5 ms·
> Protecting the most vulnerable people and ensuring people don't fall into the trap of poverty is an investment that should occur at the governmental level. Th
by rayiner 7y ago
> Protecting the most vulnerable people and ensuring people don't fall into the trap of poverty is an investment that should occur at the governmental level. There are many such governmental investments that would alleviate serious long-term problems.
The United States spends 38% of GDP “investing in people.” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_spending_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_spending_in_the_Uni.... Even if you exclude the much maligned defense spending (where a lot of our science and technology investment goes), that’s $6.5 trillion that goes to investing in people or managing people who invest in people.
I’m amenable to the notion that we should invest more. For example healthcare and guaranteed meals for everyone under age 18.
But the idea that “America sees investment in its own people as wasteful spending” is just false. It’s a statement that’s so disconnected from reality that it makes me question the point that is really being made. Are people really saying spending a third of every dollar on welfare is nothing? Or is it a way to deflect from any efforts to criticize how that money is being used? Because if you keep telling people “America invests almost nothing in its people” that makes folks very defensive about the programs we do spend money on, and willing to overlook mismanagement of those programs.
- sharkmerry 7y agoUSA seems to be around 26th in the world with that ratio. https://data.oecd.org/gga/general-government-spending.htm https://data.oecd.org/gga/general-government-spending.htm
- Enginerrrd 7y agoThe USA has a unique situation with its defense spending though, which skews that ratio in a sort of unfair way. On that same data you linked, if you look at dollars per capita instead of %GDP, the US is actually 11th and ahead of Germany, Iceland, and the UK, etc. Now really, the stats you linked probably aren't even all that correlated with social spending. It's more likely a measure of the scope of bureaucracy.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoNot only that, most of those countries have socialized medicine -- but socialized medicine isn't exactly an anti-poverty program. When the government takes an extra $1 from someone at the mean income and then provides them with $1 in health coverage, it shows up as $1 in government spending, but that's not redistributive. If the program didn't exist they could have taken the $1 and used it to buy $1 in health insurance, which is what happens in the US. Socialized medicine is only redistributive to the extent that the money comes from someone other than who receives the benefit. For healthcare spending probably 80% of the money isn't that, because it's mostly going to insure the same people who are paying the taxes. The US couldn't raise taxes by an equivalent amount unless the money specifically went to healthcare in an equivalent way (because otherwise taxpayers would still need to have that money to buy healthcare), so you couldn't use it to solve homelessness. The problem is that Social Security and Medicare in the US completely dominate social spending, and they're also the same thing. Or worse, since Social Security even gives bigger payouts to wealthier people who had higher incomes before retirement -- the least it could do is give everyone the same amount. So we end up in a situation where we are at the same time spending too much on government programs and not spending enough on government programs, not because the amount of tax revenue is too low, but because the money we currently spend mostly isn't actually going to anti-poverty programs or public infrastructure or scientific research etc.
- sharkmerry 7y ago>> When the government takes an extra $1 from someone at the mean income and then provides them with $1 in health coverage, it shows up as $1 in government spending, but that's not redistributive. If the program didn't exist they could have taken the $1 and used it to buy $1 in health insurance, which is what happens in the US. This is ignoring that a private insurer will take a profit so not all that dollar is returned in the form of care/insurance.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoIt's not ignoring that at all. The insurer's profit comes from the investment of capital. Before they make their first dollar they have to lay out money to acquire an office building to operate out of, hire lawyers and actuaries to establish procedures to operate under, maintain a large pile of money in reserve in case there are an unexpected number of claims etc. The profits are the returns on that investment, and if it wasn't a private company then the public would have had to supply that capital instead. You don't get out of paying for it -- otherwise it would be easy to avoid by having the government establish an independent non-profit insurance company.
- rayiner 7y agoYes, we’re ahead of places we think of as first world countries (Australia, South Korea, Ireland, and Switzerland. And we’re pretty close to Japan, the U.K., Israel, etc. We are closer to Germany than Germany is to France. The clustering in the OECD is pretty close.
- claudeganon 7y agoThese statistics don’t take into account things like the disproportionately high cost of healthcare in the US, so percentage of dollars spent isn’t an especially meaningful measure. Social Security payments maybe, but you would have to compare relative age of populations and account for how the wealthy escape paying into the system at anything like a progressive level. As this article demonstrates, Americans are great at paying out lots of money into private systems without receiving good material returns on these investments. By contrast, for example, my great grandmother in the UK paid into various state taxes regimes all her life. In return, she received very good quality healthcare, home care and long term care in old age, and social housing after the death of her husband. She was a working class person who suffered a lot of hardship, but lived to be 99. In the US, she probably would’ve ended up bankrupt and dead on the street much earlier.
- heavyset_go 7y ago> These statistics don’t take into account things like the disproportionately high cost of healthcare in the US, so percentage of dollars spent isn’t an especially meaningful measure Yep. The US spends more than double what countries with universal coverage spend on healthcare[1]. Those countries also have better health outcomes on nearly every metric[2] and manage to cover all of their citizens. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_health_expenditure_per_capita?sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwj8tZuoyr3lAhVvkuAKHZ96BtMQ9QF6BAgMEAI#/media/File:OECD_health_expenditure_per_capita_by_country.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_hea... [2] https://www.healthsystemtracker.org/chart-collection/quality-u-s-healthcare-system-compare-countries/ https://www.healthsystemtracker.org/chart-collection/quality...
- sol_remmy2 7y agoDoctors in the US are also grossly overpaid compared to other countries: https://www.medscape.com/slideshow/2019-international-compensation-report-6011814#2 https://www.medscape.com/slideshow/2019-international-compen... We will need to reduce doctors salaries by atleast 50% if we want to tackle high healthcare costs..