any examples to support this?