7 ms·
How to Beat a Patent Troll
- behindsight 7y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21447215 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21447215
- arbuge 7y agoThis is probably not a viable strategy for any startup without significant financial resources and time to dedicate to it. From the post itself: > It is tempting to settle with patent trolls if you can settle for less than litigation costs. Our portfolio companies do it all the time and it is rational behavior. That precisely is the trolls' business model - make settling with them the rational way to go. The system is broken and needs to be fixed so that this business model is no longer viable.
- snarf21 7y agoExactly, we need legal changes. The changes aren't even hard, just require enough political will.
- metalliqaz 7y agoThe patent system is broken but SV is full of goons who made billions off of "do it on a computer" patents and they will never allow their cash cows to be legislated away. Patent trolls are really bad but they are just one symptom of a system that is built on huge patent portfolios. The big companies are just as bad IMHO.
- throwaway35784 7y agoI'm teaching myself the law and have assertively put a bully attorney in his place. Like all people bullies go after easy targets. Don't be one. Make it cost them more than it's worth to fight you.
- rolltiide 7y agoAs a patent creator that can’t get any message returned from potential licensees, what options are there aside from selling the patent to a troll or sending letters with my own lawyers The market can’t seem to distinguish validity of claims, but a letter from Esq. LLP seems to change that notion quickly. These discussions don’t factor in that companies never want to willingly exchange value for a royalty. There is no IP acquisition department. Everyone just wants to skirt around litigation, and lawyers fix that. There’s also a conception of thinking it’s viable to create everything you’ve considered patenting
- harryh 7y agoWhat did you create?
- mcv 7y agoWhat you can do is just focus on building your own product instead trying to seek rent from others. If it's not something you create, it's not something you should be patenting.
- cma 7y ago>If it's not something you create, it's not something you should be patenting. So if the company outsources the actual production to an assembly line in China, no patent?
- mcv 7y agoAre you arguing that Apple does not make iPhones because Foxconn does?
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoThe question at hand is, are you? You were the one to say he shouldn't hold a patent of he's not personally on three company manufacturing the product ... at least if you weren't saying that, could you break down what you were saying. It seems like you're happy for corps to hold patents and use third-party manufacturers but not for individuals to do that?
- Temasik 7y agoauthor has patents
- cfitz 7y agoI am a fan of Fred's work/blog but I'm not sure how this is a "how to" AKA a guide, rather than a regurgitation of someone else's guide, meant only for well-financed companies. For those of us bootstrapping, this will unfortunately not work. We are stuck settling with these parasites.
- turc1656 7y agoIn the original cloudflare posting, they said this - "As we have explained previously, patent trolls benefit from a problematic incentive structure that allows them to take vague or abstract patents that they have no intention of developing and assert them as broadly as possible." It seems to me that the real problem is patents being issues for "vague and abstract" things in the first place. You're not even supposed to be able to patent a mere idea anyway. It is supposed to be something specific and well-defined (and also usually pretty narrow). The patent office sounds like the real source of the problem, not the system/structure surrounding the legality of patent application and ownership.