7 ms·
It's time we start manufacturing rockets a bit higher up in the gravity well.
by adrianN 7y ago
It's time we start manufacturing rockets a bit higher up in the gravity well.
- Nodraak 7y agoIt's not only about altitude (going to space is easy), it's also about horizontal velocity (staying in space is hard: 8 km/sec is a lot). I dont recall the exact number, but I think that altitude is 50% of the energy, the other 50% is horizontal velocity. So building a rocket on top of the Everest would save us maybe 5% (10 km vs 100 km altitude), that's not much
- adrianN 7y agoI was thinking at least LEO, not Everest.
- NeutronStar 7y agoThat's still only 10% less gravity, the thing is the ISS goes really fast sideways. Being high isn't enough.
- marcosdumay 7y agoLEO is as much a speed as it is a height.
- adrianN 7y agoObviously? When you want to manufacture things you probably don't want to fall back down right away.
- marcosdumay 7y agoWell, I misunderstood your gravity wheel comment for a static position too.
- Nodraak 7y agoIndeed, sorry. I focused on "higher up" while the important part was "gravity well"
- loeg 7y agoOP wasn’t talking about just altitude.
- petschge 7y agoThe split is actually much more uneven, and heavily on the side of kinetic energy. An orbit at 200 km altitude has an orbital velocity of 7.79 km/s. Potential energy is given by m * g * h (to good approximation, as h is much smaller than the Earth radius of 6300 km) and kinetic energy goes as 0.5 m v^2. Per unit mass (that appears identically in both energy forms) we have potential energy of g * h = 9.81 m / s^2 * 2e5 m = 1.96e6 m^2/s^2. For kinetic energy we find 0.5 * (7.79e3 m/s)^2 = 3e7 m^2/s^2. So only 6% of energy are potential energy, 94% are kinetic energy. For a relatively high orbit with 1500 km and 7.12 km/s the ratio becomes a more even 37% to 63%. If we include the extra 1.5km/s of delta-v that we loose to drag it becomes 28% to 72%. At the typical parameters of stage separation from the first stage the split is 3% to 97%. This is also why replacing the first stage by an airplane (that only gets you altitude, not that much speed) does buy you a lot less than you might think at first. We still need a rocket to go to space, even if you start 12km up.
- ta1234567890 7y agoThank you for the insightful and illustrative calculations :) What would happen if we were able to make it all the way up to space, vertically, but not gain any horizontal speed?
- Tuna-Fish 7y agoIt would only negate 6% of the cost of going to orbit. And you'd have to pay that 94% pretty quickly to not fall down. Except that it would be better than that, because rocket nozzles work best at a specific external pressure, and getting to launch your rocket in vacuum means you can design your engines for strictly that. There are occasionally some ideas of launching rockets from tops of tall mountains, like Kilimanjaro. The advantage directly gained from being 6km closer to space is negligible, but the advantage gained from being able to use more expanded nozzles would be substantial -- albeit likely not worth having to haul your rocket up a mountain to launch it.
- oh_sigh 7y agoYou would just fall back to earth, gaining a lot of speed and then getting destroyed by the atmosphere. Even the force of gravity where the ISS is is pretty similar to at sea level.
- drjesusphd 7y agoUsing ISS parameters, it's more like 8:1, with it taking much more energy to get to speed than altitude. "Low earth orbit is halfway to anywhere in the solar system."
- pjc50 7y agoCurrently all the stuff we want to launch is on the ground, though. Until we have a space elevator, or we're aiming to launch something huge to the outer planets, it doesn't gain us much.
- twic 7y agoJust build taller factories.
- gmiller123456 7y agoActually, it has benefits. Even if you have to launch something from Earth's surface, once in space, the fuel to move it elsewhere can be transported to meet it there much cheaper. The obvious uses are interplanetary travel, circularizing a parabolic orbit, refueling existing satellites.
- polynomial 7y agoNaive question, but don't we have to get all the parts and supplies up there in the first place?
- adrianN 7y agoa) it's easier to lift many smaller parts than to lift one big rocket b) we might start mining raw materials on asteroids or Luna.
- loeg 7y agoAsteroid mining is maybe viable.
- tomxor 7y agoYes, and how much depends how self sustaining you can make the solutions. To illustrate it with an extreme: Some initial mass of machinery must be pushed out of the significant gravity well called Earth at great cost. After which replication of more machinery, manufacturing of rockets and mining of raw materials could be done in much smaller gravity wells (e.g the moon) at significantly less cost to reach orbit again. If this is achievable, your only useful remaining mass to transport from Earth are humans, _less_ the usual long term life support equipment, the payload is relatively tiny... and if you are thinking far ahead enough even those are self replicating :)
- dredmorbius 7y agoThe general alternative falls under the acronym ISRU: in-situ resource utilisation. That's the goal of utilising materials sourced from space environments themselves (Moon, asteroids, etc.) for both structure and fuel for a spaceship. Given that space is mostly, er, space, you've got a bit of a challenge. You have to find non-space stuff that's made of the things you're interested in, and have the capacity to convert it into the forms you need. Which still represents a considerable challenge.
- rkangel 7y agoWhat that article demonstrates is that the important thing is to get fuel from a source a bit higher up the gravity well - that's the dominant mass. We 'just' need a way of making fuel from asteroids or on the moon.
- tim333 7y agoOr Mars. I think Musk has an oxygen and methane plant penciled in for there.
- loeg 7y agoGotta start asteroid mining to make that viable. Not to mention solving the difficulties of keeping humans in space healthy for your construction force (or fully automate it, I suppose).
- Gravityloss 7y agoOr at least using the propellants from shallower gravity wells. Indeed, asteroids are the best places. After that come smaller moons. The Moon, Mars, Earth are very deep and steep gravity wells and not practical. The Moon doesn't have proper elements for fuels anyway.