6 ms·
Homelessness is not going to be fixed till it is addressed at the federal level. There are difficulties: there are different homeless population types charact
by mc32 7y ago
Homelessness is not going to be fixed till it is addressed at the federal level.
There are difficulties: there are different homeless population types characterized by Mental health, substance abuse, cost of living, unemployment, etc.
Also because of a reaction to heavy handed policies of the past, it’s difficult to institutionalize those who need mental health intervention.
That said we could at least tackle the easier population whose issue is an economic one.
- jvagner 7y agoI’m back in SF after a few years away. I had developed some thoughts about the homelessness challenges that Reno was facing, but when I landed in SF/Oakland it was immediately overwhelming, occurring on such a different scale and with such visibility. I have no solid ideas of what “we need to do” but I know that in the European cities I frequent, it’s not like this. Other comments in this discussion touch on the social infrastructure that we’ve forsaken... the things that cost money, require continuity and depth in the community, and which... in other cultures, seem reasonable and required for their humans. That said, I wonder about what the infrastructure looks like that helps people months before they hit the homeless force functions. There’s a funnel in the descent of resources... the homelessness activists can’t fix the infrastructure of social support and the economic cliff son many people teeter on. I just spent a couple of months traveling, living in quarters not my own. Had a very minor health issue that was difficult to treat outside of my home base. It was inconvenient, then challenging, then debilitating, and ultimately pretty deflating. I had the resources to fix things, but if I had been financially constrained, my confidence and autonomy and self-esteem could have plummeted to hard-to-recover levels. I could feel how vulnerable other people probably would have been. And I know my friends in other countries would’ve shaken their head and muttered something about our system here in the US.
- rthomas6 7y agoWhen you consider that it costs over $3000/month for a single bedroom apartment, the local government prevents the building of high-rise buildings, and the climate is comfortable outdoors year-round, it makes sense. It will continue to be this way as long as high density low income apartment high rises are not allowed to be built in large numbers in west SF.
- asdfman123 7y agoI don't think this is a hot take, but if the market wants to build fancy apartments, let them build fancy apartments. The reason there aren't less fancy, affordable apartments is people weren't allowed to build new apartments 20 years ago, which would have aged into affordable housing this decade.
- rthomas6 7y agoSounds good to me. Just let developers build.
- axaxs 7y agoI'm not sure I follow this line of thinking. The price is what it is, and everyone knows what it is. How can I feel sorry for folks that live there and just shrug and say "can't afford it". It's one of the most expensive cities on Earth. There is so much land in the US, so many cities with reasonable cost of living, etc etc. It feels like instead of doing the logical thing, we're building some class of caviar homeless. We can't just dictate that because people want to live there, we must provide them cheap or free housing in popular coastal cities. Though the above does touch on what I think is really missing - a social safety net. I can see how high cost of living could lead to homelessness when you're trying to cling on after losing a job and can't find something to replace it right away. I fully believe we should help such folks, give them a safety net, just -not- in SF. There's tons of inland cities that are begging for people, let's solve two things at once. After they are back on their feet, if they want to move back - so be it.
- netsharc 7y agoBut SF hasn't always had these prices, what if someone was born there and has their "social network"? Do they have to fuck off when that VC-funded Node.js programmer show up? So they move to a cheaper place, try to rebuild their life, but what if that's the next hot town for Porsche-driving Saudi-funded bros? "Sorry poor man, you need to leave yet again!".
- 7y ago
- wffurr 7y agoCan we declare a "war" on homelessness and redirect some military spending? Maybe instead of another fighter jets, nuclear aircraft carrier, or nuclear missiles, we can help our citizens instead. I would be a lot happier paying taxes if the spending ratios were reversed.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoWhy do you think it's a money thing? Major cities already spend a lot of money on homelessness, and the richest cities are often struggling the most. It's not obvious to me that they'll succeed if they just get a bit more funding.
- ratsmack 7y agoThat's because a large portion of homeless people have drug addiction and/or have mental disease. Just giving them a place to stay doesn't cure the root problem.
- foldr 7y ago>Just giving them a place to stay doesn't cure the root problem. reply I suspect that this is because the 'place to stay' usually comes with various strings attached. I doubt there are many homeless people who would choose to sleep under a bridge rather than in a bed (though not doubt there are a minority who would).
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoThe strings attached generally ensure the place meets a minimum standard of tolerability. For example, while drug abuse certainly can't be cured at a snap of your fingers, it can't be tolerated in communal housing situations either; any sane person would rather sleep under a bridge than a bed in a crack house.
- criddell 7y agoHomeless people, like everybody else, usually have many problems. You can fix their problem of not having a home by giving them a home. Once somebody has an address and a little more stability, your chances of dealing with other issues goes up.
- solidsnack9000 7y agoWhat leads you to conclude it won't be fixed till it's done at the federal level?
- EricE 7y ago> Homelessness is not going to be fixed till it is addressed at the federal level. lol - it can't even be fixed at local levels where there is very close and local pressure and you expect it to be fixed at the totally remote and abstracted federal level? Want to fix homelessness and many other problems? Let go of this "two party" BS and stop voting people back in who change nothing or allow problems to continually worsen. It's really that simple. Until politicians are going to be held accountable and know that just because they have a D or R behind their name they can't take your vote for granted, why should they worry or care about opinions expressed in threads like this one? People might actually have to pay attention to what's going on around them, though. People currently not in "the game" might have to get out of their comfort zone and get involved. Perish the thought. Insanity - doing the same thing over and over while expecting a different result. As the old comic strip Pogo once opined: "We have met the enemy and He is Us". Enough blaming other people or expecting some other fair godmother in the sky (ie. "federal level") to wave a magic wand and solve all our problems. It isn't going to happen and to expect otherwise is truly irrational.