5 ms·
This is incredibly good news for the developing world in the short- and medium term, but really bad news for the long term. Cheap energy boosts economic growth
by nabla9 7y ago
This is incredibly good news for the developing world in the short- and medium term, but really bad news for the long term. Cheap energy boosts economic growth and well-being. Oil finds its comparative advantage relative to cheap solar.
Globally liquid fuel production and consumption just goes up year after year https://www.eia.gov/outlooks/steo/images/Fig6.png https://www.eia.gov/outlooks/steo/images/Fig6.png
Reduced use of hydrocarbons in the west is nice but it's not going to offset the demand in the developed world. The growth will slow down and stop in decade or two.
- option_greek 7y agoThe developing nations never pass cheaper oil benefit to the end consumers. They just increase taxes to offset the decrease in price (and thats a good thing). So there won't be any increase in consumption due to low prices.
- jdjdjjsjs 7y agoThis is also exactly correct. The actual reason is that fossil fuels are highly subsidized in most developing countries, so the only impact this has is in reducing the subsidies paid by the government exchequer.
- eej71 7y agoNot sure I understand how they can be both highly subsidized and yet highly taxed at the same time.
- SuoDuanDao 7y agoextraction companies are taxed or owned outright, end products are subsidized.
- eej71 7y agoSounds like it will just net out.
- SuoDuanDao 7y agoOnly if you tend to use as much as you produce. If you're a net exporter, it pays for a lot.
- option_greek 7y agoSome sections of society might be subsidized (poor, inputs to fertilizer industry etc) but overall the price of gas is quite high (India: $4.18 per gallon, Brazil: $4.30). Its almost at same level as California and without any activism. During the oil highs of 2011-2012, prices reached as high as $5.5 per gallon.
- PeterisP 7y agoDeveloping countries generally can't afford to subsidize fossil fuels. The only developing countries where fossil fuels are highly subsidized are the few countries with substantial domestic oil production e.g. Iran and Venezuela, not most of them.
- simonh 7y agoOk, so maybe developing nations will get a boost to government revenues. That's a trickier variable to base predictions on, depending on the level of competence or corruption in any given government.
- jdjdjjsjs 7y agoThe idea that the developing world will benefit from cheap oil is ridiculous. The developing world is the one suffering from the impacts of global warming. Several countries in Africa are suffering from wars worsened by climate change driven migrations. Countries like India have a mix of cities running out of water, cities flooded by water and cities drowning in pollution which is almost certainly gonna erase years of people's lives eliminating any improvements caused by better medicine. Cheap oil, or expensive oil, are both bad for developing countries. It's literally not possible to give the hundreds of millions of people in developing countries a better future with fossil fuel driven growth. All our thinking and planning has to start from that basic fact.
- jeffreyrogers 7y ago> Several countries in Africa are suffering from wars worsened by climate change driven migrations. What countries are these? The conflict areas in Africa I'm familiar with (e.g. Great Lakes region), seem to be driven almost entirely over access to valuable resources.
- navigatesol 7y agoSo cheap oil and expensive are both bad, but "just right" oil is fine? I'd love for some of these people to go to these countries and tell these people to do without electricity and fuel for their transportation and generators.
- koopuluri 7y agoIt's tough to think about the negative long-term impact of pollution on health or think about the connection between burning fossil fuels and flooding, etc. when you're starving, feel like you don't have any economic stability and have no idea how to adequately educate your kids because you know the public education system sucks but have no money to put towards private education. Provide economic stability to enough people in the short-term to reach a critical mass of people that have the privilege to care about the longer-term. Until then, I don't see most areas (e.g. many regions in India) have the bandwidth to trade-off short-term economic gain for long-term health. To clarify: I agree with your point. I just don't see the current economic climate in many parts of the world allow for shaping local policy that promotes long-term environmental stability.
- perfunctory 7y ago> The growth will slow down and stop in decade or two. I heard exact same statement a decade or two ago.
- neuronic 7y agoAre you suggesting that growth is infinite?
- eej71 7y agoNot quite - but what makes us so successful aren't the resources themselves but our (nearly) endless ability to be creative, to learn, to understand, to come up with new ways to make use of those finite resource. In a sense, the effective supply of oil has increased thanks to our increase in the supply of knowledge. I expect that to continue for many lifetimes to come.
- neuronic 7y agoThen the solution will have be different than stopping to use oil but mitigate its negative effects.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoIf we assume the developed world will eventually care to do something about the climate heating in the medium or long term, this is terrible for the developing world. Build out the infrastructure for oil, the refuelling, without need of a power grid for EVs first. Then find in 2040 or 2050 that the developed world imposes trade sanctions or other pressure for not being carbon neutral. Build an infrastructure for at best twenty years then throw it away. That's suggesting to build out with the horse and buggy in 1910. If, on the other hand, the developed world doesn't get their act together, sure it's great news for the developing world in the short term. While the whole planet accelerates over the cliff edge. We can ultimately trim the population more than we did in the Black Death.
- nostrebored 7y agoRight, the predicted cliff edge we've been hypothesizing is imminent for decades vs. the near-immediate loss of life caused by rejection of fossil fuels
- pastor_elm 7y agoCheap oil hasn't helped Nigeria at all.