7 ms·
The sort of arrogant self-absorbed people who would fly a drone over a wildfire are the same sort of arrogant self-absorbed people who would flash their drone w
by reaperducer 7y ago
The sort of arrogant self-absorbed people who would fly a drone over a wildfire are the same sort of arrogant self-absorbed people who would flash their drone with hacked firmware to bypass any restrictions.
Rules are for other people.
- chrisseaton 7y agoProbably many people are just ignorant, not deliberately mischievous.
- heavenlyblue 7y agoThat’s pretty much the reason Europeans don’t allow people to own guns.
- mikejb 7y agoThis is not correct. The details of gun ownership rights depends on the individual European state, but it's absolutely possible for a civilian to own guns. In fact, some do. It's just not engrained in the general culture or connected to the protection of rights, and subject to stricter regulation.
- heavenlyblue 7y agoLook, I didn’t say “all Europeans”. And “stricter regulation” is literally “you need to prove you need a gun and that you are sane” in most of the cases.
- catalogia 7y ago"Prove you need it" isn't really an accurate summation of European gun laws, since as far as I'm aware they all allow ownership of firearms in cases where somebody wants a gun, rather than needs it. Who in Europe needs to hunt for substance, or needs to participate in marksmanship sports? These are recreational hobbies that the gun laws of all European nations I'm aware of accommodate.
- chrisseaton 7y agoI know many European gun laws are what would be described in the US as 'shall-issue', so it's not 'prove you need it' in all cases.
- ascorbic 7y agoIn the UK, which has some of the strictest laws, it's more like show you have a legitimate reason. Hunting is a common one, but self defense is not a legitimate reason. Apparently, working in maritime security in a piracy area lets you buy almost anything, even handguns and automatic weapons that are otherwise banned.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> In the UK, which has some of the strictest laws, it's more like show you have a legitimate reason. This is not true for guns. The UK police are required, by law, to issue a gun certificate unless they have a specific reason not to. Rifles are different.
- vonmoltke 7y agoI really don't want to wade into this debate, but I'm really confused by how you are using "gun" and "rifle" here. "Rifle" us a strict subset of "gun" in my vocabulary.
- chrisseaton 7y agoA gun is a shotgun, a canon, something that fires shot or a shell, that kind of thing. A rifle has rifling and fires a bullet. It's technical, but we're talking about laws so the technicalities matter. In the UK a licence for a gun, such as a shotgun, is 'shall-issue' to use terminology the US is familiar with. They need a reason to deny - you don't need a reason to be approved.
- microcolonel 7y agoFor future reference, in the U.S. and Canada (and possibly elsewhere), gun also refers to rifles and handguns, not just smoothbore guns.
- the_mitsuhiko 7y agoIn a lot of European countries self defence is enough of a reason to be granted a weapon license. The regulation is mostly about sanity, central databases and background and regular storage checks.
- pvaldes 7y agoIs allowed but regulated. There are duck hunters in Europe also.
- pvaldes 7y agoThe drone problem has being disclosed since years. People flying drones are technologically competent. "If you fly we cant" campaign was launched on several media. Argumenting ignorance as excuse is strange after all those years.
- boomboomsubban 7y agoI have never seen this campaign, though I would have some reservations about flying a drone around a fire my curiosity may get the better of me. Just anecdotal evidence, buy it's entirely possible to be technologically competent and ignorant. Additionally, my father isn't overly technologically competent but does own a drone, they've been fairly standard gifts for family members who buy everything for a while now. I can easily imagine him and his golfing buddies talking about getting footage of a fire on their drones.
- erik_seaberg 7y agoIt never would have occurred to me that aircraft tough enough for the heat and turbulence and debris over a forest fire could be affected by drones. I can find a few "if you fly, we can't" search results but I hadn't seen that message before today. Maybe they're just very precisely targeted? (Drones are tempting but I don't own one.)
- jacques_chester 7y agoI'm pretty sure that people who design, build, operate, maintain, pilot or regulate aircraft know more about that topic than anyone else does. Without strong evidence to the contrary, I'm going to believe them when they say it's dangerous to have drones in the air they're trying to use. "It never would have occurred to me" doesn't meet the standard for strong evidence to the contrary.
- erik_seaberg 7y agoI'm not saying the problem doesn't exist, just that it's counter-intuitive and not widely publicized.
- rgbrenner 7y agoNot always... They could just be curious people who want to see the fire. Just because they didn't fully think through their actions doesn't mean they would continue if it was pointed out to them. And some people might want to see the fire.. but maybe not enough to risk bricking their drone. Introducing additional financial risk could be all the disincentive they need. If you caught a flashed drone and found the user, it would enable stiffer penalties also. Flashing the drone would signal clear intent to break the law.
- 14 7y agoI don't think a person needs to be self-absorbed or arrogant to flash their drone. It reminds me of jailbreaking when iPhones first came out. We were warned it would void our warranty and possible we could go to jail for hacking our own device. But we did it anyways because I like to have full control over my devices. I would want the same with my drone. Why? Because though I would respect a no fly zone in a fire situation I may not do the same if my government was arbitrarily placing them up during protests or to prevent people from recording human rights issues.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- blotter_paper 7y agoWell said, I'm disappointed that you're getting downvoted for expressing this sentiment. Actions like BART blocking cellphones show that the government is entirely willing to make arbitrary technology restrictions to squash protests. If drones were widely available in Nazi Germany, would they have been allowed to fly near concentration camps? Pass whatever silly laws you want, but don't call those who preserve their tools and freedoms arrogant and self absorbed -- save those labels for the assholes who actually interfere with firefighting operations.
- codedokode 7y agoStrict laws can help to fix people who don't want to play by the rules.
- JPKab 7y agoShotguns are a fun solution for these assholes. I of course mean shooting the drones, not the pilots.
- cma 7y agoSounds like a bad idea in a dry area battling wildfires given that the lithium batteries could burn.
- m-p-3 7y agoAt this point that's where the legal/justice system should intervene. Not all problems can (or should) be fixed by a technological solution. Same thing with consumer routers, I wouldn't want the FCC to forbid custom firmwares to cease to exists because some bad actors could use frequencies they're not supposed to. These custom firmwares are useful in many cases, including supporting them with security fixes when the manufacturer doesn't.
- newnewpdro 7y agoDoesn't it seem likely at least some of these drones are operated by the same people chasing accidents/violent crime scenes with cameras to then sell the footage to TV/news? It's not uncommon for them to break rules to get the shot. Arguably it defines a big part of their profession, and if it's paying their bills they're going to keep doing it. The film Nightcrawler provides an interesting lens to view this situation through.
- pvaldes 7y agoThat would be a reasonable explanation. People can accept the risk of being fined if there is a reasonable expectation of monetary reward. But this still does not explain why so many fires and why now and not one month ago.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 7y agoHmm, maybe when I own the device, I should be able to use it without interference ( and suffer the appropriate consequences ). I wonder if you be posting the same thing if say.. your automaker made your car refuse to enter Boston, as it was just designated a no drive zone. Rules matter and should be enforced. Just not via limiting my ownership rights.
- shakna 7y agoYour car however carries registration, which has a strong papertrail that leads directly to you, which can easily be observed from a distance. Drones on the other hand may not carry registration requirements at all (depending on jurisdiction, power and weight), and building one yourself doesn't require more-than-hobbyist level knowledge of engineering. A technical solution probably is required, but what that technical solution is I can't say.
- pmoriarty 7y ago"A technical solution probably is required, but what that technical solution is I can't say." The government could make drones that shoot down unauthorized drones.
- jacques_chester 7y agoIt's safer to not need to do this at all.
- leetcrew 7y agoin the US, any drone above 250g must be registered with the FAA. there are very few drones below this weight that can hover in place or be controlled at all from more than 100 feet away away. the new DJI mavic mini is a notable exception. I know it's tempting to essentially say "fuck them, just force them to comply" when people partaking in an activity you don't really care about cause problems, but imo this is not the best solution for a free society. if you believe car registration creates an effective deterrent, why not advocate for stricter registration requirements for drones? if you believe drone enthusiasts are ignorant, why not require an exam? > building one yourself doesn't require more-than-hobbyist level knowledge of engineering this seems like a red herring in your argument. the DIY crowd is not likely to bother implementing no-fly-zone enforcement in their own project.
- benburleson 7y agoHanlon's razor https://simple.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanlon%27s_razor https://simple.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanlon%27s_razor
- hanniabu 7y ago> would flash their drone with hacked firmware Is it possible to have the firmware signed so that if it doesn't match a hash then it bricks the device?
- chii 7y agoyes, but where would you get that hash from? Unless there's a trusted computing unit with an encrypted enclave, you can't prevent the user from also creating a matching hash. I say it's better to use the rule of law - make drones registered, and licensed. If you fly it and got caught doing no-fly zone, you get punished.
- MertsA 7y agoIt's relatively cheap and easy to use something like ARM TrustZone that has a public key hash set in the processor via blowing fuses on the die itself to ensure that that processor will only boot up with a firmware image that's signed by the manufacturer. If you wanted to get around it you would need to replace the processor with a virgin one and then get it to load your modified firmware. It's completely impractical to do something like this to evade a geofence block. It would be much easier to just add a tiny microcontroller between the GPS receiver onboard and the processor that just introduces a large offset in the NMEA messages such that it would think it's hundreds of miles away from it's true location and evade the geofence that way.
- consumer451 7y ago> The sort of arrogant self-absorbed people who would fly a drone over a wildfire are the same sort of arrogant self-absorbed people who would flash their drone with hacked firmware to bypass any restrictions. Perfect is the enemy of good. [0] DJI has a 70% market share.[1] If they made the changes which the parent requested, then it would certainly lower the number of times this would happen. IMO, not all self-absorbed people are into flashing hacked firmware. Lowering the number of these incidents has the potential to save lives, and also lowers the risk of regulatory changes for radio controlled aircraft. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_is_the_enemy_of_good https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_is_the_enemy_of_good [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DJI_(company) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DJI_(company)