4 ms·
I feel like that’s a cop-out. I agree that draconian criminal enforcement of what is a civil tort is unwarranted. But do people really see it as a form of civil
by rayiner 7y ago
I feel like that’s a cop-out. I agree that draconian criminal enforcement of what is a civil tort is unwarranted. But do people really see it as a form of civil disobedience, or do they just feel entitled to stuff for free? And if it’s civil disobedience, why not do it in a principled way? Download and share but don’t watch it.
I’d liken it more to the looting and vandalism in response to police brutality. More opportunism than civil disobedience.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoI think comparing it to looting and vandalism is a bit hyperbole. It’s closer to copying a book at the library and taking the copy home. No one is deprived of an object or the content when duplicated, they only miss out on whatever revenue they were attempting to capture.
- rayiner 7y agoI dislike the book analogy because it puts on the cloak of “sharing learning.” The kinda of things people are pirating are consumer goods—created solely for the purpose of being sold for entertainment. It’s stealing candy, not stealing bread.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoLet's split the difference. It'd be like parking outside the drive-in theater and watching the movie from the top of your car without having bought a ticket. Still not good, but of limited harm caused.
- rayiner 7y agoSure. I don’t think that should result in a SWAT team, but should people feel entitled to do it?
- toomuchtodo 7y agoHumans are tricky creatures.
- papln 7y agoIt's OK if I steal a copy because someone else is willing to pay for it. Ask Immanuel Kant how he feels about that.
- vijayr02 7y agoSincerely, I can't
- Marsymars 7y agoIt's a bit of a convoluted analogy, but if you want to extend it to cars, it's like stealing a car off the end of the assembly line, and leaving behind a briefcase full of cash to cover the marginal cost of production.
- tracker1 7y agoEven then, imagine not being able to buy any given book at a few different stores. I can get just about any of them on Amazon, B&N and others. Imagine having to go to 6 different stores, with a membership club fee, to check out 6 different books. Vs a single store or library.
- rayiner 7y agoYou mean like how I can’t buy a Surface at an Apple Store and vice versa?
- givinguflac 7y agoNow you’re just being silly.
- tracker1 7y agoMore like, I can buy an apple or surface at BestBuy, Amazon and a number of other places. Neither is exclusive to where you can only get it at the one place.