6 ms·
I was recently staying with a friend in a suburb of Amsterdam. One night we decided to go to dinner. She has three kids and I have two. She piled four of the
by jedberg 7y ago
I was recently staying with a friend in a suburb of Amsterdam. One night we decided to go to dinner. She has three kids and I have two. She piled four of the five kids onto her bike (it had a basket for kids) and headed over. My wife and I and the baby rode in my car. She only got there one minute after me despite it being a few miles away.
I think the reason is because she was able to take the inside passages that are only for bikes, so her trip was much shorter than mine.
So not only are their buildings close together, but they are built around walking/bikes, such that those modes of transit are actually shorter.
- the-dude 7y agoIn almost all NL cities except the biggest ones, a bike outperforms a car on 90%+ of the trips.
- boudewijnrempt 7y agoIn the city where I live, Deventer, at least for the inner city, walking even outperforms biking. I recently got a bike again, but I only use it for going places that would take me 20 minutes or more on foot. Of course, I haven't got a car, have never had a car and haven't even got a driver's license.
- btrettel 7y agoCyclist here. I've told people that this can be true in the US as well (taking the exact same route even). I picked my current apartment because it has a relatively short bike commute. Going from my current apartment to where I work takes about the same amount of time by bike or car because the car is at best 5 minutes faster to the general area but that advantage is quickly lost when one has to park and walk to the building. With my bike I park 100 feet from the door. Some drivers might say that counting time to park is "cheating", but I strongly disagree. Time from door-to-door is what matters.
- rolltiide 7y agoreminds me of "our city is just as big when you count the suburbs!" but by that standard you have to count the bigger city's suburbs too
- jpollock 7y agoWhen you factor in rush hour, it's definitely true for the Bay Area. I live in San Jose, a morning car commute on the 101 is ~30mins, return is ~50-60mins. Riding my bike is 45mins (43-48) each way. It's a complete wash and I get 90mins of exercise per day. If you don't want exercise, get an e-bike and go faster for less effort!
- zbrozek 7y agoI live a lot closer to work - 4.5 miles straight down Central Expressway. Even though my route is no better than what I could do by car, both my average and variance are much better by bike than by car. Typically 15 minutes door-to-door by bike. I can't touch that by car, with evening commutes often taking 45 minutes. I wave at my coworkers when I bike past them.
- retbull 7y agoWhen I am in SF often I can walk faster than I can drive.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoIn La Jolla, I had a bus pass because I had been running errands. I was tired and we had more stuff to do, so I took the bus since I already had a pass good for the whole day. It didn't cost anything. My sons walked to meet me somewhere midway to where we were going. They arrived about the same time I did. I would get ahead of them because the bus is faster -- when it's actually moving. Then we would sit at a light or get stuck in traffic, and I would watch my sons pull ahead of the bus. When we first gave up our car, it took no more time to pick up groceries on foot than by car. The same scenario often took place, where a car would zoom past us, then get stuck trying to turn into the parking lot. We were going into the store while they were looking for a parking space. Cars on the open highway going long distances are absolutely much faster than someone walking. But for many local trips, they aren't as advantageous as many Americans assume them to be and will vociferously argue they are when presented with such stories.
- itronitron 7y agoSpeaking of kids, the distribution and location of schools is a huge factor in where people choose to live in the US, relative to where they work. It would be interesting to also look at statistics on school sizes and locations relative to other countries.
- Moru 7y agoJust one data point: north Sweden, three schools and 4 daycare, 2km radius.
- esotericn 7y agoNorthern Sweden is interesting because there's a ton of space, but really nothing outside of the cities. I've just finished up a job in Luleå and effectively everyone seems to live either in the city or in suburbs that are about 10 minutes drive away. If you gave that sort of space over to the Americans you'd have little towns _everywhere_.
- Moru 7y agoThe Germans are slowly taking over the North so mabe ;) Bikes are well used here and 3-4 km is no problem to bike on flat land, not even if you're untrained. Bike roads are usually straighter to goal and plenty of parking in front of all doors.
- aqme28 7y agoIt's true in New York too. Bike rides are more-often-than-not faster than the car or even the train, depending on the route.
- radiorental 7y agoMy 16 mile commute is quickest on my ebike. Car = 35-40 minutes on average, sometimes more. eBike = 30-35 minutes consistently. The reason - bikes can 'filter' up to a set of lights, whereas a car in heavy traffic might take 2 or 3 rotations of the light to make it through a junction.
- Scoundreller 7y agoDon’t forget about those “no left turn” intersections where you can suddenly turn into a pedestrian.
- outworlder 7y agoYup, the ability to transform into a pedestrian is underrated.
- earthboundkid 7y agoIn Europe, this is strictly forbidden though, which is the one negative to their vastly safer infrastructure.
- anonymouz 7y agoYou can't bike across the crosswalk, but you can get off your bike, step onto the sidewalk and walk your bike across the pedestrian crossing.
- syrrim 7y agoForbidden how? Getting off your bike to cross the street?
- earthboundkid 7y agoIn Copenhagen at least there are rules for when you can turn left on your bike: http://www.aviewfromthecyclepath.com/2010/07/not-really-so-great-cycle-path-design.html http://www.aviewfromthecyclepath.com/2010/07/not-really-so-g... I don't know how other European cities do it.
- jMyles 7y agoThe same is certainly true in Portland, especially if your origin and destination are on or near greenways. At rush hour, a trip from, say, 52nd to the river will take forever in a car accounting for traffic and parking, but is like 10 mins on a bike.
- mdasen 7y agoI'm in Boston and even here my bike gets me places faster than my car, at least between 8-10am and 4-7pm. Traffic is such a killer to car speed. Right now at 3pm, Google Maps tells me that my 6-mile commute home by car would be 32-39 minutes. By bike it's 39-41 minutes for a 7-mile ride. During rush hour, the bike really wins. What makes biking uncomfortable here is that you really have to be alert. A lot of roads don't have good space for bikes and cars can be really aggressive, even if they're just racing toward the next light. Cars just don't move through cities fast when there's traffic. Plus, parking here is just a nightmare.
- outworlder 7y ago> During rush hour, the bike really wins. Also consider that you no longer have to take extra time to exercise, it's now built-in to your commute. At least the cardio side.
- earthboundkid 7y agoIn Boston, riding a bike is suicidal. Driving a car is homicidal. :-)
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoCan't be true. If it were true central/western mass would have a lot less problems. ;)
- kingkawn 7y agoBiking already faster in NYC to get most places than the train, definitely than cabs because of traffic
- lutorm 7y agoThis is one of the most infuriating parts about the road layout where I live now. Everything is built as small residential cul-de-sacs without any access except the entry from the main street. I can look at my neighbor's house 100ft away but there's no way to get there, even as a pedestrian, except walking out on the busy main street (with no sidewalks), walking half a mile down the road, and then walking half a mile back up their residential street. It's like they actively try to discourage any mode of transportation except driving.
- xyzzyz 7y agoThe point of cul de sacs is to discourage people who do not live there from passing through. They are there to discourage all driving except your driving.
- Scarblac 7y agoSo why not a sidewalk connecting them?
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoBecause towns don't insist on it, it costs money and it's less land that's free to develop.
- xyzzyz 7y agoI wouldn't mind that, but with the decay of community life in America, people aren't all that interested in easy access to their neighbors.
- lutorm 7y agoExactly, they think transportation==driving. That's the problem.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoThat used to be my pet hate on trips to the US - it definitely felt like active discouragement - finding the pavement would just stop with no warning, or being able to see and almost touch the place I wanted to get to next block or lot, but getting there was a major hike. All that lovely California sun, why on earth would I want to be in the rental car for only a mile or two? :) Cul-de-sacs are fairly popular in current UK estate designs, but usually - not always - include footpaths to link the obvious places. Mostly goes with shopping areas too - if you have walked, you can usually shortcut most of the road routing. That said, UK cycle friendly is mostly tokenism - a few efforts, a few half hearted painted lanes, but it's inconsistent. Pedestrian friendliness is usually pretty good.
- mturmon 7y agoI live in LA. I'm not sure if it's just my changing age, but my perception is that, due to traffic and parking, people now do much more business locally than they did in the 1990s. This implies more biking, walking and alternative transportation. By locally, I mean "within Silver Lake" or "within Echo Park" -- shopping, groceries, and especially casual dining. My belief is that pockets of density are slowly emerging.
- Scarblac 7y agoThe city of Groningen had a great idea in the 70s. They wanted less car traffic in the inner city. So now there is a ring road around it, and the center itself is divided into four parts, with one-way streets laid out so that if you want to go from one part to another, you have to go to the ring road. Cars can't travel through the center, they have to go around it. In the center you only get cars that have that as their destination. But, all these one-way streets are marked "except for bicycles". None of the above applies to bicycles. So for even quite long trips, say from the north of the city to the south, bicycles beat cars because they can just go straight through the center and cars have to take the long way around.