5 ms·
This is a lot more satisfying than just r > g, which although seeming to be well supported in a rather large book somehow is dissatisfying. Specifically, I was
by lordnacho 7y ago
This is a lot more satisfying than just r > g, which although seeming to be well supported in a rather large book somehow is dissatisfying. Specifically, I was looking for some kind of agent model like what this author is presenting here.
I've often thought about the "it's expensive to be poor" adage. What's interesting is he takes in this risk preference idea, in which you naturally expect the poor to have to be cede certain opportunities in order to secure further existence. I've played a lot of poker where you see this dynamic where the big stack guy can take chances and still win, and the cards (and skill) don't matter that much.
- notahacker 7y agor>g is broadly equivalent to the ζ parameter in this model I don't find the model itself especially compelling as a broad model of the economy myself, though it's nicely written exposition of how variance can wipe people out and largely agrees with my biases. The fact that a curve with three arbitrarily-set parameters can be made to fit empirical Lorenz curves doesn't particularly impress me, and the concept of rich people enriching themselves through wiping out poor people in zero sum trades as opposed to having the ability to transact with a lot more people in positive sum trades doesn't ring especially true of a modern economy.
- lordnacho 7y agoI don't see zero sum as so important as much as risk preference. Or you could call it risk necessity. The game can be positive sum, but if you're poor you have to play it a certain way that keeps you poor.
- notahacker 7y agoAgree with that, but that's better represented by modelling poor agents as systematically transferring small portions of their wealth to the rich rather than randomly losing or winning large portions of wealth.
- lordnacho 7y agoBut the randomness is what hides the transfer. Poor agents are forced to choose out of some set of bad outcomes. Some of them can win, but as a whole, no.
- viburnum 7y agoSugarscape is probably what you want.