3 ms·
> none of them for storing value That one is a plus. Money is a transactional tool, speculation and storing value do not add to its main value. As an aside, e
by marcosdumay 7y ago
> none of them for storing value
That one is a plus. Money is a transactional tool, speculation and storing value do not add to its main value.
As an aside, everybody that I know that ever brought some crypto coin did it for speculation. The more likely explanation is that I'm looking at the wrong country, but if speculation suddenly stoped being a main use of BTC, I would start to seriously look at it.
- shadowgovt 7y agoStoring value is considered to be one of the three functions of money [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money#Functions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money#Functions]. And the fact that BTC's value fluctuates so wildly (in an era where fiat currencies like the dollar tend to remain a lot more stable) is one of the obstacles to mass adoption. It turns out that making a currency behave "gold-like" carried with it the disadvantages to the gold standard that induced so many countries to move away from it.
- lawn 7y agoWhat he should have said is the focus on being a store of value, while rejecting the other functions (high fees work against being a medium of exchange). In practice when people say "store of value" they mean "speculative vehicle that will make me rich". That is the real problem that's causing volatility and making cryptocurrencies worse at it's intense purpose: as money.
- marcosdumay 7y agoI'm not saying that money isn't useful as a storage of value. What I am saying is that there is very little social benefit from that usage. To decide whether a currency is successful, one should look exclusively at its use as a means of exchange, ignoring any use as a storage of value or speculation target.
- shadowgovt 7y agoThe social benefit to storing value is de-risking against the future (2). I keep some money in my bank account so that if I need to buy food for a month with no source of income I can(1). If the money in my bank account buys a third as much food tomorrow because it lacks stable value as a store, that's bad for society, because if I'm going to starve to death, I might as well use the remaining energy I have to burn some stuff down or eat the rich. (1) Ideally, I of course live in a society that doesn't consider it acceptable to let people starve to death and has a secondary system for routing food from supply to necessity without demanding I exchange stored value for that food, lest I die because I have no measurable stored value. I'm using a simple model here, and we can probably move the particulars around to find something that a society doesn't provide which is considered valuable enough that people store up private wealth to acquire it (and lacking the ability to do so, would resort to burning the system down). (2) There is probably an interesting question in whether such privatized de-risking against the future is actually a societal benefit (because of the risk that it becomes simple hoarding). Is that risk why you have discounted value-store as a societal benefit?
- dTal 7y agoYes, storing value is useful, but not storing value doesn't make a currency useless. You can always store value in other ways, by purchasing assets - such as food, or another currency. It's worth noting that people tend to like to do this anyway, even when the currency is already pretty stable - because a house you can rap your knuckles against feels like a more secure store of value than numbers in a bank.
- papln 7y agoMoney is designed (by central banks) to depreciate at 2%/yr. Most erstwhile "durable" goods depreciate at a faster rate. Your house certainly does. Heck, taxes and insurance alone are almost 2%, before you even look at physical depreciation, which is generally estimated to be at least 1%/yr. (Speculative assets like the land it sits on might appreciate far more to compensate, however.)
- shadowgovt 7y ago
- clarkmoody 7y agoAll money has value because people demand to hold it. In a hyperinflation scenario, people are dumping the currency for goods as fast as they can. They are using the money as a transactional medium only: get paid -> rush to buy goods to capture the value of your labor in something that won't be worthless tomorrow. Dumping worthless paper currency is a form of speculation that the value won't unexpectedly rise before the goods purchased with it are consumed. When people have confidence that the money they receive in exchange for their time will be able to transport that labor into the future, then they will demand to hold a balance in that money. That is why the money has value. The "store of value" proposition of Bitcoin is that it can't be printed by a central bank, so you can be sure that your holdings relative to the size of the money supply cannot be diluted.
- this_user 7y ago> The "store of value" proposition of Bitcoin is that it can't be printed by a central bank, so you can be sure that your holdings relative to the size of the money supply cannot be diluted. Except that's not true. The block reward consists of newly created coins of which there are 1800 per day. Currently, that is a 3.7% annual inflation rate in supply, which is far more than the 2% target most central banks from developed countries have. In value terms, at a price of $9300 per coin, that is $16.7M that need to flow into the Bitcoin eco system each day for it to remain stable. But "store of value" also means something beyond just money supply, namely stable buying power. And that is not something that Bitcoin has ever offered on account of being more volatile than a micro cap biotech penny stock. Bitcoin may very well be one of the worst stores of values imaginable.
- eccodown 7y agoThe supply is currently being bootstrapped, the rate of new creation is falling as the supply get closer to the maximum. Some months from now new coins from block rewards should halve (3.7% inflation dropping to 1.85%), and the process repeats as maximum supply is reached in the distant future, at which point the mining reward would primarily be the transaction fees.