3 ms·

Just saying, you said this is new therefore invalid. Now you talk about it being different therefore invalid. I think you are a holding a political position but

Just saying, you said this is new therefore invalid. Now you talk about it being different therefore invalid. I think you are a holding a political position but trying to mask it with random requests for legitimacy. Back to your original statement, when do you give legitimacy to a movement?

Arkhaine_kupo 7y ago
On the basis of cultural, religious or ethnic differences. Palestine, taiwan, kurdistan, the division of middle east in ethnic groups instead of ww1 borders, The divisons we have seen in Congo in the last 30 years, even the indigenous people of Peru probably with their recent protests againt Lenin Moreno all have claims to needing due to incapability to form an understanding with the central goverment to be allowed to have their own country. Catalunya has no historical, political, religious or ethnic divide with Spain. Literally 0. Their tripartit is gonna be mimic now by Cuidadanos, PP and PSOE. Their elites are just as corrupts as madrid. They are as religious as anywhere else in Spain. Catalunya has never been a historical region unless you concede Aragorns crown to be fundamentally Catalan but even then it is ages ago. Basque country has a much better claim to indepdence in my opinion, and I still do not think they deserve the right of self determination. Not only in part because a great claim of their ethnic difference is still based in anti Spanish racism.