3 ms·
What you can do is just focus on building your own product instead trying to seek rent from others. If it's not something you create, it's not something you sh
by mcv 7y ago
What you can do is just focus on building your own product instead trying to seek rent from others.
If it's not something you create, it's not something you should be patenting.
- cma 7y ago>If it's not something you create, it's not something you should be patenting. So if the company outsources the actual production to an assembly line in China, no patent?
- mcv 7y agoAre you arguing that Apple does not make iPhones because Foxconn does?
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoThe question at hand is, are you? You were the one to say he shouldn't hold a patent of he's not personally on three company manufacturing the product ... at least if you weren't saying that, could you break down what you were saying. It seems like you're happy for corps to hold patents and use third-party manufacturers but not for individuals to do that?
- mcv 7y agoI'm not a fan of any kind of patents because they create a tax on a market that newcomers have to pay to established parties. I'm even less of a fan of patents that are just paper vapourware that only exist to extract value from companies that actually produce value. The only valid case for a patent, in my opinion, is someone making a unique product, investing in it, providing there's a market for it, and wanting to protect this investment from a better funded competitor trying to swoop in and take over the market without having invested anything in it. Patents exist to protect real investment, not to seek rent from parties who are doing real investments. No doubt there's some grey area in there, but if you're not somehow involved in serving that market, you've got no business claiming that those who do are violating your paper monopoly that you're not even using. Go use it, then you might have a case. If it's actually innovative and others are clearly taking advantage from your investment.
- cma 7y agoI'm just trying to understand the full proposal. "Designed in California": contracting out production of the design is ok, but licensing it out wouldn't be? If they mix in enough hands on in setting up the production, that process engineering work is ok to be protected with trade secrets but not patents unless they get hands on with the assembly? Is it ok to patent inventions from hired contractors? Or do they have to be in-house employees? Isn't it the same thing as licensing from a third party, just done after the fact instead of in anticipation of getting some inventions out of a contractor?
- mcv 7y agoWhy would licensing not be okay? If someone designs a thing and someone else wants to pay them to build that thing, that's totally fine. What's not okay is if someone designs and builds a thing, and then a complete stranger comes by and claims to have designed it based on some questionable similarities to a vague description of an idea on paper. The big issue is: did you actually design the thing, or are you merely trying to extract money from those who did?
- cma 7y ago> What's not okay is if someone designs and builds a thing, and then a complete stranger comes by and claims to have designed it based on some questionable similarities to a vague description of an idea on paper. What about the case where it isn't a simultaneous discovery, and instead is a copy? Are you saying the patent should only be restricted from applying to independent rediscoveries, but that otherwise patents can go to people who don't build the thing or contract someone else to build the thing? And people who build the thing and patent it can also sue people who independently come up with it, because they invented it and then built it rather than just invented it? During the ramp up of the build process do you have to swear everyone to silence because if someone copies it before it has yet been built they are in the clear, or is there a "intend to build it or contract someone else to build it" standard?
- rolltiide 7y agoCan you expand on that thought? So if I receive a patent for something financial I should spend the next decade acquiring licenses in 50 states and multiple countries, some of which have multimillion dollar bond requirements, getting product market fit for my new financial service just to prove that the “locked down IP” has legs? Ignoring any other pursuit I might imagine in the mean time? Or just letting the market stay in its current unimproved state just in case maybe someone else independently comes up with the idea did you have something more practical in mind that fits your criteria which I didn’t consider? just disclosing the idea publicly as loud so others can build from it?
- harryh 7y agoPatents, at their best, are for IP that requires significant capital investment like drug development or wireless modem chips or things like that. You have to pay a bunch of talented and expensive people a bunch of money for a long time how to figure out how to make the thing. But once they figure it out, replicating the thing is fairly easy and cheap. In this case patent licensing is great because it allows for there to be some companies that do the invention and others that do the manufacturing. The patent license is the bridge between these two things. Patents are at their worst for IP that is just "I had an idea." Because, honestly, ideas are easy. Lots of people have ideas. Most ideas aren't original. When patents get issued for this sort of thing they mostly just cause problems. The lawsuit in the original link here is a good example of that. Someone had an idea to "provide an internet third party data channel" which is....kind of silly. A bunch of people had that idea. The idea had so little value it got sold for $1 but then it got turned into a series of annoying lawsuits that just cost a bunch of people a bunch of money with no good outcome for anyone. Based on your comments, it kinda sounds like the patent you have falls into the latter category and not the former which is why other commenters are skeptical of you. Maybe they're wrong though, but unless you are willing to talk about your patent (or link to it!) it's hard to really judge.
- bdowling 7y ago> The idea had so little value it got sold for $1 Public assignment records often state that a thing was sold for “$1 plus other good and valuable consideration” to keep the actual sale price confidential. The $1 is there to ensure the contract is enforceable and there’s no rule that says the other good and valuable consideration isn’t a whole lot of additional dollars.