5 ms·
> Why is anyone entitled to own a chip fab? Why is anyone entitled to own food? If someone invests their resources to have something built (or help make it the
by kortilla 7y ago
> Why is anyone entitled to own a chip fab?
Why is anyone entitled to own food? If someone invests their resources to have something built (or help make it themselves), why wouldn’t they be entitled to own it?
The rich daughter gets to own it because that’s what the owner wanted and the thing about owning something generally is deciding its fate.
If someone builds themselves a house out of wood they chop from trees they grew, do they get to keep it? What if they exchanged goods and services for the wood instead? What if they also exchanged goods and services to have someone else build it who needs the goods and services.
> have to work their whole lives, and convince hundreds of others to work with them, to create a chip fab, if they wanted to own one.
So? That’s how many of the successful chip fabs existed.
What’s your proposed alternative when 10,000 people want chip fabs and there are only 200 for you to steal? The government seizing them certainly doesn’t make more and it completely discouraged anybody from wanting to invest their time/labor/money into building new ones.
- tsimionescu 7y agoMy proposal is that no one person is entitled to own vastly expensive items that required the work of countless people to create. Those items should generally be collectively owned by the people who designed and built them. The profits from operating them should go to the people operating them (which includes marketing and sales people and whatever else is needed), in some democratically chosen percentage. I said nothing about the state in this. I am still talking exclusively about private property. And as for food, I believe people are entitled to life, and by implication to anything required to sustain it, such as food, medication, water, air etc. The exact means for realizing this entitlement (free food? UBI? I don't know) are not clear, but the fact that you can starve to death in a country with enough food to feed the whole medieval world is a travesty.
- imtringued 7y ago>The profits from operating them should go to the people operating them Well, economic theory says that the profits should approach zero as more and more competitors join the market and the provided goods or services become commodities. This effectively is a redistribution mechanism. The reality is a bit uglier. By the way, prevention of wealth accumulation doesn't require repossession of existing property. A simple redistribution policy could dictate that a single person is not allowed to inherit more than 50% of the wealth of their parents. This forces parents to have two children and split the wealth. After a few generations the children will have 25%, 12%, 6% of the original wealth and so on. There are still ways to exploit this if the siblings are colluding but let's be serious. If your family is rich and owns 50 billion dollars. Would you prefer $25 billion or $0 billion for the sake of higher generational wealth? My point is that you need to create policies that even rich people would agree with.
- ctdonath 7y agoNot yours to “not allow”.
- tsimionescu 7y agoAgreed, and I never mentioned repossession. I was taking about ideal notions of entitlement, not practical measures for realizing that entitlement.
- ctdonath 7y agoAs one who is not involved in creation or operation of “vastly expensive” items, you have no say in the matter. Those involved do have a say, that being accepting or rejecting contracted providence of goods or services, which may or may not involve co-ownership. Distribution of profits occurs by contracting. Democracy doesn’t apply because those not involved have no say. You are entitled to life insofar as nobody may actively take it from you. There is plenty opportunity in this country to earn; $1 per meal is enough for healthy comfort (thanks to capitalism, food is plentiful, varietal, and cheap).
- tsimionescu 7y agoIn an ideal world, they should have more of a say than 'take it or leave it'. And in fact, for most of human history, people who produced things did have more say than that. I was also talking about democratic governance among the worker-owners: this is how cooperatives work in general. The strict top-to-bottom autocracy of regular corporations is not the only possible system of governance for a successful market actor. As for food, it's not so much capitalism as enormous state subsidies that affect the price of food in America. And living on 2-3$ worth of food a day will not lead you to a long life. Also, how is someone refusing you the right to take food when you are starving not actively taking your life from you?
- ctdonath 7y agoYou would refuse a starving person your food? You have enough, why the compulsion to steal from others to “redistribute”?
- tsimionescu 7y agoI didn't talk about redistribution. I'm describing how a system could work from the ground up with a market economy but without any capitalists. How to get there is another discussion that is far more thorny. I wouldn't deny a starving person my food, though the reality is that I rarely come into contact with someone who is starving. On the other hand, a lot of restaurants and super markets do regularly deny starving people food - they ask for money in place of common human decency.