3 ms·
Honestly, I have never wanted user-definable menu shortcuts on a 90's desktop application either. Each time I saw it, it was a crutch for making a badly designe
by marcosdumay 7y ago
Honestly, I have never wanted user-definable menu shortcuts on a 90's desktop application either. Each time I saw it, it was a crutch for making a badly designed menu a bit less worse, and things would be much better if the time spent on that feature was simply spent on a better menu.
Very few CAD programs gained something from customized menus (not icons). But this one was also almost always a crutch for fixing bad designs, and those same few programs always gained much more by having a good keyboard based interface.
- chipotle_coyote 7y agoThere's a few times I've used macOS's ability to define menu shortcuts -- although it's generally either to add a shortcut to a menu item that didn't have one or to make the shortcut consistent with the OS and/or other applications. But in general, it's not something I think of as a critical missing feature in apps, you're right.
- fjp 7y agoEven if everyone is doing everything really well, there will always be the endless battle between "usability" aka having a few obviously-named-and-organized features that a new user can instantly understand (while severely limiting overall functionality) - think Asana task management software - vs. "flexibility" which is having all the features anyone could want which almost invariable leads to bloated incomprehensible menus that lead to menus that lead to more damn menus - think Jira or Salesforce. I think non-enterprise sites/web apps are usually going to tack toward "usability" and enterprise sites/web apps are usually going to tack toward "flexibility".