5 ms·
Saying that most PhDs you worked with are idiots The person you are replying to did not say that.
by mindcrime 7y ago
Saying that most PhDs you worked with are idiots
The person you are replying to did not say that.
- goatlover 7y agoBut they did say "many of them are idiots", which is similar and rather arrogant. I don't trust people who claim their colleagues and classmates are idiots. Dunning-Kruger effect and hubris being what they are.
- mindcrime 7y agoBut they did say "many of them are idiots", which is similar Similar, yes. But, at least to my mind, there's a pretty big jump from "many" to "most". But maybe that's just me. shrug
- xeromal 7y agoMot really, many still sounds like more than 50%. That's a huge claim
- blotter_paper 7y agoNope, we have a separate word for that: most.
- dekhn 7y agoI think that's what they said, slightly paraphrased: "I've published papers in bio and worked with many PhDs. Many of them were idiots" I have no interest in arguing about the interpretation of that sentence.
- mindcrime 7y agoI have no interest in arguing about the interpretation of that sentence. Then don't "interpret" anything. The person who wrote that sentence explicitly said "many" and not "most". Barring some evidence to the contrary, the sensible thing to do is take it literally, no interpretation necessary.
- dekhn 7y agoI changed the text from "most" to "many" to more closely match. This seems like a fairly pedantic thing to complain about, not really contributing to the substance of my argument.
- haolez 7y agoIf the performance of those PhDs were extremely subpar to the point of hindering the research altogether, what sentence would you use to describe this situation?