4 ms·
I find one of Dawkin's implicit assumptions very interesting. My colleague takes the view that this YEC is entitled to a job...because he keeps his private bel
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
I find one of Dawkin's implicit assumptions very interesting.
My colleague takes the view that this YEC is entitled to a job...because he keeps his private beliefs to himself while at work...I would object to employing him, on the grounds that his research papers, and his lectures to students, are filled with what he personally believes to be falsehoods. He is a fake, a fraud, a charlatan, drawing a salary for a job that could have gone to an honest astronomer. Moreover, I would regard his equanimity in holding two diametrically opposing views simultaneously in his head as a revealing indicator that there is something wrong with his head.
Dawkins seems to believe that to be hired as a scientist, one must believe in the truth of the model one uses. I can't quite understand why he holds this view - at least in my experience, scientists study hypothesis they don't believe in all the time. I've done this (I don't believe in Copenhagen QM at all, and I'm skeptical of Bohmian mechanics). Does this make me a fraud? According to Dawkins, I guess it does.
By his logic, Einstein (not to mention Podolsky and Rosen) was also a fraud. He used a theory he didn't believe was correct (quantum mechanics) to derive conclusions he didn't believe were true. (Sadly, he didn't live long enough to see experimental verification of what he believed was a reducto ad absurdum.)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EPR_paradox http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EPR_paradox
I wonder if Dawkins truly believes all scientists who use theories they don't believe are frauds, or if he only thinks this about theistic (quasi-)theories [1]? If he holds the former belief, I think he really needs to devote a little bit of time to learning about metaphysics and the philosophy of science.
[1] Many beliefs held by theists are "not even wrong", and are therefore not theories. Take, for example, the following flavor of young earth creationism: "God created the universe 6000 years ago, with the state psi(0) = U(-6000 years) psi(world today). psi is the wavefuntion, U is the propagator. It is true that U(-20 billion years ) psi(world today) yields the big bang, but that's just a mathematical curiosity rather than history." This belief is unfalsifiable, and completely consistent with all scientific theories that are governed by an initial value problem (pretty much all of them).
- borism 16y agowell, I recall few months ago you criticized climate scientists for using incomplete models for their simulations...
- chc 16y agoI think you need to distinguish between different kinds of "using a theory." Investigating something you don't believe in is not the same thing as using (perhaps with reservation) a model you believe to be imperfect, and that in turn is different from claiming as true things that you believe to be totally false.
- jimbokun 16y ago"and that in turn is different from claiming as true things that you believe to be totally false." Dawkins approach would lead to more people claiming as true things they believe to be false, so they can get the jobs they want. Kind of like how people living under totalitarian regimes pretend to really like government policies and government officials, in order to get or keep a favorable position within the system.
- chc 16y agoIf it seemed like I was arguing for Dawkins' position, that wasn't my intention. It just seemed like yummyfajitas was lumping a lot of very different things under a vague umbrella term, which I think does a disservice to the argument he was making.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoIn general, a scientist will never "claim as true" anything. They will make claims of the following nature: Theoretical: Given assumptions A, we derive conclusion Y. Experimental: We observe phenomena Y. This is consistent with A, but inconsistent with A2. Thus, assumption A2 must be false. The fact that you don't believe theory A doesn't make your experiment refuting A2 invalid. And the fact that you don't believe A doesn't mean that it's incorrect to make conclusions about what would happen if they were true. And in particular, none of this has any bearing on holding beliefs which are not even wrong. You might believe in Copenhagen QM, I might be a Bohmian, but that doesn't make either of us frauds when we do calculations involving the Schrodinger equation. That's the thing - science isn't religion. The correctness of a theory or the usefulness of an experiment is not dependent on the beliefs of the person performing it.
- Luc 16y agoI'm just an amateur physicist... but since you're a pro, I'm sure you don't really mean it when you say Einstein 'used a theory he didn't believe was correct (quantum mechanics) to derive conclusions he didn't believe were true'. I mean, that could be misunderstood quite easily as the pop-physics version of history, in which the aging old Einstein just can't hack it, staying stuck in the old ways of thinking. In reality, of course, Einstein was one of the world's top experts in QM, made some large contributions to it, and understood and agreed with the formalism like everybody else - since the experimental verifications were clearly impressive. His opposition was mainly to Bohr's positivism, and to the completeness of QM, but he didn't oppose it's consistency or correctness. At least after about 1930 or so.
- bugsy 16y agoI took his comment to mean that Einstein didn't initially believe in it and it was an intellectual exercise at the time, not that he didn't believe in it after evidence was built up. Kind of the flip side of the Michelson-Morley experiment where they set out to measure the properties of the ether and then tried to find what had gone wrong with their experimental method in that they couldn't detect the ether at all. Belief in the ether was wrong, yet they experimented on it anyway. Likewise, if a religious person decides to do experiments to find evidence the earth is not very old, and his experiment is done properly and fully documented, the experimental results he gets, whatever they are, can still be useful and valid. Maybe the results prove the earth is very old. Maybe they show that different methods of dating the same material give different results and that leads to a breakthrough in more accurate dating.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI mean, that could be misunderstood quite easily as the pop-physics version of history, in which the aging old Einstein just can't hack it, staying stuck in the old ways of thinking. This is totally the opposite of what I meant to convey. Einstein/Podolsky/Rosen were doing great work. They helped us understand an important implication of quantum mechanics - that if our configuration-space based theories are correct, we must have some non-local hidden variables. They proposed an experiment to validate this, and for philosophical reasons they believed the experiment would invalidate QM. Their guess was wrong, but so what? My point is not that Einstein couldn't hack it - it's the exact opposite. My point is that EPR was a fantastic result, discovered by a group who believed the underlying theory was wrong and their predictions would not come true. Their beliefs were wrong, but their science was sound.
- naner 16y agoDawkins seems to believe that to be hired as a scientist, one must believe in the truth of the model one uses. I can't quite understand why he holds this view - at least in my experience, scientists study hypothesis they don't believe in all the time. I've done this (I don't believe in Copenhagen QM at all, and I'm skeptical of Bohmian mechanics). Does this make me a fraud? According to Dawkins, I guess it does. I don't believe that is the case. As long as you can explain why you don't agree with the models in a rational manner and are open to the possibility that you are wrong, then you are fine. Dawkins appears to be upset with compromising the integrity of a scientific position. He quoted a scientist claiming that even if all evidence clearly indicated the Earth was very old, he would still not believe it because the Bible says differently. And that same scientist also appears to believe that there is not an insigificant amount of evidence indicating that the Earth is very young. This makes me think Dawkins might be right. If this man already knows the answers he is looking for then he cannot be reasonably impartial. That type of thing is worlds away from "I am skeptical of this model because [science stuff]". Perhaps Dawkins is holding these positions to an unrealistic high standard, but I don't think he is being as ridiculous as you indicate.