6 ms·
> I waited for a point in their model where people actually produced wealth and consumed it, made something or ate it, in addition to redistributing it. Not par
by taneq 7y ago
> I waited for a point in their model where people actually produced wealth and consumed it, made something or ate it, in addition to redistributing it. Not part of the model.
That’s because the people making the models don’t create wealth and don’t really understand where it comes from.
It’s like the way you see Marxists saying “seize the means of production” but never “build the means of production”.
- WilliamEdward 7y agoNot so sure you understand what means of production are. You cannot build more means of production without having access to means of production in the first place, hence the 'seizing' part.
- kortilla 7y agoYet all of the modern means of production stemmed from no means of production... hmmm. People create all of the time with extremely limited resources. Especially ones that haven’t been seized.
- pmiller2 7y agoHow would you go about building your own means of production for creating modern computers?
- taneq 7y agoIt took a large part of modern industry working cooperatively for decades to build the tooling to make ICs. If your commune wants to make a similar effort then there’s nothing stopping you. If you don’t then you’re not entitled to own a chip fab.
- tsimionescu 7y agoWhy is anyone entitled to own a chip fab? Why is some rich daughter entitled to own a chip fab? Because she is in the current system, while anyone else would have to work their whole lives, and convince hundreds of others to work with them, to create a chip fab, if they wanted to own one.
- kortilla 7y ago> Why is anyone entitled to own a chip fab? Why is anyone entitled to own food? If someone invests their resources to have something built (or help make it themselves), why wouldn’t they be entitled to own it? The rich daughter gets to own it because that’s what the owner wanted and the thing about owning something generally is deciding its fate. If someone builds themselves a house out of wood they chop from trees they grew, do they get to keep it? What if they exchanged goods and services for the wood instead? What if they also exchanged goods and services to have someone else build it who needs the goods and services. > have to work their whole lives, and convince hundreds of others to work with them, to create a chip fab, if they wanted to own one. So? That’s how many of the successful chip fabs existed. What’s your proposed alternative when 10,000 people want chip fabs and there are only 200 for you to steal? The government seizing them certainly doesn’t make more and it completely discouraged anybody from wanting to invest their time/labor/money into building new ones.
- tsimionescu 7y agoMy proposal is that no one person is entitled to own vastly expensive items that required the work of countless people to create. Those items should generally be collectively owned by the people who designed and built them. The profits from operating them should go to the people operating them (which includes marketing and sales people and whatever else is needed), in some democratically chosen percentage. I said nothing about the state in this. I am still talking exclusively about private property. And as for food, I believe people are entitled to life, and by implication to anything required to sustain it, such as food, medication, water, air etc. The exact means for realizing this entitlement (free food? UBI? I don't know) are not clear, but the fact that you can starve to death in a country with enough food to feed the whole medieval world is a travesty.
- tathougies 7y agoBut all humans of sufficient ability (except those with extreme mental handicap) have innate means of production. Even those who have lost use of their limbs have an innate means of production via their minds in the form of intellectual property. Honestly, even many with mental disability but physically capable are capable of producing value from relatively little.
- Klinky 7y agoYour bar is too low if you think that things are okay because "you can always become a starving artist".
- tathougies 7y agoNo need to starve. Just make something people want. You can do ghostwriting or content writing with few materials. You can become a personal assistant if you can answer a phone. You can, with labor, and ready materials(garbage for example) make a lot of things people want
- taneq 7y agoMore like “you can get a job and use the money you earn to buy tools.”
- Klinky 7y agoUnless the job you get doesn't provide enough money to buy these tools, or there is a general lack of labor opportunities. This is a reality for a large portion of the current population. So it's not an innate ability to create value really that matters, it's the ability to navigate a system with many gatekeepers who have entrenched interests, and where not everyone is starting from the same spot, but we should pretend they are, and pretend that all wealth accumulated is justified. Let's not question the means to that wealth or its ramifications on society as a whole.
- tathougies 7y ago
- sdfin 7y agoHow did the first means of production appear?
- hollerith 7y agoThe first capitalists stole it from the poor people :)