10 ms·
Hmm... so, at first blush at least, this sounds like a pretty Big Deal, and a Good Thing. From the press release: Better World Books, the world’s leading soci
by mindcrime 7y ago
Hmm... so, at first blush at least, this sounds like a pretty Big Deal, and a Good Thing. From the press release:
Better World Books, the world’s leading socially conscious online bookseller, is now owned by Better World Libraries, a mission-aligned, not-for-profit organization that is affiliated with longtime partner the Internet Archive. This groundbreaking partnership will allow both organizations to pursue their collective mission of making knowledge universally accessible to readers everywhere. This new relationship will provide additional resources and newfound synergies backed by a shared enthusiasm for advancing global literacy. Together, the two organizations are expanding the digital frontier of book preservation to ensure books are accessible to all for generations to come.
This new relationship will allow Better World Books to provide a steady stream of books to be digitized by the Internet Archive, thereby growing its digital holdings to millions of books. Libraries that work alongside Better World Books will now make a bigger impact than ever. Any book that does not yet exist in digital form will go into a pipeline for future digitization, preservation and access.
Sounds good to me. Of course, there's a big difference between issuing a press release and actually doing something. It'll be interesting to see how this plays out in reality.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jjeaff 7y agoBetter World Books has in my experience been purposefully misleading about the structure and purpose of their business. They put book donation boxes everywhere that are covered in "save the children" style graphics and messages. But the reality is, they are a for profit company that very much enriched the owners while donating a very small percentage to charity. And it's one thing to have a corporation that does social good. But their entire business is based on receiving donated books from people who think they are donating to charity. They also make deals with public libraries to sell their books online and take a big cut. Which makes me suspicious of this new arrangement. So it is now a for profit corporation owned by a non-profit? Did the owners decide to reorganize or donate the whole business or something?
- ryana 7y agoAs a prior BWB employee (with no equity or outcome from this sale) I'm happy to respond to some of these concerns. "Very much enriched the owners" is quite a stretch. Especially considering pretty much every equity holder was wiped out ~5 years ago when they had to raise money to stay in business. The CEO lives in a house in central Indiana that costs less than the average 1BR condo in San Francisco. Before that he lived in a townhome in suburban Atlanta. This business is not and never has thrown off cash. At best they've made as much money in profit as they've donated, in cash, to literacy causes over the life of the business. A "very small percentage" donated to charity is up for debate based on everyone's belief of what that means, but all charity payments were made as a percentage of net sales revenue, which was essentially the money that came in from any sale. The only cost that was subtracted out was marketplace fees when selling on Amazon, ebay, etc. Sales percentage back to the book sources (academic and public libraries) and non-profit partners (on all sales from all sources) were paid out before shipping costs were even accounted for. "Their entire business is based on receiving donated books from people who think they are donating to charity" is not true. Drop box books accounted for < 10% of all books sourced and even less than that of revenue since those books are typically the lowest quality stream (slightly better title mix than thrift purchases, but much higher logistics cost and risk of spoilage). The business is almost entirely dependent on public and academic library partnerships. There were many, MANY monthly all hands meetings we sat in where the business lost money but wrote 6 or 7 figure checks to literacy partners. Donations were not a function of making money. BWB was a great company full of people who truly cared about the mission. Some people did well, but nobody got rich off this business. If they didn't move most of the corporate activity out of Atlanta and up to Indiana I would still have been happy to keep working there.
- rwmurrayVT 7y agoDo you know any one at Jenson Books or who the owner might be :) That's the biggest mystery from my entire time selling books on Amazon. They're by far and away the most frustrating seller in the marketplace. I truly despise them. They can't POSSIBLY make money on so much of their inventory without lower negotiated FBA rates from Amazon. It's not just a few like with BWB, but over 75% of their inventory seems entirely unreasonable to sell at their market price.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoMaybe it's just due to the current sociopolitical environment we are living in but "socially conscious" makes me wonder if they'll decide which books are worth preserving and which are not.
- mekarpeles 7y agoMek here from Internet Archive's OpenLibrary.org. We've thought carefully about this as well. We feel it's critical that Internet Archive and Better World Books aren't the only organizations involved in determining which books should be preserved. In late October, we launched a new program which allows anyone in the world to take control of our Library's shelves and contribute/sponsor the books which reflect their values: https://openlibrary.org/sponsorship https://openlibrary.org/sponsorship So far we've seen an influx of high quality reference books come in (everything from African antiquity to Microbial biology) that we almost certainly wouldn't have procured ourselves based solely on the data available from e.g. library holdings, wikipedia citations, etc. Having Better World Books as a partner has been incredibly helpful because we're able to calculate sponsorship prices quite accuracy (because shipping prices are included) which was a big challenge with other APIs we previously used. Also importantly, Better World Books helps our patrons sponsor older books which are often more at risk of disappearing, which is one (of many) useful heuristics when considering preservation.
- joveian 7y agoI suggest updating that FAQ to make it clear that you also accept direct book donations and linking to: https://openlibrary.org/bookdrive https://openlibrary.org/bookdrive
- toomuchtodo 7y agoIs the number of digital copies you can lend out limited by only how many physical books you have "dematerialized"? For example, if I shipped 10 used copies of a book to Open Library and you recorded you destroyed them, could you lend out 10 digital copies at a time?
- 7y ago