7 ms·
It never ceases to amaze one just how tone-deaf big companies can be. Smart managers at Krispy-Kreme would have been all over this: looking to include this guy
by mindcrime 7y ago
It never ceases to amaze one just how tone-deaf big companies can be. Smart managers at Krispy-Kreme would have been all over this: looking to include this guy in ads, touting the way Krispy Kreme is helping one hard working student pay for college, living the American Dream, etc., etc. The good-will alone would have been something you couldn't buy if you tried.
Instead, they totally screwed the pooch and hurt their brand, their customers, and the hard working college kid aspiring for the American Dream. Way to go, Krispy Kreme.
- hnspirit 7y agoIt's an American story as old as boomers!
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThey didn't see how great that was for their product and brand. They just saw that this guy's profit didn't go to them...
- joezydeco 7y agoYou know normally I would agree with this sentiment, but we're talking about food that's being shipped in unsealed boxes. I can totally see KK's side of this problem. It's sad to say in the scope of modern society, but how can you trust that this kid is actually selling you legitimate (and, without getting off track, unadulterated) Krispy Kreme donuts when he pulls up in your town? What damage would this do to the brand if the person turned out to be a bad actor? If you were the CEO of Krispy Kreme, would you err on the side of caution and stop something before it gets out of hand? A good friend of mine is a restaurant owner and he has a similar gripe about GrubHub and delivery services of this ilk. They bring the food cold, late, and mangled and now the restaurant's reputation is damaged instead of blaming GrubHub for how it was treated in transit.
- foxyv 7y agoIt would be cool if restaurants could take a picture of the food as it goes out and send it to the consumer. "Hey your food just went out. Look how good it is!" Then when the delivery driver crushes it with something they can take the heat.
- mindcrime 7y agoWhat damage would this do to the brand if the person turned out to be a bad actor? If you were the CEO of Krispy Kreme, would you err on the side of caution and stop something before it gets out of hand? Fair point, but people already trust strangers to deliver their food by using GrubHub, Postmates, Uber Eats, etc. Anyway, maybe the "right thing to do" for KK was not to just turn a blind eye and ignore the whole thing, but one can't help but suspect that they could have found a better way to deal with this, that would have been more of a "win-win". Worst case, buy the kid off behind the scenes, pay him to appear in an ad or two, and then quietly shut down his service. Surely they could have some up with something that didn't portray this "$BIGCORP uses it's army of lawyers to smash the little guy" pattern...
- joezydeco 7y agoTo me, using the kid in any kind of publicity is basically hanging a banner that says "you too can make money cross-shipping our product!", which is probably not what KK corporate wants. In my view using the big hammer was necessary to stop it before it got out of control. Sure, it's brand-damaging as well, but we all have short memories these days when it comes to the Global TCP/IP Outrage Generator. It probably would piss off the franchisees too. They're the ones that paid big money for exclusive sales territories and (contractually) don't want those boundaries crossed by others.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agothis insoluble argument is between those who see opportunity and those who see risk, we love and admire those who see opportunity and we dislike those who see risk, until that risk becomes active, in which case we punish those who did not guard against it adequately. Can't have it both ways I guess, although I am probably most often on the side of those who see opportunity that tendency has come back to bite me at times.
- zaroth 7y agoBeautiful comment, insoluble barrier adds alliteration.
- scohesc 7y agoI would be comfortable with making a statement saying "we don't condone this, we can't guarantee the quality or sanitation levels of the food." Done. How in the hell would Krispy Kreme be responsible for this guy reselling doughnuts? He's literally filling a niche market that the company chose not to fill.
- patio11 7y agoHow in the hell would Krispy Kreme be responsible for this guy reselling doughnuts? Their agent, the franchisee, has actual knowledge of his intent for the 100 boxes of donuts he routinely buys. Now that they know that, they can't un-know that. There's a real risk that, in the event of a controversy, serious people will not describe this as "a niche Krispy Kreme chose not to full" but "the mechanism by which Krispy Kreme chose to fill the niche." Which is not totally unfair; their agent is taking active steps to facilitate this.
- lmilcin 7y agoA lot of food is shipped in unsealed boxes. Bread, meat, fruits and vegetables. Have you ever seen the horror of grains growing on OPEN field and then transported on OPEN truck and then processed UNWASHED?
- somehnguy 7y agoIs that really Krispy Kremes problem? If I buy some waffles from the (definitely not sanctioned by any corp) random waffle stand next to the local bar who do I blame with the syrup is bad? Not Aunt Jemima, I blame the guy running the waffle stand. Same if I go to Walmart and buy bananas that turn out to be rotten. I don't blame whoever grew the bananas, I blame the local Walmart. If you don't trust that the kid is selling legit donuts then don't buy from him, its pretty simple. I don't think KK should have any say in the matter, hes just buying donuts. What he does with them after that is none of their business as far as I am concerned. You can buy and resell anything you want if the market for it exists.
- travisgriggs 7y agoI get what you're saying... but it doesn't make sense in this case. Back in the early days of Krispy Kreme, this kind of thing was defacto standard way to get Krispy Kreme donuts as everyone in rural communities made runs to metropolitan areas to get boxes of donuts to sell on corners and in WalMart parking lots for fund raisers for every type of youth organization possible. I've noticed I see less of that now, as the number of stores has gone way up and novelty of importing the cool rare donut has worn off. But I still see it a little. If food safety were ever an issue, this company would have died a long time ago.
- scarface74 7y agoHow can you be sure that the non profits who distribute Krispy Kreme Donuts in the same unsealed boxes that sell them as fundraisers with Krispy Kreme’s blessings aren’t selling unadulterated products? https://s3.amazonaws.com/Fundraising_KKD/2015KKCIFUNDRAISINGFrequentlyAskedQuestions.pdf https://s3.amazonaws.com/Fundraising_KKD/2015KKCIFUNDRAISING...
- jjeaff 7y agoExactly. And how can I be sure that the CEO of Krispy Kreme hasn't ordered that all doughnuts be poisoned?!?!?
- TeMPOraL 7y agoYou can never be sure. But you can estimate probabilities. I wouldn't even be worried about intentional poisoning - just pathogens introduced by improper food handling.
- scarface74 7y agoAnd how is that different than when people do it for fundraising? They pick up the donuts from KK and sell them somewhere else?
- jacobwilliamroy 7y agoI think Krispy Kreme will be okay no matter what donut man does. It's worth hundreds of millions, it has 4300 employees, operates in multiple countries, it has been around for nearly a century. In a "rogue donut man" scenario, I think Krispy Kreme would do fine because it already has employees or contractors who talk to the press and argue with the public on corporate social media. As for your friend's opinions about grubhub, if his restaurant is a similar size to Krispy Kreme - i.e. international franchise, over $500 million revenue - then I could have an easier time imagining that his fears align perfectly with the fears of c-level execs at Krispy Kreme; right now I just don't know if your friend really reflects the conciousness of Krispy Kreme's high-muck-a-mucks because I don't know if the two companies are equally vulnerable to internet slander.
- gremlinsinc 7y agoa disgruntled pizza delivery person could put rat poison in your pizza if you're not a good tipper. There's plenty of opportunity to do so. I'm sure some bad pizzas have been delivered and have been tampered by bad employees one way or another. You can't control everything. Would've probably been better for them to create some sort of on-the-books business association, make him sign a contract or something and follow some protocols on food handling to deliver as good a product as possible.
- jiofih 7y agoIt should simply not be the company’s responsibility? You have no obligation after sale. Anyone can walk into any store, buy a box of donuts, the turn around and resell them on the street.
- twblalock 7y ago> Anyone can walk into any store, buy a box of donuts, the turn around and resell them on the street And when something goes wrong, anyone could blame the donut shop. It doesn't matter if those people are right or wrong -- the donut shop could lose business either way.
- goatinaboat 7y agowithout getting off track, unadulterated What do you mean by this? I assume you’re not into drugs - I’m not either - but no one is sneaking free cocaine into donuts, I guarantee it
- icebraining 7y agoHow many dollars do you have behind that guarantee?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deadmetheny 7y agoDo you have any idea how expensive drugs are? I assure you nobody is spiking people's food with them.
- goatinaboat 7y agoExactly, it’s the same as worrying that whey powder is spiked with steroids.
- SN76477 7y agoOne word Liability They are so obsessed that something could go wrong it takes a team of lawyers. I hope they can’t stop him. That would be really nice.
- CamperBob2 7y agoI don't see how they could possibly stop him, under the First Sale Doctrine. About the only avenue of attack would be to rat him out to the state as an unlicensed food vendor, or something like that. And no, they shouldn't be able to use trademark law against him, any more than Microsoft should be able to stop me from selling legitimate new-in-box copies of Windows or Office on eBay.
- daveFNbuck 7y agoThey could just not sell him the doughnuts. They know who he is, and they're not obligated to sell him 100 boxes of doughnuts.
- SN76477 7y agoThat is my thinking, that they have the right to deny service.
- kpU8efre7r 7y agoBetter question- if this is so profitable why the hell aren't there more Krispy Kreme spots?
- astura 7y agoThere used to be, most of the locations went out of business around 10-15 years ago. Corporate was screwing over their own franchisees and making bad business decisions that saturated the market. On top of that corporate was cooking the books. The result was the company lost 80% of it's value and most franchises couldn't stay open. https://www.marketwatch.com/story/rise-and-fall-of-biggest-krispy-kreme-franchisee https://www.marketwatch.com/story/rise-and-fall-of-biggest-k... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Krispy_Kreme https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Krispy_Kreme >Krispy Kreme also had supermarkets and gas stations carry their donuts, which soon contributed up to half of the chain's sales, creating further market saturation as well as increasing competition to its franchisees. All this expansion devalued Krispy Kreme brand's novelty, by making the once-specialty donuts ubiquitous, particularly as the newer sales outlets required pre-made donuts as opposed to the ones made fresh in factory stores, which alienated brand devotees. >Besides royalty payments from new stores, the parent company also enjoyed significant profits by requiring franchisees to purchase mix and doughnut-making equipment from the parent's Krispy Kreme Manufacturing and Distribution (KKM&D) division. KKM&D earned $152.7 million in 2003, which made up 31 percent of sales, with a reported operating margin of 20 percent or higher, but these mark-ups were largely at the expense of its franchisees. >Krispy Kreme has been accused of channel stuffing by franchisees, whose stores reportedly "received twice their regular shipments in the final weeks of a quarter so that headquarters could make its numbers".[9] The company was also dogged by questionable transactions and self-dealing accusations over the buybacks of franchisees, including those operated by company insiders.
- moftz 7y agoI think even the boxes you bought in the grocery store had a note about microwaving them for 8 secs to mimic the hot and fresh donuts available at the franchise locations.
- gremlinsinc 7y agoImagine if 50 mules popped up... increasing KK doughnut sales by 1500 per week at 50 different locations nationwide... hard to imagine they'd dislike making more money.... how is that negative? If it were me, I'd jump on the bandwagon and create some mule services to help grow mules to markets where Krispy's aren't delivered.
- patio11 7y agoSmart managers would run it by equally smart lawyers and regulatory partners, who would patiently and in no uncertain terms explain that compliant operation of this business has a playbook, that "college kid with an unrefrigerated uncontrolled uncleaned car" is not part of that playbook, and that the last time a fast food chain needed to announce a food safety issue it wiped off billions of dollars in market cap. (The tippity top of the iceberg here is that the courier can't produce a document attesting to the last time his car was cleaned signed and dated by the person who visually inspected it. Note that this is a different requirement from "You must clean the interior of any vehicle which transports food over state lines.") It is very plausible that the playbook is excessively limited and excessively costly because of regulatory capture by competitors, because of excessive loss aversion, or because society weights preventing risk-adjusted botulism outbreaks incorrectly against the societal good of an expectant mother being able to eat a donut, but none of those arguments against the playbook are responsive to the brute fact that the playbook exists and that you must follow it or be sanctioned. Additionally, and Dangerous Professionals will love to remind managers of this: after you have been told the playbook exists, your risk of sanction if you ignore it _increases markedly_, particularly if you do something like cite any of the above rationales as a reason to _ignore_ the playbook.
- eutropia 7y agoI'm sorry, but you're suggesting that botulism would take hold inside a 4-6 hour window on fried, glazed, doughnuts? The risk of foodborne illness on an unopened box of fresh, less than half-day old deep fried sugar crusted doughnuts has got to be stupendously low. Krispy Kreme literally sells older doughnuts on the shelves of gas stations and grocery stores. And furthermore, managers at a Krispy Kreme franchise aren't running an abstract game theoretical calculation based off of input from pastry lawyers, they're saying: "cool, $1200 in sales every Saturday!" When I was in scouts we'd do the same thing: load up the back of the SUV or pickup with boxes, drive street to street, walking door to door selling them to fund summer camp.
- patio11 7y agoI think that there is relatively little weighting to food science here and relatively high weighting towards technocratic administration, which predicts (correctly) that neither Krispy Kreme franchisees nor donut couriers have done a risk assessment and therefore is extremely prescriptive about the paper trail you need to have to exempt you from broadly applicable practices. Grocery stores are an example. They're professionalized infrastructure! The regulator knows their safety record individually, as a class, and feels regulatory-warm-fuzzies over knowing that there is a named individual at the store responsible for food safety and who files a report weekly saying "Story this week same as the last week; we checked everything you want checked and there were no anomalies, because we made it so."
- notatoad 7y agodid it really hurt their brand though? it seems like maybe they're using the streisand effect to their benefit here - i wouldn't have heard about the original story if not for the controversy. they get the "people want our product so bad they're breaking rules to get it" headlines while also shielding themselves from any potential legal or food-safety issues by being loudly on-record as saying not to do this.
- mindcrime 7y agoOK, good news. Krispy Kreme came around and worked out a deal with the kid after all. https://www.wfsb.com/krispy-kreme-strikes-deal-with-college-kid-who-drives-miles/article_c09a7527-8224-56bd-a570-b4c89d70701f.html https://www.wfsb.com/krispy-kreme-strikes-deal-with-college-...