11 ms·
Passivhaus Detailing and Design
- adrianN 7y agoI don't understand why we don't mandate stricter energy efficiency for new buildings. Why is it still legal to rely on fossil fuels for heating for example?
- raxxorrax 7y agoIn some countries there are mandatory rules for new buildings. Most experts would tell you that they failed spectacularly. For a time styrofoam was recommended. Today you have difficulties to dispose that shit again. > Why is it still legal to rely on fossil fuels for heating for example? Because there are few alternatives. You can use wood, but that comes with its own problems.
- Tharkun 7y ago"We" do. But who "we" is, and how strict those rules are will depend heavily on where you are.
- ovi256 7y agoAn example given in this thread was that current Passivhaus practices specify that embodied energy (one time energy cost that goes into the materials and the construction) be no larger than 50 years of operating energy costs. Stricter energy eficiency means reducing operating energy costs. Reducing operating energy automatically reduces the allowable embodied energy budget. This limits how much energy you can spend upfront to improve efficiency with current techniques. We need better techniques. Increasing the number of years doesn't help that much, as it can lead quickly to a higher energy TCO than a conventional house, so why bother. Remember it's the energy TCO (total cost of ownership over project lifetime) that captures the full environmental impact of the house, as every MJ of energy - regardless if embodied or operating - translates into a known quantity of GHG emmissions, particle pollution, and so on. In a pleasant surprise, spending energy later (in energy costs, rather than embodied) is better than spending it today for the environment! Energy produced in the future will surely emmit less GHG and pollution than today (better techniques!), and the GHG will dwell less time in the athmosphere, so less compounding effects on the total temperature rise that we'll have at the end of this century. If you care about the environment, you have to consider the energy TCO.
- batushka3 7y agoEU has them, A++, A+, A, B etc. Depends on per country regulation which lowest can be build. For new projects I think it's A now most widespread.
- Heliosmaster 7y agoAs far as I understand, buildings (walls, ceiling, roof, etc.) mostly get to A. A/2 is achieved with photovoltaic panels on the roof, and A/3 with also thermal solar.
- m-i-l 7y agoIn the UK the plan is to eliminate the use of fossil fuel based heating in new homes by 2025, and convert existing homes by 2050[0]. Apparently "14% of UK greenhouse gases come from our homes, a similar level to emissions from cars. In major cities gas boilers are also a main source of nitrogen dioxide emissions."[1] [0] https://www.gov.uk/government/groups/heat-in-buildings https://www.gov.uk/government/groups/heat-in-buildings [1] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-50041077 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-50041077
- pbowyer 7y agoHaving researched this recently for a potential house purchase, there's a need for innovation before electric heating becomes a reality. The standard is still storage headers and other wall mounted electrical heaters. I remember those from childhood, and how happy we were to switch to gas-fired central heating. There are electric boilers which can power a hot-water based heating system; they are substantially more expensive to operate than current gas boilers (due to the UK price differential between gas and electricity). My most favoured approach is an air source heat pump, and larger radiators/underfloor heating to make use of the lower temperature heat source. More expensive to install and run than a gas fired central heating system. Perhaps in the house after next, this will be standard - or I might even be able to buy a Passivhaus.
- m-i-l 7y agoAlso had a look at electrical heating options again recently. Everywhere I've lived that burns fossil fuels to generate heat has been plagued by costly maintenance. At my current place, not unique to these issues, I've now spent an average of £175 a year on repairs (£1230 total over 7 years). In contrast, I lived for 10 years in a place with electrical heating and never had to do any maintenance whatsoever. Certainly gas is cheaper to run in terms of the price per unit of energy consumed, but if you factor in the maintenance and the hassle factor of taking time off to be in for the repair people, then I'm not convinced there's such a big difference. If you ask a boiler repair person about switching to electricity though, they'll say they strongly recommend against it, but part of me wonders if that's because they have a vested interest in keeping people using the high maintenance options. I used to joke that the only reliable thing about my boiler was the revenue stream it generated for the repair people. Underfloor electrical heating is apparently a lot more efficient than radiators, e.g. because you only need to run them at a much lower temperature. If you combine with things like ground source heat pumps and solar panels, the electric heating proposition looks a lot more appealing. That said, the conclusion I came to is that for an old place that doesn't otherwise need major work, it just isn't worth the expense of making the switch. It might be that if I were to move somewhere that needed a complete refurbishment anyway, then I would. Even then, with most homes, at least in cities like London, being flats rather than houses, then things like solar panels and heat pumps become much more difficult if not impossible to arrange.
- fyfy18 7y agoAt least in the EU it is in the process of being mandated: https://ec.europa.eu/energy/en/topics/energy-efficiency/energy-performance-of-buildings/nearly-zero-energy-buildings https://ec.europa.eu/energy/en/topics/energy-efficiency/ener... The actual implementation is left up to individual countries. In my country, Lithuania, it means from 2021 all new houses require insulation to be at the same level as Passivhaus, and buildings to obtain the majority of their energy from renewable sources (so most new houses will have PV installed). It gets cold here in the winter (-20c isn't uncommon), so if it can work here, it can work pretty much anywhere in Europe. As can be expected this will push the price of new builds up, but the benefits are a more comfortable and healthy environment (I grew up in drafty & moldy houses in the UK) and lower energy costs (grid-tied PV installations, without a battery, usually pay back in 7 to 10 years, after which they provide free energy for the life of the system). Edit: I should mention the prices will not rise in a significant way. Materials for the structure/building envelope are usually a small part of construction costs, and those required for Passivehaus are not expensive or hard to obtain. Of course propery developers will complain, as the extra cost will come out of their profit margin :-)
- skybrian 7y agoThere was going to be a net-zero energy standard in California for new houses, but it's not clear to me what happened. Apparently they decided that solar panels shouldn't generate more power than needed by the house? This FAQ has an answer that doesn't seem to say yes or no: https://ww2.energy.ca.gov/title24/2019standards/documents/2018_Title_24_2019_Building_Standards_FAQ.pdf https://ww2.energy.ca.gov/title24/2019standards/documents/20...
- specialist 7y agoI now prefer performance standards, auto incrementing, at a predictable rate. Let the various industries figure out how to attain those standards. https://www.vox.com/energy-and-environment/2019/5/31/18646906/climate-change-california-energy-efficiency https://www.vox.com/energy-and-environment/2019/5/31/1864690... Like applying the Toyota Production System to A/E/C. Better improvement at a faster rate, without the inevitable recurring food fights (lawsuits).
- im3w1l 7y agoThe obvious answer is cost. How long do you want young people to live with their parents to save up for the efficiency improvements you propose? How much longer should their mortgage be? How many people become unable to afford one at all and have to live on the street? I have a friend who is a building a house by himself. I think that's really cool. If you set standards too high that wont be possible. Finally bureaucracy sucks. Even an "obvious" regulation that all houses follows like "your house has to have a roof" has the potential to become seriously annoying if you have to get an inspector who is only available in a month and only on Mondays 9-10, to take a look and write a statement that your house indeed does have a roof.
- ip26 7y agoThe sad thing is the cost is recouped in energy savings very quickly, and there's never a better time to add inexpensive subslab insulation than right before you pour the slab.
- im3w1l 7y agoDon't get me wrong, I agree there are a lot of arguments in favor of building efficient houses!
- notJim 7y agoI feel like housing cost is driven more by land use policy than by efficiency standards (or building codes.) This must be something people have researched though.
- runxel 7y agoThere are even two subsequent standards: the Nullenergiehaus (zero energy building) and the Plusenergiehaus, which is better by having the ability to generate more electric energy than it needs. However, those buildings are not as amazing as they might look. The "better" the standard, the greater the effort. What people didn't really took into account was the energy needed to actually build the house is becoming very large. At this point it takes the same amount of energy (embodied energy, called grey energy in Germany) to erect a Passivhaus as it will need operating over the next 50 years.
- the_mitsuhiko 7y ago> energy needed to actually build the house is becoming very large Why is it becoming larger? I would have assumed that we would use less energy rather than more to build buildings nowadays given the advances in technology.
- roel_v 7y agoBecause you need all sorts of technology, and lots of materials that need high energy inputs to be manufactured.
- ntp85 7y agoDo you have a source on that?
- stewbrew 7y agoYou need permanent ventilation, better heat insulation, better doors and windows etc. for this to work. You still have to plan for some way of heating so you cannot just leave that out. This in all takes more energy to build and maintain. That said, I live in a passive house and we turn on the heating only when one of us is sick or when it gets really cold.
- the_mitsuhiko 7y ago
- geff82 7y agoInteresting that this comes up now in 2019. I'd say, while a Passivhaus is not the standard in Germany yet, you can simply go and buy one, like you can choose a special version of a car and simply order it. Passivhaus is still cool, but nothing extraordinary from the future.
- jayalpha 7y agoIt comes with several disadvantages. Like no air circulation (except air condition, what is probably a must in such a house), mold problems etc. ...
- n1000 7y agoThat is simply wrong. The passive house standard requires ventilation systems with highly efficient heat exchangers. This makes for good air quality. The massive thermal insulation ensures that no condensation occurs in the interior, i.e. no mold problems. A common problem, however (esp. if inexperienced planners design the house) is too dry indoor climate in winter. This happens if air change rates are too high and no humidity is recovered.
- bipson 7y agoThe regulations for Passivhäuser (or houses with the respective efficiency rating) in fact require a ventilation system with heat recovery (since the otherwise necessary open-the-windows-like-a-savage-system wastes too much energy). These nowadays come typically with moisture recovery (which arguably not always works well enough, depends on how much you still need to heat).
- n1000 7y agoMany governments, such as the EU have decided Zero Energy Buildings as a target for 2020. Those are basically passive houses with PV systems. Hence they produce the same amount or a surplus of energy as is being used throughout the year.
- n1000 7y agoNot from the future, but for the future: In 30 years from now (2050) we should be carbon neutral in order to have a shot at the 1.5° C target. Average building lifetime is >30 years. So in my opinion it would be irresponsible to build anything else than a passive house or a zero energy building today.
- Gravityloss 7y agoAir tightness can easily be a problem. Something gets wet and can never dry out. There is mold. The only solution is to dismantle the structure. One problem with complex buildings is the limited average skill of the builders and variable quality control in the business. Building technology should take that into account. Probably one reason is the volatile nature of the business - you have to hire anyone you can get because everyone else is building too at the same time. So I guess if one were to "disrupt" construction, one would have to start from the financing...
- supermatt 7y agoIt sounds like you are confusing air-tight (draught free) and breathable (vapour permeable). These are the passivhaus definitions.
- Gravityloss 7y agoI guess I am.
- myspy 7y agoHence why you either need the ventilation or you need to manually open windows a couple of times a day. Building with stone and materials for insulation that allow no diffusion are a problem too. Builders need to conform to rules and norms of course.
- bradfa 7y agoSeems like there'd be a market opportunity to automate or at least create an assembly line for constructing the most at-risk parts of buildings. Or to make systems which might cost more in materials but assemble correctly with low skilled labor quickly. I'm sure there's lots of this already going on. New houses built recently near me have all the walls delivered on a truck preassembled, but the skill and quality of the assembly teams from house to house has been interesting to watch from afar.
- Gravityloss 7y ago
- choeger 7y agoSadly it looks like that idea is not that sustainable. A Passivhaus (well, every current Niedrigenergiehaus, actually) is a very complicated matter and comes with some intrinsic problems: > Airtight design resulting in draught free construction That airtight design leads to problems with mold if you have any cold spots. These spots can occur due to construction faults, material faults, or any kind of acquired damage. For instance, you might not even notice that your windows do not shut exactly as they were supposed to after a few years. In the end, the repair of such a complicated design is again very complicated (especially after a decade or two have passed and technology has again advanced), expensive, and error-prone. So for me, I'd rather prefer to take an existing, robust and dry building, insulate it somewhat (especially roof and windows) and put in a regenerative heat source (wood, electric) but not to focus too much on the actual energy needed.
- sourcesmith 7y agoThe mechanical ventilation with heat recovery deals with the humidity problem.
- Gibbon1 7y agoWhat if I don't want to live in a plastic box?
- sourcesmith 7y agoWhat plastic box would that be?
- Gibbon1 7y agoAll the closed cell plastic foam needed to meat passive house requirements. A point. All the energy savings disappear the moment you open a window.
- sourcesmith 7y agoI think this has already been addressed by the sibling comment to my question. Insulation does not have to impermeable. Its purpose to prevent the loss of air carrying heat with it, not the transfer of moisture/humidity.
- dr_faustus 7y agoWhile not entirely "passive", houses built to the KfW 40 Plus standard in Germany are pretty close (without some of the inconveniences of a real Passivhaus)
- scotty79 7y agoWhat are the inconveniences of Passivehaus?
- buboard 7y agoIs this kind of design fit for non-german climates?
- grzm 7y agoFrom the article: > Some estimates suggest there are well over 50,000 Passivhaus buildings around the world. They have been successfully built in European climates, the US and Canada along with warm Asian climates where there is a requirement for cooling.
- upofadown 7y agoYes but the amount of insulation required to meet the requirement is climate dependent. That means that the building methods for achieving the requirement might not exist yet in some places in the world.
- adwww 7y agoThe new Austrian embassy in Jakarta is Passivhaus certified, a first for that climate. http://www.passivhaustrust.org.uk/news/detail/?nId=527 http://www.passivhaustrust.org.uk/news/detail/?nId=527
- raxxorrax 7y ago> The Passivhaus has a continuous airtight barrier [...] Theoretically that could work with a reliable air conditioner. In practice, I know quite a few passive houses that have problems with mold. And seriously, no air conditioner is superior to opening windows, don't kid yourself. A "normal" house with a good insulation (don't overdo it) would be my preference.
- neilwilson 7y agoPassivhaus isn't a passive house. It has Mechanical Heat Recovery Ventilation as standard. And if you're in warmer climes, air cooling rather than air heating. But yes, the windows do open.
- AliAdams 7y agoApologies for the tangent, but I'm interested; Are there problems with over-doing insulation?
- raxxorrax 7y agoThere can be of the same nature if there is not enough air circulation so that the walls get mold.
- fyfy18 7y agoThere's nothing wrong with over-insulating (although at a certain point it is no longer economical), but you need to ensure the house is ventilated to prevent mold. You also need to ensure you choose the correct building materials, so they can ventilate themselves. Modern building science says there should be a continuous airtight wrap around a house with insulation either side. The interior insulation ventilates to the inside, and the exterior ventilates to the outside. What you don't want is multiple airtight layers as that could cause it to become moldy inside the layers. Passivhaus houses will almost always have a heat-recovery ventilation system. These will bring in fresh air and take out stale air - like a bathroom fan. But they also exchange heat from the outgoing to income air in the process. Typically 80%+ of the heat is recovered (you can get systems that are 95% efficient). They run at a low speed so consume minimal electricity (typically under 100W for small houses) and don't provide a noticeable draft like air conditioning or forced-air heating. They have filters to prevent pollen and other contaminants from entering your house, so for allergy suffers they are a big plus. I live in a cold climate in an apartment built in 2015, which is well insulated and has this system. Even though it has been below freezing (currently 8c) outside, we haven't yet needed to turn on our heating because of how well the building is insulated. We do actually have a typical vented bathroom fan, but everything else (kitchen hood and dryer) are unvented, so we keep all that heat inside.
- neilwilson 7y agoJust bought a brand new house here in the UK and the house has a SAP designed footprint of 85kw/m2/a compared to the Passivhaus standard of 15kw/m2/a. Unfortunately I have no choice. Unlike in Germany I don't get to buy the land and pick the builder. The two come bundled in the UK. And will do until we get political change that breaks up the building oligopoly.
- brnt 7y agoHere in NL the two are also usually inseparable (you buy a house from a large project, typically 100+ homes/apartments, sometimes even 1000+). But, just looking around our two countries, it just seems requirements in the UK must be lower. The average house just seems less well built.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoThere were some improvements on the way but when the current Conservative government came in they scrapped them at the behest of the big builders.
- bipson 7y agoThis can happen in DE and AT as well, especially in expensive regions. Developers simply have the money/the better leverage by buying in bulk. Then there are developers that simply sell you the (tiny) lot for a premium, and let you choose between something they arrange, or building yourself. And the good lots are always gone long before the project is announced anyway.
- aries1980 7y agoI was thinking on buying a land in the UK and buy a prefab/kit house that cost about £2000-£3200/sqm . Did you consider that option? Why did you reject it?
- neilwilson 7y agoIt's really difficult to get the land, and the planning, in an area you'd want to live.
- upofadown 7y agoPeople tend to confuse the passivhaus idea with other energy efficient methods. The passivhaus idea is that if the building has sufficient insulation and is air tight, you can use the air from the heat recovery ventilation system to do any required heating cooling. This simplifies the mechanical part of the system. As a result, such houses are very well ventilated when it is cold outside. Mould is not a problem. The potential problem is instead excess dryness in places where it gets very cold.
- cookieswumchorr 7y agoit becomes dry inside no matter how you ventilate or heat, if it happens through a vent system with heat exchanger, there are built-in humidifiers for these
- upofadown 7y agoThere is a second problem in cold places that comes from the humidity you add on the air intake. The heat exchanger has to deal with that moisture freezing on the exhaust side. There are methods for doing this but none of them are ideal.
- mlang23 7y agoI can confirm the excessive dryness problem. My gf moves to a passivhaus a few years ago, and I had real trouble with cry eyes during the night. After a year, I sort of adjusted, but it definitely doesnt feel very healthy.
- throw0101a 7y ago> I can confirm the excessive dryness problem. You just need to cook more pasta: large pots of boiling water. :) More seriously: a very airtight house, which is generally desirable, does need a properly balance HVAC system. In some climate zones this means perhaps having a humidifier and in other zones a dehumidifier. Most people only think about furnaces and air conditioners when considering HVAC, but those mostly deal with temperature. Humidity has to be considered separately, often by different equipment.
- donquichotte 7y agoI remember seeing a very different approach with a very similar goal in Vietnam. In Hanoi, many houses have a small greenhouse-like glass structure on the roof. The greenhouse has a chimney. When the sun is shining, it gets hot in the greenhouse and the hot air escapes through the chimney. A hatch through the roof into the greenhouse draws new air from below, essentially creating a passive, sun-powere air-flow through the whole house, bottom-to-top. Usually some windows on ground level are left open to let air in.
- buckthundaz 7y agoFYI this is called a "solar chimney" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_chimney https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_chimney
- chmaynard 7y agoIn 2016, I moved from California to Rhode Island to build a Passive House. It was completed and certified by PHIUS, the American PH standards organization, in 2017. https://www.corememory.io/this-new-house https://www.corememory.io/this-new-house
- Nasrudith 7y agoI know it is a fringe case relative to the lifetime but I am curious how well the designs handle power extended power outages and say high ambient temperatures compared to other house types.
- n1000 7y agoThermal insulation helps to decouple indoor climate from the outdoor climate. It depends a bit on what kind of heat period you consider. When high ambient temperatures occur it will remain cool for longer indoor and night ventilation can be used to cool the house. The cold produced by the AC is also better trapped inside, ie used more effectively. There has been a case of extended power outage in Germany due to heavy snowfall. I saw a report that showed how the indoor temperature remained almost constant for the first two days of the outage.
- n1000 7y agoGiven that we should be carbon neutral in 30 years from now (2050) in order to have a shot at the 1.5° C target and given that average building lifetime is >30 years, it would be irresponsible to build anything else than a passive house or a zero energy building today.
- nebulousmenace 7y agoThere's a countermovement, the "Pretty Good House" idea ( https://www.greenbuildingadvisor.com/article/pretty-good-house-2-0 https://www.greenbuildingadvisor.com/article/pretty-good-hou... .) It has the goals like "simplicity" and "avoiding diminshing returns" (the 80-20 rule: 20% of the work gets you 80% of the improvements, in this case.) It avoids certification and excessive rigor. (One article about it mentioned the split between Passivhaus and Passive House. As I recall it was over the amount of shading from one southern tree.) My point, if any, is that it's not "Passivhaus or nothing."
- simonsarris 7y agoOh thank god. This is the approach I had when I built my house. This is IMO the most desirable territory: Just try to maximize the easy assets of wind and light using traditional methods, and add in modern insulation. Few(???) architects and zero builders seem to understand light/wind/circulation like people apparently intuitively did 200 years ago. You might be better off with the average curious engineer designing a house after reading a couple books than the average architect. Everyone is astonishingly lazy, even mansions around here have terrible light/circulation problems. But if you care, you can totally design a good one yourself that has very low operating costs (our electric bills are 50-80 a month in a 2200sqft house. We use maybe 3 cords of wood a year, but that's very approximate). It does not take a lot of work to design a house, especially if you want to build an efficient Colonial style. My goals were simple: Build something that appears traditional, maximizes light and airflow and wood burning heat. Think about ventilation passageways as the windows and doors, and think of the wind as coming and going. Since heating is easier than cooling (we built in no AC system and zero ducting), make your ceilings taller. A little wood stove (Vermont Castings Encore) heats the whole thing. Spray foam insulation in the walls (plus fiberglass), tall ceilings, and modern windows (lots of them) is all you need. Some pics of what I built, with design sketches: https://twitter.com/simonsarris/status/1183143604925190144 https://twitter.com/simonsarris/status/1183143604925190144
- pbowyer 7y ago> Few(???) architects and zero builders seem to understand light/wind/circulation like people apparently intuitively did 200 years ago. You might be better off with the average curious engineer designing a house after reading a couple books than the average architect. Any book recommendations, especially around wind/circulation?
- danans 7y agoA more general learning we can take from Passivhaus building techniques is that habitable buildings should be designed to work in conjunction with the natural environment they inhabit, like they used to be before the era of cheap fossil fuels. But such site and solar-orientation aware design isn't today part of the practice of building mass produced homes, and absent forces that push that industry that way, things aren't likely to change.
- rebuilder 7y agoHow does a passivhaus maintain airtightness in the face of e.g. rodent incursions?