7 ms·
Right! Engineers driving busses; office managers flipping burgers. And the administration dares to call it 'full employment'. Its part of the very wealthy keep
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
Right! Engineers driving busses; office managers flipping burgers. And the administration dares to call it 'full employment'.
Its part of the very wealthy keeping all the money - if nobody has a skilled job, we don't get (much) income, and wealth inequality zooms onward.
A better measure of employment would be, how much total payroll is across the country. Per capita if you like. That would tell us how we're doing. Not just a total of whom 'has a job'.
- crdoconnor 7y agoSomewhat ironic since we were told in no uncertain terms that automation would cause the exact opposite to happen.
- pjc50 7y ago"Service" roles have been put in a weird state where, because they involve relating to humans, they're difficult to automate. But because they involve doing what you're told, with low room for autonomy and creativity, they're low-status and therefore low paid.
- BurningFrog 7y ago> they're low-status and therefore low paid. Pretty sure it's mostly the other way: They're low status because they're low paid. Jobs are low paid when there is a big supply of people who can and want to do them. Which is pretty much equivalent to the jobs being low skilled. Since everyone can flip a burger, you don't have to pay much to find someone to do it.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoAdditionally, the demand may not be sufficient to support higher wages. Even if no one is willing to flip a burger for less than $50 per hour, who is willing to pay for a burger flipped by someone earning $50 per hour?
- CydeWeys 7y agoAnd yet people are totally willing to contribute to servers earning much more than $50/hr in tips (on busy nights). $50/hr spread across a lot of customers works out to not actually being that much per customer. Admittedly this is relatively expensive sit-down restaurant service we're talking about here, which is different from the fast food market.
- crdoconnor 7y agoYou typically have to pay a lot more if public sector jobs and wages aren't being cut.
- cannonedhamster 7y agoIt would be trivial to replace servers, but there's an initial cost investment most restaurants can't afford. The obvious transition is those screens you see popping up everywhere. It's going to be the next step are conveyer belts that deliver the food to your table. Industrial automation already exists for this. Need to send it back open the receptacle click the screen to say what's wrong and your order will come back correct.
- rmrm 7y agoExcept you would need to remodel every exusting restaraunt to have conveyer belts behind false walls. This isnt the next step, it will not happen. Walk up windows for ordering and numbers are already increasing. That is the next step for reducing server numbers.
- edoo 7y agoCapitalism sees most the productivity gains to the workers. I think our experiment has failed and it is time to try capitalism again. Our country hasn't seen it for over 100 years.
- Frost1x 7y agoThat sounds like communist socialist facist nazi etc. propaganda to me... ...at least that's the knee-jerk defense you hear from the priests of our current system (most mislead or benefiting from the corruption). If you don't support our current broken form of capitalism, you're labeled a blasphemer. Heaven forbid we, as a society, re-evaluate the functionality of something adopted hundreds of years ago and adapt/change it without offering an impossibly proven successful alternative. Because, you know, the current economic system we have was proven successful before it was adopted. It won't necessarily be trivial or painless but it will be less painful than it will at a later date, unless we want to pass the burden down to future generations.
- edoo 7y agoSince they instituted the communist economic system that makes it impossible to save capital by draining the purchasing power of the currency at an exponential rate the working class has been on a steep downhill decline. I think it is pretty obvious at this point the experiment has failed.
- perl4ever 7y agoI'm sure this will convince nobody of anything, but inflation in the US in July was 1.8% (annualized) in July, and a Vanguard money market fund was yielding 1.9% recently. What more can you ask, whether you're ranting in favor of or against socialism? Risk free returns maintain your purchasing power, while at the same time, you get essentially nothing for taking no risk with capital. This seems exactly how it should work in a perfect system...doesn't it?
- lotsofpulp 7y ago
- chooseaname 7y ago> Its part of the very wealthy keeping all the money ... When does it start trickling down Mr Reagan?! When does it start trickling down!?
- chewz 7y agoStealing is the only sure way to make trickle down economy work.
- VladimirIvanov 7y agoWhen corporations stop using stock buybacks as a tax free mechanism to return value to shareholders
- rileymat2 7y agoI believe buybacks have the same long term capital gain consequences as dividends, currently. The party who sells stock at a profit will pay tax, it is not tax free. Buybacks allow shareholders to time capital gain better.
- Aeolun 7y agoIt’s already tricking down. Just not anywhere near enough to make a difference.
- xkde 7y agoI don’t know any engineers driving busses (or the equivalent). The company I’m working for is currently looking for a lot of new ones, too.
- xkde 7y agoWhoops, I thought we were discussing our personal experiences, not just whining about “the system”. My bad.
- non-entity 7y agoThey may not be driving busses, but from what I've heard people like Electrical engineers and some others often have difficulty finding work.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoAn additional complication is availability of work may be concentrating in fewer geographic regions. There very well may be a shortage of engineers for engineering jobs, but not in the same place. And yet another complication is the perception of long term security of available jobs might be less than before, so moving for one is not an easy decision.
- non-entity 7y agoAh yes I forgot to add that I'm speaking from a US perspective. I'm recalling a comment I read on HN a while back claiming that a lot of the EE jobs moved to east Asia as the manufacturing already went there
- xkde 7y agoAnd what do you propose we do about that?
- lotsofpulp 7y agoI have no idea. Wealth transfer? Training programs? Basic income?
- not2personal 7y agoA few years of college does not an engineer or office manager make. The good ones are employed in those roles, the rest haven't proven to be useful enough to be afforded them.