6 ms·
Assuming they follow on with a credible laptop CPU, AMD is a clear BIG underdog winner, and Intel has some reflecting to do. It's a pretty unique moment in time
by tyingq 7y ago
Assuming they follow on with a credible laptop CPU, AMD is a clear BIG underdog winner, and Intel has some reflecting to do. It's a pretty unique moment in time.
- big_chungus 7y agoIt's been great for consumers, though. This ought to be a textbook illustration of how serious competition can drive a net increase in surplus, especially for consumers. I'd guess anyone who follows hardware, even from a distance, would agree. Finally broke the four-core "ceiling" intel imposed, too. I don't know if AMD will stay in front long-term (intel's got some nice stuff coming out on new nodes), but that doesn't matter. If intel is forced to put some work in and pull ahead again, still better. Interestingly enough, I'm hoping that intel does the same to nvidia in the GPU space. Nvidia is still the choice if you want the best performance, and cuda is the standard. That might change (and prices might drop) if intel's cards end up being good. Fingers crossed.
- topmonk 7y agoWouldn't we all fair better if those doing the duplicate work of researching for their individual companies instead were able to work together on a single design? If instead of two corporations wasting resources fighting each other for market dominance, if we all were only allowed to work for the government, tasks like these could be performed in a way that nothing was wasted and not only that but we all worked for the greater good of the people rather than the profit of a few. Such a configuration would surely beat the pants off of any capitalist environment regardless of the regulatory structure imposed. Not to mention, by having goals that put the people first, would end up with a society of better served, happier people where empathy was the rule rather than the exception.
- mika9090 7y agoI also suggest that those people charged with designing this new unified CPU will have a progress quota. And if they do not meet this quota they will be send to a labour camp. This will surely speed things up! And just to be sure all is fair you will in charged of defining this quota.
- timlatim 7y agoIntel's current situation with the 10nm node actually illustrates why having separate designs is a net benefit for the industry and the consumer. It was supposed to be delivered earlier, but due to a design/planning failure (https://www.tomshardware.com/news/intel-ceo-cpu-shortage-company-aggression,39955.html https://www.tomshardware.com/news/intel-ceo-cpu-shortage-com...), it was stuck in development and kept Intel from rolling out their new architecture (Ice Lake) until recently. What prevents a government-led project from hitting the same problem? Without serious competition from AMD, I'm quite sure there would be no price reductions and we'd be paying more for inferior products.
- topmonk 7y agoThe person in charge could have the same philosophy as you, and after seeing several reports of non-progress, invite some other people with alternative ideas to work in tandem. There is nothing wrong with trying different approaches in parallel, but why does it have to go all the way from cradle to market that way? At a certain point it would be obvious which design was the better one, and then the group who was working on the design that proved inferior could then join the more successful group and double their productivity. If it was possible to cut losses way ahead of the curve, imagine what could have already been achieved.
- jl6 7y agoIt’s still not obvious that Intel’s R&D is inferior (late, sure, but it hasn’t killed the company yet), and ultimately the market is the best judge of which is the best design.
- topmonk 7y ago> ultimately the market is the best judge of which is the best design. This is just bias. How can you know what the ultimate best judge of anything is? You would have to know what all the alternatives that could ever be conceived would be. And I can prove you wrong more directly. If the market is the best judge of the of the best design, why is so much money spent on advertising? If a better designed product with less advertising faced a worse designed product with better advertising and always won, since "ultimately the market is the best judge of which is the best design", then there would be no point spending money on advertising at all.
- itronitron 7y agoyou need a diversity of opinion in order to make meaningful progress and that is more likely to happen when there are different companies
- lliamander 7y agoAn under-appreciated point. All heirarchies impose some degree of conformity, whether they are corporate or government. The market is in fact a very non-hierarchical structure, and provides the necessary space for creativity.
- topmonk 7y agoIf you are able to recognize that diversity of opinion is desirable, why can't the person in charge recognize this, and create groups that work on different ideas in tandem? Once the ones that are successful bear fruit, those that are working on the failures can be moved over to the successful groups. And instead of the current environment, where there is a lot of wasted effort allowing an inferior product to go all the way to market to languish there, the decision can be made much earlier than that, saving all those wasted resources.
- itronitron 7y agoThat has worked at companies but it tends to not be a stable state for them long-term. Hewlett-Packard (HP) is the best example I can think of that started off as an innovator and then got re-orged into a walking corpse. I think it is a result of human nature responding to the incentives provided by their company, their education, and culture. Most people, if hired to lead the work on an idea, will become upset or stressed if they learn of another group at the company that is also focused on the same area. Companies can adapt their culture and organizational model to create an ecosystem in which diverse efforts can develop at their natural pace. However if that was easy to do well then there would be no need for companies to hire external design agencies. At the scale of chip manufacturers such as Intel and AMD they probably feel that they are considering many diverse opinions, but each company has its view and once they decide on the path forward they will cut any staff that are not contributing directly to that path (or at least AMD will.)
- mamurphy 7y agoThe problem is incentives. If you are the only chip in town, who cares if you go for a long lunch and aren't that creative in pushing performance limits? Capatlism creates winners and losers, and creates incentives for people to try their best to not be on the losing team.
- topmonk 7y agoThe problem is not incentives, but culture. From a view purely based on incentives, there is no reason to support your grandmother, for example, rather than kicking her out in the cold. Only our culture stops us to treat our closest family members this way. If we expanded what we thought of as “us” from just the individual unit, however small that might be (the familial unit for some, just the individual self for others) to to include the entire country and government running it, there is no telling what we could achieve.
- mongol 7y agoI would say empathy plays a stronger role than culture in your example.
- depressedpanda 7y ago> If we expanded what we thought of as “us” from just the individual unit, however small that might be [...], to include the entire country and government running it, there is no telling what we could achieve. Please consider that people have historically tried to achieve the Utopia you describe, where everyone is expected to put the State before the individual. It degenerates into totalitarianism, since forceful coercion and defining a "them" to the "us" is necessary for that to happen. I much prefer the arrangement of putting more emphasis on the individual and money being wasted on duplicated r&d than what you seem to be arguing for.
- monkeywork 7y agodid you forget your /s ?
- sharpneli 7y agoIn that case we would likely be stuck with AMD on bulldozer era or Intel now. No competition allowed thus the incubent will stay lazy. The fault lies with human organizations in general. Everything will stagnate and there will be a boss ”We have always done it this way”. Only by coming from outside can one go around these issues. In the 50s or so US was actually worried what you say might be the case and communist society would trash capitalism because factories would share innovations instead of competing with them. For some reason the innovations didn’t really come.
- CamouflagedKiwi 7y agoNot that unique; the early Athlon64s were miles ahead of Intel, who'd gone a long way down the wrong road at the time. This feels very similar, but doesn't bode that well for AMD if they can only do this once a decade.
- tyingq 7y agoI feel like that's less than fair. AMD is a much smaller company with fewer resources.
- adventured 7y ago> AMD is a much smaller company with fewer resources. To put that point into context, Intel's operating profit in just its most recent quarter ($6.55b) is greater than AMD's revenue over the last four quarters combined ($6b).
- CamouflagedKiwi 7y agoI'm not trying to be harsh; in both cases I think it's impressive what they did. Just saying it sucks a bit that in between Intel inevitably seems to get back in front.
- simion314 7y ago>Just saying it sucks a bit that in between Intel inevitably seems to get back in front. What sucks is that Intel used illegal means to fight AMD , so despite having the better CPU the OEMs were not using AMD in their builds.
- gscott 7y agoCpus are now lasting a lot longer... a top end cpu is likely to still be fast enough after 6 years, maybe longer. Catching up to Intel and surpassing them may be good enough for a whole decade.
- clarry 7y ago
- twotwotwo 7y agoI'm interested to see it but I expect it'll be just a noticeable step up, not a blockbuster. The process and focus on IPC seem like good things for power consumption. But it seems like there's a ton of work Intel's done to optimize sleeps/twiddle clock freq/etc. for the thin-and-light laptop use case, and I'm not sure AMD is close to catching up with that. They could always surprise me. (TSMC does fab power-sipping mobile chips too!) I just don't have super high expectations.
- atq2119 7y agoIt's a good thing that the next Surface is going to use AMD's CPUs. It's likely that (unlike other laptop manufacturers) Microsoft will spend a decent amount of time to work through sleep and power issues on the software side at least for Windows, which will then trickle down to other manufacturers.
- mkl 7y agoOnly the 15 inch Surface Laptop 3. All other models are still Intel.