6 ms·
> With an eventual flight rate of once per day per Starship, Gwynne Shotwell said that their business plan for using Starship to compete with long-distance air
by bryanlarsen 7y ago
> With an eventual flight rate of once per day per Starship,
Gwynne Shotwell said that their business plan for using Starship to compete with long-distance airliners involved making about a dozen trips per day per Starship.
- avmich 7y ago> about a dozen trips per day per Starship Gagarin flew for around 108 minutes, so orbital velocity allows longest trip between two points on Earth in about 54 minutes. Shorter trips could be less, but liftoff-landing take roughly a fixed amount of time. Twelve trips per day is 2 hours per trip. Taking 40 minutes of flight, there are 1 hour 20 minutes to get onboard, to get off board, to handle luggage (if needed?), to refuel and check systems. Wonder how does it look from airlines operation prospective.
- madaxe_again 7y agoThat stands pretty much parallel with aviation turnarounds - it’s purely logistics. If they don’t need to do any maintenance other than standardised checklists between flights, which is their ambition, there’s no fundamental reason they couldn’t do this.
- deadbunny 7y agoA (very) cursory search turned up this[1], which suggests they can turn around what appears to be a relatively short haul aircraft in ~50 mins arrival to departure. My uneducated guess would be that refueling of a starship alone is likely to take a long time if you're pumping in 1,200 tons of fuel. 1. https://your.heathrow.com/happens-aircraft-turn-around-british-airways/ https://your.heathrow.com/happens-aircraft-turn-around-briti...
- Consultant32452 7y agoDo all orbital flights take off in the same direction due to the rotation of the Earth?
- gpm 7y ago"Most" would be more accurate. Flights that want to orbit over the poles take off aiming perpendicular to the rotation instead. A few satellites have been launched backwards intentionally.
- isostatic 7y agoI think sun synchronous orbits are retrograde P2P sub orbital hops are either direction, 30-40 minutes, maybe 25 for shorter trips like London to New York.
- gpm 7y agoAgreed that P2P sub orbital hops are any direction. Low sun synchronous orbits are approximately the same as polar oribts, more perpendicular than retrograde. I'm not sure if we use high sun synchronous orbits for anything?
- isostatic 7y agoSun sync is approx 98.7 degrees at 800km - so slightly retrograde (prograde being 0-90) Majority of LEO sats are sun sync
- Tuna-Fish 7y agoAll satellites that want to efficiently get into somewhat equatorial orbit do. However, satellites heading to polar orbits of course launch north or south, and famously Israel launches things into retrograde orbits, due west, because of lack of suitable launching locations that head east. In the case of suborbital hops, it doesn't matter, because your target isn't orbital speed, and what you lose in free speed you gain back in your target coming towards you as you hop.
- gameswithgo 7y agoI wonder if anyone with sufficient experience in rockets could comment on whether that idea is at all plausible.
- chasd00 7y agoi have no experience but, man, it would be so freaking noisy. where would they take off and land?
- donkeyd 7y agoYup, that's the big issue. Being able to fly London to NY in 30 minutes is great, but the landing/launch sites will have to be pretty far from the cities to have the sonic booms not break windows all the time. That increases total travel time.
- ralusek 7y agoAnd then you can just travel through Boring tunnels.
- deadbunny 7y agoSome routes would definitely be worth it. Opposite sides of the world would become connected like never before. If I could catch a "flight" to Australia (from the UK) in the time it takes to fly to New York it would be game changing. Hell even 4 hours to LA would be preferable to the 11 hour flight time + 2 hours either side it takes now.
- jandrese 7y agoBut would you be willing to pay 10x or 20x the cost of a "slow" conventional airline ticket for it? The fuel costs may be low by space launch standards, but they'll be huge by commercial airline standards.
- bryanlarsen 7y ago
- DennisP 7y agoAnd in his recent big presentation, Musk said they hoped to ultimately reach three daily flights to orbit for each Starship, and thirty per day for each first stage. He said at that rate, with ten Starships they would have a thousand times the launch capacity of the entire world right now including Falcon 9/Heavy.
- tbabb 7y agoThis is not happening soon. Safety/redundancy of rockets (including SpaceX's) compared to airliners is abysmal—about five orders of magnitude worse. With passenger manifests in the hundreds (necessary for the economics to work), and with any failure being catastrophic, you'll be seeing multiple Tenerife disasters [1] per year. You also can't launch a rocket (especially one that big) anywhere near a major city for sound and safety reasons, which means at best you are building an offshore spaceport, which is terrible for the logistics and economics. But that's still nothing compared to the safety problem. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tenerife_airport_disaster https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tenerife_airport_disaster
- randyrand 7y agoWhen does startship need to light its engines on landing? What about landing in a 2000 foot deep hole in the ground?
- tbabb 7y agoI don't follow. What's the hole for?
- londons_explore 7y agoThe sound reasons could potentially be mitigated by launching behind a wall, acting as a sound reflector right? Humans can build walls 1km high or more without much difficulty, and by the time the rocket is 1km up, it is already moving pretty fast, and is already much further away.