3 ms·
Mass distribution isn’t part of it as long as things are symmetrical (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pendulum_rocket_fallacy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pe
by taneq 7y ago
Mass distribution isn’t part of it as long as things are symmetrical (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pendulum_rocket_fallacy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pendulum_rocket_fallacy) but yeah, threading the needle like SpaceX does is not easy.
- anovikov 7y agoDue to fuel slosh, things aren't symmetrical really.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoGot to say, I don't understand how the argument in that article works. If Goddard's rocket that's on the photo had a canvas stretched between the wires/pipes that form its body (I assume it's a part of the rocket, and not a launch platform), then I'd expect aerodynamic forces to act on them, countering the tilt. Conversely, if such surfaces were above of the engine, I'd expect them to make the construction unstable.
- taneq 7y agoYou're right that any canvas stretched around the frame could act as aerodynamic stabilizer fins. The pendulum rocket fallacy is the assumption that a higher mounted engine will stabilize the rocket's direction due to it 'hanging' from the engine, by analogy with a pendulum (where the higher a point you 'hang it from' the more stable it is). The fallacy lies in the fact that the pendulum is hung from a fixed point which can apply forces to generate a stabilizing torque, whereas there are no such outside forces generated by the rocket engine (other than the thrust it produces). Fins totally work and that's why almost all rockets use them to some degree for stabilisation while in the atmosphere.
- anovikov 7y agoBut for landings, it's totally a part of it. If there is a mentionable lateral velocity component, rocket will tip over on landing unless it's center of gravity is very low. It happened just once with SpaceX rocket though.
- creatornator 7y agoThe pendulum rocket fallacy refers to the placement of the engine itself, not center of mass. Mass distribution absolutely matters, because with vectored thrust, your engine can exert a higher torque on the rocket if the center of mass is farther away. You can try it yourself with a long pole and weight (e.g. broom with big brush?). Balancing the pole with the weight on top is easier than with the weight on the bottom.