15 ms·
Life expectancy for American men drops for a third year
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- digitalsushi 7y agoA lot of people are having a difficult time. I don't pretend to know anything about psychology or depression, but I do know that between the elbow of exponential growth in all things good and bad, and our increasing awareness of it, that it's good to reach out to friends and read between lines, and ask if we're all ok. Sometimes flipping a stone over to check in can really make a huge impact in someone's life, even just a random coffee that wasn't normally meant to be.
- tomp 7y ago> it's good to reach out to friends and read between lines, and ask if we're all ok Will this actually reach the people that need it? I mean, just having friends (and/or people you're regularly in contact with) is probably quite helpful in preventing these situations from arising... I imagine the path towards suicide / serious life & mental health issues is quite gradual, rather than a cliff... so people would become negative, unpleasant to be around (hence lose their friends) way before coming anywhere near suicide... by then it's already too late. I often think, in terms of my life (highly privileged, smart & well educated, upper class, rich or at least high-earning, programmer, young, healthy, lots of career options, career resistant to automation, first-world citizen so easy to migrate, ...) I'm really quite isolated from "normal", "average" people... I don't actually even know anyone who's poor, or not in a career (i.e. just has a dead-end job like a bartender or truck driver)... just by virtue of the education system, I've been kept away from people like that since I was 15! How am I to even imagine what they're going through?! Sure not everything is rosy in my life, and even rich people can get sick and depressed, but I sometimes consider this viewpoint for some perspective...
- snagglegaggle 7y agoThis is a good point. I live partly in the country and small towns are full of guys 40-60 years old with no immediate family and, I presume, a limited support network. I realized at some point these are the men society marginalizes and sends out into the country to die. Only 40-60% of men become fathers. It's something I think about a lot after failing out of school. No one wants to date me, and the chances of me ever forming a nuclear family are getting slimmer by the day.
- digitalsushi 7y agoYou owe it to everyone else to go talk to some random people, people that you don't think you have any business talking to. Because they are the people you have the most business talking with, to help you learn about everyone else.
- zarkov99 7y agoI salute you for having the humbleness to see it. There is horrific pain and suffering out there, one has only to hang out a bit with people outside the tech bubble to see it. Talk to your mechanic, the waiter, the landscape guy, the aging bro at the gym, the broken vet. There but for the grace of god is any one of us. It is unspeakably shameful that we dismiss their suffering because of their supposed male white privilege. As if that made them less worthy of empathy and respect.
- swebs 7y agoSome advice I've found helpful is to quit Twitter and Reddit, while also unfriending particularly misandrist and racist (yes, anti-white racism is still racism) Facebook friends. I've found myself a lot happier when I cut out people who would constantly try to demonize me for various physical traits. If you have the mass media constantly telling a group of people that they're inherently evil, of course it's going to cause suicides.
- thiago_fm 7y agoAs if this is the cause of the life expectancy drop for American men. I think learning how to deal with this type of criticism is a quality one needs to have nowadays. I'm white and I have no problem with twitter or reddit. They are actually great platforms. I think the root of the problem with American men is that inequality in America is increasing. Also the culture and education system needs a reform, a lot of kids are growing in an environment where drug abuse is cool, doctors don't want to hear patients and just prescribe medicine etc. There are a lot of wrong incentives. Hopefully the next president focuses on addressing them.
- BlueGh0st 7y ago>They are actually great platforms. With incredibly toxic userbases.
- eej2ya1K 7y agoWhat does "toxic" mean?
- ohlookabird 7y agoMaybe you haven't heard that word in this context before, it's of course not meant to be read literally. I understand it the same way as I would read "toxic workplace culture" or "toxic social environment", which is that there are people who bully, abuse power, take advantage of you, deliberately misunderstand you, are racist, sexist, etc.
- paganel 7y agoThis starts being pretty similar to what happened in the USSR immediately after the Perestroika failed, in a span of 10-years (1990-2000) life expectancy for men fell by 5 years (from 63 to 58). That was a pretty big societal crisis which among other things helped bring to power an autocrat like Putin (and especially helped him stay there, as life expectancy shot up again starting with the early 2000s), I’m wondering when will the present situation in the States be treated like the real societal crisis that it represents? In other words, guys like Trump are not merely the causes for much that goes wrong in the States, they’re merely the effects, take him down and a new Trump-like character will probably emerge in his place, unless you fix the problem at its very roots.
- gtirloni 7y agoAnd what's the root cause in case you know it?
- doboyy 7y agoI'm treading into Marxist territory, but I think industrialization, technology, and their societal consequences are a large part. If I dropped the first part, there would be no downvotes.
- paganel 7y agoIncreased inequality (both economic and social), crippling debt, horrendous health system, lack of hope (this one especially stings) etc etc. I personally am not from the States, I lived and grew up in Eastern Europe back in the ‘90s, and saw the same thing happening here, only that we used cheap alcohol instead of opioids in order to dig up our own early graves.
- SuoDuanDao 7y agoIt's probably overdetermined, but I suspect that peaking fossil fuels and a subsequent deceleration in energy entering the economic system play an underappreciated role. To give context: Hubbert's peak, which is generally considered the most reliable predictor of fossil fuel extraction curves, predicted a peak for the US in 1970 and the world in 2010. Allow 2 years margin of error on either side and it lines up very closely with the advent of stagflation in both systems.
- ErikAugust 7y ago"Men who are among the richest 1% of Americans live almost 15 years longer than those who are in the poorest 1%, the Harvard analysis found." 15 years is a tremendous gap!
- throwawayhhakdl 7y agoTheir health may be better, but the 15 years is because the poor are being killed by things like overdosing, not natural longevity.
- snarf21 7y agoAbsolutely true. Also, I was disappointed that the article didn't mention opioids. It seems like that would have a huge impact on all life expectancy in the US over the last several years.
- ptah 7y agoyip, i think the drop is mainly due to the poor getting poorer
- patentatt 7y agoThe poorest 1% is an extreme outlier cohort in America. Some sources from a cursory search suggest it’s something like less than $2 a day.
- chrisweekly 7y agohaven't looked at the data, but I'd guess a similar gap exists if comparing the top 1 or 2% to the bottom 5-10%...
- ErikAugust 7y agoYes it would be interesting to see if it extends to poorest 5% at least. However I would assume the poorest 1% would be covered by social security.
- dredmorbius 7y ago
- rhegart 7y agoSociety doesn’t care about men’s issues. 57% of undergraduates are now women yet every resource makes it seem like men are way ahead and tries to bring them down because.001% most powerful are mostly men. It’s okay to mock men constantly and anyone responding back gets demonized.
- TulliusCicero 7y agoNeither side is actually wrong. Men dominate the corridors of power, and also the corridors of the dispossessed (e.g. the homeless, imprisoned, etc). Both of these things are problems.
- mongol 7y agoBut interestingly, one gets much more attention than the other.
- TulliusCicero 7y agoCorrect. The left cares about the dispossessed, at least to the extent that it gives them votes, but all the anti-men-in-power animosity does spill over I think to the effect of making it hard to drum up sympathy for men where men are suffering. The right mostly doesn't give a shit about the dispossessed, at least as far as potential government intervention goes. They're more social darwinist; if some men are really suffering, maybe they should stop being such losers, goes the thinking.
- AlexTWithBeard 7y agomaybe they should stop being such losers I think another motive here may be that if you provide "the dispossessed" and benefits, you create the incentive to become dispossessed. This problem is relatively easy to solve on a small community level (all family knows that aunt Rosa isn't actually as sick as she likes to pretend), but becomes extremely complicated when scaled to the whole country.
- sacrificedcapon 7y agoYou mean after years of relentless attack on men by the traditional news/media? You mean after social media gave toxic journalists/media types/etc, especially on twitter and reddit, full cover to attack men? What's next? Black prison population increased after "news" pushed the "super predator" narrative? The question is who or what pushed for and funded this decade-plus long media propaganda campaign. "Mansplaining", "Toxic Masculinity", "Campus Rape", "Income Inequality", "Patriarchical oppression", "Safe Space", etc. Systematic media campaigns like this don't appear out of nowhere. No more than previous systematic media campaigns like the red scare, nazi germany propaganda antisemitic propaganda campaigns or the yellow peril propaganda campaigns. From the "hallowed" media outlets like the nytimes to the lowly huffpo, from broadway to hollywood, the entire media seems to have participated in one form or another. At least with the red scare, nazi germany propaganda or the yellow peril propaganda, it was ostensibly against the "other". It's quite amazing that a nation's propaganda outlets attacked half of its own citizenry. I think it's time to start investigating "news" companies along with social media. If social media is a platform for delivering poison, the "news" companies themselves and their product are the poison. But I won't be holding my breath. Keep in mind that news media was able to do what tobacco and alcohol industries could not - lower life expectancy.
- mk376 7y agoWell, if white men "deaths of despair" rates are surpassing that of black men, may be the answer is to start treating them like black men. You, know...more police and more jails.
- kilo_bravo_3 7y agoSomething has to change, radically, when it comes to mental and medical healthcare in this country. I am very, very, fortunate. In 2018 I was suffering from the effects of PTSD: social isolation, anxiety, hyper-vigilance, poor physical health, and depression. Many men are experiencing some of these issues, not brought about by PTSD but by other factors and they turn to drugs and alcohol to cope. Luckily, instead of coping with PTSD brought about by deployments to Iraq and Afghanistan through drugs and alcohol I turned to food and extreme isolation. But I make money. Lots of it. I also have persuasive parents, and a great job with awesome co-workers who spurred me into action. With my money I hired a registered dietician, therapist, and a personal yoga instructor, and have completely changed the trajectory of my life. I meditate daily, go to yoga six days a week, have lost 50 lbs (22.7 kg) in eight months. I have had more, positive, social interactions in the last year than I have had in the last 10. My daughters say I am a completely different person, and I feel healthier at 40 than I did at 20. I am tapering off the industrial quantities of anti-depressants I was on, and no longer eat anything that came off an assembly line. There are very few social problems that lead to shortened life expectancy that cannot be overcome. And while "diet and exercise" seems to be met with derision on HN, it's not just about that. It is about the mindfulness and care one puts into themselves when dieting and exercising. The slow changes that are barely noticed from day-to-day but hit you like waves, like when I was brushing my teeth and some toothpaste fell from my mouth and instead of landing on my belly, it landed on my feet. Or when you struggle for months with sitting still and focusing on your breathing while meditating and then one day your timer goes off and you are amazed because it feels like you just started your timer two or three breaths ago. It is unacceptable to me that just because I used the GI Bill to get a degree in Computer Science and now make lots of money that I can save myself from a downward spiral of isolation and addiction (to food), while most other men cannot. Because of my limited ability to effect change, the only thing I can propose is that we collectively throw the stigma associated with depression and isolation in the trash and look out for each other as best as possible, talking openly and candidly about those things and trying to support each other with low-cost evidence-based self-improvement methods like diet, exercise, and positive social interactions until access to the same resources I used to save myself of are attainable by everyone.
- rpmisms 7y agoMen are risk-takers by nature. When we feel lost, we take risks, for better or for worse That's why the military still has great recruitment rates. It's also why many of the self-made wealthy are men, and the ones who aren't are often people more like JK Rowling. Looks like fewer of those risks are paying off than usual.
- GaryNumanVevo 7y agoThis vague generalization of men is exactly the issue. "Why haven't you gotten a job yet, you should be a risk-taker". Men aren't a monolith, and this exact thinking boxes people in.
- jhanschoo 7y agoI won't be so quick to say that the kind of overgeneralization the comment you're replying to is guilty of is clearly a factor in this issue, but it does indeed undermine their point and "explanation".
- rpmisms 7y agoVague generalizations are all the rage nowadays. See "Men are trash". Granted, I should have said "Tend to be risk-takers" or something.
- trianglem 7y agoShocking as it may sound, modern feminism is cancerous to the normal function of society and the mental health and wellbeing of both its male and female participants.
- messo 7y agoI agree that the ardent tribalism and group-ism can become a big drain on mental health, and can only imagine how exhaustive it must be to constantly measuring oneself up against other groups and demographics that seemingly enjoys more privileges than oneself.
- minikites 7y agoYou're going to need a raft of evidence to justify this claim.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't use HN for ideological battle. Not what this site is for. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- messo 7y agoThis drop is largely caused by deaths of despair [1], partly related to a lack of affordable health care in the US. The fact that (at least [2]) 78% of Americans live from paycheck to paycheck [3] underscores the relative poverty many people experience in daily life. I think it is fair to say that a majority of Americans live with a scarcity mindset, likely affecting mental health negatively. EDIT: As a Norwegian following American politics, I am surprised that this topic is so rarely talked about by the democratic nominees. The only candidate I have seen talking about the causes of the drop in life expectancy is Andrew Yang. Not even Pete has worked this into his talking points as far as I have seen. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diseases_of_despair https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diseases_of_despair [2] The number is increasing fast; it was 75% in 2016 and rose to 78% in 2017. [3] http://press.careerbuilder.com/2017-08-24-Living-Paycheck-to-Paycheck-is-a-Way-of-Life-for-Majority-of-U-S-Workers-According-to-New-CareerBuilder-Survey http://press.careerbuilder.com/2017-08-24-Living-Paycheck-to...
- zeppelin101 7y agoIt's ignored because it concerns white men. The demographic which is not permitted to have its problems recognized.
- growlist 7y agoEven raising the topic attracts hostility.
- claudiawerner 7y agoThis is one of the most ridiculous things I've read on this website, especially when it pertains to a country with a legislature, judiciary, police system and executive section of the economy with such a high proportion of white men - and even more so when one considers the law (not necessarily culture, though) was explicitly (to the actual letter) biased toward the needs and desires of white men until less than 70 years ago.
- zarkov99 7y agoWait, so you think white men are not killing themselves out of despair? Or maybe that if they are they are pussies unable to see how privileged they are even in their despair? Or maybe that they have reasons to despair, but that every single one of them had it coming anyway because of the sins of their fathers?