5 ms·
Maybe this is my uninformed opinion but I think the state should own the poles at least. Pole real estate is a natural monopoly that we subsidize anyway and it
by jayd16 7y ago
Maybe this is my uninformed opinion but I think the state should own the poles at least. Pole real estate is a natural monopoly that we subsidize anyway and it empowers existing entities to stifle new competition. It also makes sense to me that such a thing should be tied to city planning.
In a perfect world power consumers and producers can just buy and sell into the marketplace as provided through the public lines. That's a long ways off because the grid just isn't that smart but maybe one day we'll get there.
- vkou 7y agoThe reason the state doesn't own the poles is that by allowing a private company to own them, the state doesn't have to finance their construction up-front. The downside is that the taxpayers are now forever on the hook of paying shareholder dividends for electricity. The best outcome in this whole situation is that PG&E is sued into bankruptcy and nationalized, leaving the shareholders with nothing. Owning a government-protected monopoly-utility that is bad at its job should not be a license to print money, regardless whether or not you ponied up some cash up front. Sometimes, you make bad investments.
- nerfhammer 7y agoThe CPUC (state regulators) already stipulate literally how much money PG&E is allowed to make, i.e. target profit margin. PG&E isn't state-owned but is largely not allowed to make its own decisions. Especially since the CPUC is not widely understood, this structure allows elected officials to present themselves as not being responsible for the tradeoffs PG&E has to make, even as the CPUC actually makes those decisions for them.
- Teknoman117 7y agoThis. Nearly all of the situations we've found ourselves in, be it power, internet, water, etc. are because we allow companies to have local monopolies over distribution systems, because we don't want to pay for the infrastructure up front, or take loans out as a towns. It's a lot easier as a politician to say that someone else will pay for something than to say that we as a municipality are going to issue 10 year bonds or something so that we can fund an infrastructure project. We then freak out 10 years down the line when we realize we're stuck with a bad system because we sold ourselves out.
- AcerbicZero 7y agoI mean, you're probably right that having California "nationalize" (State-ilize?) their power company is the answer to this, but being as the political system is what created this problem, I'm not exactly convinced its going to solve it any better this time.
- scrumbledober 7y agoI've always struggled with using the term nationalization for state level control, but it is technically correct for any governmental control.
- wpietri 7y agoWhy not? Public ownership of highways and water systems works well enough.
- stickfigure 7y agoThe residents of Flint, Michigan might disagree.
- labster 7y agoIn California we don't let the political equivalents of script kiddies run our water system because it turns out water is super important in semi-arid climates. Too many stakeholders care too much about it. That causes its own problems, but at least we're not letting complete novices decide engineering problems.
- wpietri 7y agoOne, that's exceptional, so it's a bad way to make policy. It's like saying, "Because Theranos, we should end capitalism." Two, Flint's water system ran fine until it was removed from local control and given to ideological white Republicans to run. Since this discussion is about shifting to local control from a state-scale entity, Flint may work better as an example for the change.
- rayiner 7y ago
- dickeytk 7y agoDo they have to go bankrupt? Can’t the state just pass laws to force them to quit operating? Sort of like eminent domain (or maybe exactly?) I’m sure they’d have to make reasonable payments to the shareholders, but it’s not like PG&E is in a very good bargaining position here
- antisthenes 7y agoQuit operating? Who's going to provide power to 16 million customers in California?
- dickeytk 7y agoThere is no need to be dense, of course I mean not straight away. I’m just saying there is a path where the government can take over the utility that doesn’t require waiting until PG&E goes completely bankrupt.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoYeah, rending infrastructure and operational authority to 3rd parties seems like the best compromise IMO. You can not renew contracts when service is not satisfactory and any lawsuits are on the operator, not the taxpayer.
- SamReidHughes 7y agoMaybe the state could provide and control brush-clearing services that do what PG&E was supposed to be doing, and mandate their purchase. If some convicts can do fire-fighting, they could do this as well. Just spitballing here.
- nerfhammer 7y agovetoed! https://www.gov.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/AB-1516-Veto-Message.pdf https://www.gov.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/AB-1516-Ve...
- denkmoon 7y agoWhat a cop out! "Every situation is different". Yet in every situation, money is the lubricant needed to make changes and meet those fire protection needs.
- nerfhammer 7y agoIt's essentially saying that local communities should decide how flammable they want to be
- calithrower 7y agoThe peril of democracy is the tyranny of the uneducated masses.
- snovv_crash 7y agoAs a counterpoint, it is much easier to corrupt a few politicians than a majority of the population.
- calithrower 7y agoThe politicians are corrupt, the people are just manipulated. The difference is the politicians know they are doing wrong.
- kevingadd 7y agoAn interesting related problem is that even if you set up your own solar or wind power on your property, PG&E charges fees and higher rates when connecting to the grid. Supposedly this is to fund important programs for low-income users or something, but you'd think you would save money by contributing to the grid. If local municipalities or the state own the poles, you can have a better incentive system where homeowners hooking up well-maintained solar/wind to the grid helps keep the grid humming and lowers costs for everyone.
- vkou 7y ago> but you'd think you would save money by contributing to the grid. You actually don't. When you are generating most of your own power during renewable generation peaks, and drawing power from the grid, during renewable lulls/peak usage, you are in fact using the grid as a giant, personal battery. (One that would run you in the order of ~$50,000, if you were to build one out for yourself.) Electricity is relatively cheap, especially during peak renewable generation times. Maintaining the grid is what's expensive.
- imtringued 7y agoI don't understand where you get your $50,000 figure from. You can get 8 Powerwalls for that price for a total of 108kWh of energy storage. I don't know what Americans are doing all day to consume 4500kWh per capita (residential energy usage) but even with such a high rate of energy consumption that setup has enough storage to keep running for days during a grid outage. I live alone and consume less than that so this system could keep the lights on for slightly more than 2 weeks. Buffering solar power with such a setup feels like a joke.
- calithrower 7y ago"The worst form of capitalism is one which bestows all of the benefit to the private sector while forcing all of the risk on the public sector." -- Adam Smith. Over the past 50 years PG&E has made a game out of mis-managing the transmission infrastructure, selling it to the state, then buying it back at a discount. California needs to own the entire utility and not just keep giving it un-warranted subsidies and gifts. All PG&E executives should be imprisoned for the hundreds of people they have murdered in the past decade between their fires and the San Bruno explosion. It is never in the best interest of the people to give critical public infrastructure to rent seeking flam-flam artists.
- brobdingnagians 7y agoTo my knowledge, in France, the national road systems are private (but weren't always) and charge massive tolls, but maintenance is paid for by contracts from the government. So all of the private owners of the roads also run sister companies that do maintenance. The government pays exorbitant prices to the companies to do maintenance for the roads that they then also make large amounts of toll from. I'm not saying I fully support private roads or public roads, but the worst combination is a little bit of both...
- ptah 7y ago"autoroutes belong to the French state and their administration to semi-private companies." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autoroutes_of_France https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autoroutes_of_France
- Leherenn 7y agoTo make it even worse, they were built using taxpayer's money, then sold for peanuts to those companies. It's corruption at an astronomical scale.
- rayiner 7y agoMaybe. But private companies own the poles and transmission grids in many countries. You don’t see these problems in the U.K., Spain, etc. (Or for that matter in Maryland, New York, or Illinois.) People calling for nationalization are focusing on the wrong thing. For the reasons you mention, utilities need regulation. Both government ownership and rate regulated private monopolies are a model that works routinely around the world. The ownership structure therefore can’t be the reason for PG&E’s problems. The problem instead seems to be California. PG&E was heavily regulated by the CPUC the whole time. What was CPUC doing wrong that the regulators in Germany, Spain, not to mention other US states are doing right? Bigger picture, why is it California that seems to suffer from all of these problems? Among the worst schools in the country. Housing prices out of control. Massive failed investments in public infrastructure? Cities running out of water?
- sangnoir 7y ago> You don’t see these problems in the U.K., Spain, etc. (Or for that matter in Maryland, New York, or Illinois.) Because they don't have a PG&E in those places. Maybe the problem is with the culture at PG&E and not with the regulators? I can't figure out if your argument is that there wasn't enough regulation in California or there was too much of it.
- eecc 7y agoThat’s how it works in NL; the power grid is owned by a separate entity (I think a consortium, not sure whether regional or national.) The cable and fiber networks are also separate and - lo! Behold! - the water management company board is even an elected body! And NL is the least “socialist” place I’ve even known
- rayiner 7y agoThe Dutch electric grid is mostly privatize, both retail and energy production. A publicly owned company manages the high voltage production lines. (But publicly owned companies in Europe often behave very much like privately owned ones. For example, TenneT, the Dutch high voltage grid operator, has a subsidiary that manages part of the grid in Germany. It issues annual statements reporting profits: https://annualreport.tennet.eu/2018/annualreport/userfiles/pdf/TenneT-Financial-Statements-2018.pdf https://annualreport.tennet.eu/2018/annualreport/userfiles/p.... It just so happens that the Dutch government owns all the shares.)
- eecc 7y agoCorrect, indeed the local distribution grid is owned and operated by private companies but these are separate from the energy operators.