4 ms·
This obsession with unearthing people's private beliefs and actively using them as grounds to discriminate against them, seems quite Orwellian to me. Why not j
by jimbokun 16y ago
This obsession with unearthing people's private beliefs and actively using them as grounds to discriminate against them, seems quite Orwellian to me. Why not just evaluate how well an employee does the job she is paid to do, and not worry about the ideas she expresses outside of work, or the activities she engages in?
Dawkins simply seems to be looking for ways of making life more difficult for religious people. If the job involves some kind of proselytizing for Atheism, rejecting people based on religious views might make sense. Otherwise, I don't see how it's relevant.
- rewind 16y agoThere's too much grey to make this black and white. What would you say to a closeted gay politician pushing anti-gay legislation? Would you not consider that person a fraud, just like someone saying their research is based on the universe being 13 billion years old when they don't really believe that?
- endtime 16y agoHonestly, I don't think the politician's sexuality, open or not, really matters there. Either the legislation is good or (in this case) it isn't.
- JabavuAdams 16y agoIt is relevant because it speaks to their honesty and tolerance for hypocrisy. If I'm a person who habitually does certain things, but I publicly advocate denying those activities to others, that's very significant information.
- kldavis4 16y agoIf that politician is truly representing his constituency, then he is not a fraud and is doing what he is paid to do.
- jbooth 16y agoPoliticians are supposed to lead, not follow.
- JabavuAdams 16y agoSo, because he does what he's told, that makes it alright? He has a choice not to represent that constituency. Let's take a different example. Suppose an American is being paid to do something that is actively bad for other Americans. Does "doing what you're paid to do" make it all right? There are no other considerations?
- mseebach 16y agoPresumably he's not doing "what he's told", he's doing what he thinks is the right thing. Anyone pushing a policy they actually oppose is a fraud, gay or not.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoWhy would that person be a fraud? He might honestly believe homosexuality is wrong, but simply be unwilling to control his urges. For a non-moralistic example of this behavior, consider a fat person who wishes to lose weight for the selfish purpose of attracting sexual partners, but is unwilling to put down the bacon. Is this person a fraud when they say people should lose weight?
- JacobAldridge 16y agoGreat example, from a user named yummyfajitas
- JabavuAdams 16y agoYes, of course.
- nika 16y agoI'm gay. If I were a politician, I would oppose laws (actually like Dawkins does here) that ban discrimination based on sexual orientation (as well as religion.) Would my thinking be suspect? Does that mean that I think that gay people shouldn't be hired or be able to get housing? From the common / popular "pro-gay" view my positions would be characterized as "anti-gay" and I would risk being demonized by GLAAD, etc. The problem here is that these terms "pro-gay" and "anti-gay" etc, are completely political and ignore all possibility of nuance. Let me put it another way. I think a gay person should be allowed to choose not to rent out a room in their house to a mormon who, when he came to see the room, went on and on about how evil gay people are. Clearly, this gay person is choosing to discriminate based on religion. Clearly, also, being forced to rent a room to someone you are not going to get along with is a recipe for trouble. But, specifically, it is a violation of your property rights in the room you're renting out, just as forcing you to rent it out, or preventing you from renting it to anybody, or dictating the price at which you can rent it is a violation of your right to use this property as you see fit. Further, freedom of association is the freedom to associate with whom you like and also not associate with people you don't get along with. Discriminating against people (based on sexuality or beliefs) is a bad idea when you're hiring because you'll exclude people who would be productive in preference to people who might be less productive. But discrimination is intrinsic in both property rights and freedom of association. (And freedom of association is simply another way of saying property rights in your own body.) So, while GLAAD and other political groups would call me an anti-gay politician in this hypothetical, would you really call me a fraud? I think in the end I'm agreeing with you that it is not black and white, you just hit on the political angle that I can speak directly to. I've been called "anti-gay" because I don't support "pro-gay" legislation, even though my position is based in a (stronger than my opponents, I believe) belief in human rights.
- ekanes 16y ago> Clearly, this gay person is choosing to discriminate based on religion. Not really. It's a subtle difference, but it's more like discriminating against someone for being a jerk. Or perhaps insensitive. a) If the person wasn't religious but said the same thing, one might discriminate the same way. (Therefore showing it wasn't because of religion) b) Alternatively, if someone was religious, but wasn't judgmental, presumably you wouldn't have a problem with them.
- jasonlotito 16y agoThe article isn't about religion so much as it is about beliefs. Does being a religious belief make a belief better? The current laws seek to protect religious beliefs over non-religious ones. Basically, why is it okay to reject people based on some beliefs but not others?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- khafra 16y agoIn this case, as someone on Lesswrong pointed out, religious beliefs are a special category that people have historically proved adept at compartmentalizing so they don't get in the way of day-to-day life. As long as the algorithm constently outputs correct results, the fact that it includes unnecessary steps is only a small worry, not a big one.
- mseebach 16y agoPolitical beliefs are also very much protected.
- jasonlotito 16y agoWhich leads back to the question: why is it okay to reject people based on some beliefs but not others?
- jimbokun 16y agoI was careful to use the term "private beliefs" in my first paragraph. If your beliefs, religious or otherwise, are not affecting your job performance, I don't see how they're relevant to hiring and firing decisions.
- jasonlotito 16y agoDoes private beliefs have an official definition? What I mean is, if you make public a belief, is it no longer "private"? Especially in a teaching position, where your personal beliefs directly contradict what your teaching? Do as I say, not as I do? > If your beliefs, religious or otherwise, are not affecting your job performance, I don't see how they're relevant to hiring and firing decisions. Except things that aren't directly related to job performance are used as an excuse all the time. So we come back to the question: why special treatment for some beliefs and not others?