5 ms·
I’ve never heard of a liquor board that required stores to deliver to the government a real time feed of who’s buying what liquor. If such a policy were created
by SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
I’ve never heard of a liquor board that required stores to deliver to the government a real time feed of who’s buying what liquor. If such a policy were created, and BevMo announced they refuse to comply, I’d be fully in support of that despite my normal concerns about companies ignoring regulations.
It’s not about the general principle here. If Uber’s claim about deanonymization is accurate, this specific policy is PRISM level bad.
- sailfast 7y agoAgreed, and I don’t necessarily agree with the real-time requirement as the best way to regulate. That said, while the data providing burden is certainly more than the liquor store must provide, it doesn’t seem like they’ve delayed permitting for months, requiring public notice, checking to ensure named individuals are at work, etc (not to mention some of the graft that has been associated with liquor licenses in other cities). They have a data requirement. It is not new, the company is not responding. Don’t they already do this with ride data from Uber? EDIT: Looks like they don't do this for rides yet, and may be using this as a trial balloon for greater data access? (based on this article from May, if accurate?) https://www.cnn.com/2019/05/23/tech/uber-lyft-cities-data/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2019/05/23/tech/uber-lyft-cities-data/in... EDIT2: DC has been doing this with car / ride-sharing agencies for awhile but I don't believe it's published. Not sure of the status of SharedStreets: https://www.wired.com/story/uber-nacto-data-sharing/ https://www.wired.com/story/uber-nacto-data-sharing/
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoUber appears to be claiming some kind of procedural issues happened here. They mentioned an "eleventh-hour administrative review process" in the article, although I don't have time right now to dig in and find more details on what they're talking about.
- sailfast 7y agoYeah - checking on the overall policies for LADOT as well and their data API but only so deep you can go when it’s not your day job haha. Appreciate the discussion!
- supercanuck 7y agoIs Uber a Retail Store? Does the Store leave their merchandise all over the neighborhood with GPS micro controllers on them? This analogy is absurd. As municipalities get more technically advanced, why shouldn't they have access to the same type of data or where these scooters are? How hard is it to open up an API? This seems to be, how dare citizens impose a cost of doing business in their neighborhoods!
- Karunamon 7y agoBecause a private company having access to GPS data and the government having access to GPS data are two different threat models with different concerns.
- supercanuck 7y agoThe "elected representatives by the citizens of Los Angeles" (Government) are accessing GPS Data about a companies property in its jurisdiction because the companies are not regulating their own behavior and property. This is where citizens need to advocate in their own neighborhoods and get involved and vote if that is what they want.
- dwild 7y agoThus you are agreeing that the government should get access to every phone calls, because some people may use it for illegal purpose and phone company doesn't regulate their behavior? If you have an issue with how theses companies operate, stop theses ways of operating, that's all. The solution isn't to deanonymize the userbase.
- supercanuck 7y agoUber is a corporation and the property is the corporations. The data is the corporations too, and not the property of the individual. Users relinquished that control in your TOS. What the user wants has no bearing in this whatsoever. Uber is simply using you as a tool to get around the laws in the regions it operates in. How would you feel that instead of demanding the data , they simply purchased it?
- threeseed 7y agoYour analogy makes no sense. Liquor stores don't physically move around and violate regulations on where they should operate. That is why LA is asking for this information. To regulate them since Uber can't be trusted.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoOn where they should operate, maybe not. But liquor stores definitely do violate regulations on how they should operate, and a real-time feed of sales would surely help catch things like Amazon's clearly fake retail outlets (https://www.wine-searcher.com/m/2019/11/amazon-still-mocking-california-liquor-law https://www.wine-searcher.com/m/2019/11/amazon-still-mocking...).
- lm28469 7y agoIf you honestly can't see the difference between a liquor store and a company that changed the face of every major cities in the world and how their inhabitants move around in less than 10 years* I don't think anyone can argue against your point. edit: *while using every loopholes, sketchy and sometimes straight up illegal ways to do it and killing someone as a result.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoI'm very comfortable saying alcohol affects the world as much as Uber does. Liquor stores regularly use sketchy loopholes to dodge regulation, and the entire reason they're so tightly regulated is that we believe unrestricted liquor sales will kill people.
- xfitm3 7y agoLiquor is tightly regulated for tax enforcement.
- lm28469 7y agoI'm very comfortable saying alcohol would never be approved/legal if it started being marketed 10 years ago.
- rootusrootus 7y agoLike cannabis?
- lm28469 7y agoYou mean illegal in most places, barely tolerated for medical purposes in a few other and legal in a very few states/countries VS legal and abused almost universally in the world ? Yeah exactly.
- sailfast 7y agoYes, I see the difference. My purpose with this comment was to illustrate that Uber's primary complaints appear to be about the Process, and not the request. "Last minute X" etc. While a good process is important, I was holding up that often times in local regulation there are all kinds of really terrible flaws and gotchas - you have to know people to get a license or permit, etc. In this case, it seems like a pretty straightforward compliance request, using an API whose code is publicly available, in a process that has been in-progress for at least six months, which, for local regulation, is pretty good! I was not comparing the industries, or the materials requested.