23 ms·
PG&E turning off power to protect against fire has created a new disaster
- dredmorbius 7y agoDirect link to article: https://slate.com/business/2019/10/california-power-outage-pge-fires-new-kind-of-disaster.html https://slate.com/business/2019/10/california-power-outage-p...
- dang 7y agoOk, we've changed to that from https://twitter.com/aprilaser/status/1188870991390232582 https://twitter.com/aprilaser/status/1188870991390232582. Thanks!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- maximente 7y agocali has added 10 million people since 1990 but 30% of PG&E's infrastructure is over a century old. also in the 1990s, deregulation allowed the valuable parts of various electricity companies to be sold off in a classic private equity vulture move, leaving the utilities basically holding the bag on largely crufty shells. the governor said it all: > Wilson admitted publicly that defects in the deregulation system would need fixing by "the next governor". it's hard to imagine this ending well. i would advocate for regulatory enforcement via state attorney general election as the most direct /potential/ route for changing things. obviously jailing executives would be more effective, but despite way more deaths than boeing, that seems unlikely.
- danans 7y ago> the governor said it all: > Wilson admitted publicly that defects in the deregulation... For anyone who may be less familiar with 90s CA politics, this refers to then governor Pete Wilson (R) who was responsible for the utility deregulation which then became an albatross around his successors' necks.
- ars 7y agoLots of states have deregulated. but other states have not had the experience of California. What makes California different that deregulation failed so badly?
- SamReidHughes 7y agoWell, the current situation couldn’t happen in states with low risk of wildfires...
- m463 7y ago"According to a 2007 study of Department of Energy data by Power in the Public Interest, retail electricity prices rose much more from 1999 to 2007 in states that adopted deregulation than in those that did not.[23]" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_electricity_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_electricity_crisis
- roenxi 7y ago"Deregulation" is a term that doesn't convey much information. In Australia we 'deregulated' the power industry. That means that we swapped shareholders in for government collecting the profit and removed some of the regulations. The problem is that the remaining regulations created a hugely complicated market and still involved a lot of price controls for arbitrary things. Eg, "network charges component of retail electricity prices is set ... by the Australian Energy Regulator ... based on ...operational and maintenance expenditure" [0]. So we have an unregulated market where the cost of electricity goes crazy because wholesalers overspend on grid maintenance and get no-risk profit. I don't know how California tried to do it, but in Australia deregulation didn't mean 'try and set prices using a market'. That was too hard and they didn't manage to set up a system that worked. It meant 'try and redirect profit from government to private enterprise'. Not surprisingly, the whole system is a disaster and worse than if they hadn't ever tried. I still think an actual free-market system would have worked but the design might be too delicate to run the political gauntlet and get legislated. [0] https://www.rba.gov.au/information/foi/disclosure-log/pdf/101115.pdf https://www.rba.gov.au/information/foi/disclosure-log/pdf/10... - I think I'm characterising the situation fairly but rely heavily on general knowledge.
- njarboe 7y agoPG&E is already a highly regulated company. So much so that one could say that it is really state controlled [1]. "Among its stated goals for energy regulation are to establish service standards and safety rules, authorize utility rate changes, oversee markets to inhibit anti-competitive activity, prosecute unlawful utility marketing and billing activities, govern business relationships between utilities and their affiliates, resolve complaints by customers against utilities, implement energy efficiency and conservation programs and programs for the low-income and disabled, oversee the merger and restructure of utility corporations, and enforce the California Environmental Quality Act for utility construction." [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Public_Utilities_Commission https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Public_Utilities_Co...
- BubRoss 7y agoThe 'new kind of disaster' is just what you would expect from no electricity - dialysis, medicine in general, poor people having their remaining food spoil, etc. Saved you a click.
- newguy1234 7y agoAnother issue I saw on the news was that firefighters couldn't fight a fire because the water pressure was too low. Turns out the water utility lost power and didn't have any backup power. They couldn't pump water from the wells.
- dredmorbius 7y agoMost regions have some sort of above-grade water tanks. Not the water towers you'll find in the plains states, but tanks built upslope of served areas. Though these are filled by powered pumps, they'll supply enormous amounts of water even after power is cut. In San Francisco there are numerous reservoirs, virtually all decked over. Four of the highest are located near Twin Peaks, the highest point in the city: https://www.google.com/maps/place/Sutro+Reservoir,+San+Francisco,+CA+94131/@37.7520825,-122.455615,15z/data=!4m5!1m2!2m1!1sreservoir!3m1!1s0x808f7dfb3135dc73:0x24f109be56aaf920 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Sutro+Reservoir,+San+Franc...
- code_duck 7y agoI guess the problem is for places that don't have that.
- dredmorbius 7y agoYou'd be hard-pressed to find such in California, is my general point. I'd be interested in specific citations of exceptions to the rule.
- faissaloo 7y agoAppreciated
- jnwatson 7y agoI happen to be vacationing in Northern CA this week. We drove up the coast on Hwy 1 then 101 from Oakland to Crescent City. After we left Oakland, we saw no public power for 250 miles. Just a handful of places were open with generators. There was 1 open gas station for all of Hwy 1. We waited in line an hour. The economic impact of this event is mind boggling.
- zaroth 7y agoThey should hold PG&E liable for that! </s>
- linusnext 7y agoGiven that we lost cell coverage as well as power. Really regretting the Tesla after 3 days without power.
- newguy1234 7y agoAgree. I think Tesla car is a bad idea, especially if you don't have solar panels on your roof or a generator.
- ghaff 7y agoIn all fairness, multi-day power outages are a really rare event in a lot of places. And many households that own an EV also own an ICE vehicle. Also if power is out, you're not going to be able to fuel up either in the affected area. But, yes, with extended power outages the general shift towards cell phones, EVs, etc. can make the consequences of not having electricity worse. Presumably at some point there will be more single-home panels and batteries that allow for extended disconnection from the grid but we're mostly not there today.
- delfinom 7y ago>In all fairness, multi-day power outages are a really rare event in a lot of places. And many households that own an EV also own an ICE vehicle. Also if power is out, you're not going to be able to fuel up either in the affected area. Hah. I thought about this. In NY, we lost power for a month after hurricane sandy because the public utility completely imploded due the years of corruption finally reaching criticality when the hurricane came through. It was so bad they privatized the power grid. Anyone with a EV would have been absolutely fucked in the meantime. We even had gasoline rationing because :surprise: many gas stations had no power to run the pumps. (Gas stations now mandated by law to have generators). Present, one is better off having an ICE vehicle instead of an EV if one lives anywhere with bad weather events and not living in a city where you can just walk everywhere.
- ghaff 7y ago
- ars 7y agoHere is an example: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-california-wildfire/as-wildfire-rages-in-los-angeles-city-tells-wealthy-to-warn-staff-of-dangers-idUSKBN1X813H https://www.reuters.com/article/us-california-wildfire/as-wi... A branch broke and landed on a power line, sparking a fire. I'm curious what PG&E could do different, it sounds like the tree wasn't even very close to the power line, but wind pushed it. Turning off power like this during wind-storms might be the permanent new normal.
- r00fus 7y agoUnderground the power distribution like in France. It’s expensive but probably less costly in the long run.
- m463 7y agoFrance does everything right (but it also does everything wrong.)
- ars 7y agoWouldn't that cost something like $1 trillion to do for the entire state? Math: 155147 miles * $750/foot And an article https://www.desertsun.com/story/news/environment/2019/10/11/cost-to-bury-california-fire-prone-power-lines-why-not/3937653002/ https://www.desertsun.com/story/news/environment/2019/10/11/... confirming it's pretty much out of reach. $15,000 per household estimate (and 1,000 years!!).
- sjg007 7y agoWell then everyone has local solar with a powerwall for when PG&E shuts down. Maybe that's cheaper? Honestly I think PG&E could bury the lines cheaper than $750 a foot.
- SllX 7y agoMaybe, but I think CEQA will pretty much guarantee that it will end up being a bit more expensive than even that.
- kordlessagain 7y agoDuring the first wave of outages for winds up North, PG&E shut off Moraga's power. We had very little winds aloft, but a few hours into the outage, some idiot started a fire with a vape (that's the story) which caused a mini evacuation from our neighborhood at 3AM....IN THE DARK. Today, while Orinda and Lafayette had no power, we did. Extremely windy today! The reason our outages are backwards appears to be due to the fact we're a tiny branch off a main line that runs well North of here. They can't turn us down unless they turn all those people down as well. By my guess our chances of fire are pretty were pretty much a guarantee from this whole thing. Thanks PG&E.
- FooHentai 7y agoRight, but it'd be a fire that PG&E aren't responsible for starting. This is the outcome of threatening to enforce responsibility on PG&E for fires caused by their lines. Not to say this is the way it had to go, the alternative I see a lot of people proposing is that some level of additional investment in lines maintenance/clearing would have allowed PG&E to safely continue supplying power through the dry season. What I don't see there though is any consideration as to whether that made financial sense for the company. Given that anything other than a naive view of the world tells us that a private corporation's focus will be it's liabilities and bottom line, it's hard to see (admittedly from the huge distance at which I stand) what other way this could have gone.
- cddotdotslash 7y agoIt's absolutely crazy reading about these events happening in a first world country in the richest state in that country. Something has gone seriously wrong when we're seeing near-daily stories about power outages in the tech capital of the world. Combined with all the other issues plaguing CA right now, I can't see why companies still base themselves there. Eventually the "all the tech people are there" argument won't be strong enough and competing markets like NYC, Seattle, and Austin will win out.
- dredmorbius 7y agoIn many parts of the world, power is unreliable due to a lack of resources -- fuel, capital, labour, distribution, maintenance. Power cuts occur, either scheduled or unscheduled, due to an inability to meet demand. The case in California is different. The fundamental resources are present: there is fuel (or, in many cases, hydroelectric, geothermal, nuclear, wind, or solar power) for generation. Distribution systems exist. There is no shortage of local labour. Systems aren't going offline due to direct failures of maintenance. Rather: the outages are prompted by a consequence risk. Given the extreme fire danger throughout the state, the least source of ignition creates a fire hazard, and electrical transmission and distribution equipment is a high risk for such ignition. Previous major wildfires have been sparked by: mower blades, rims of flat tires sparking on pavement, catalytic converters parked over dry grass, sparks from a hammer. And electrical equipment. There's a case to be made that PG&E have neglected maintenance activies not related directly to continued operation of their plant, but to risk mitigation, and I'm not going to argue one way or the other. But the fundamental problem California's electric utilities face is not that of most of the world, where means are insufficient, but that consequence is too great to ignore. I'm coming to see this generally as a late-stage dynamic in many technological areas, one in which the unintended consequences (sometimes unanticipated, often not) simply rise to a level of major significance. You might think of these generally as hygiene factors (the phrase I've been using). Past examples would include: - Basic personal and public hygiene factors for maintaining public health in cities. - Pollution control laws affecting solid, liquid, and gas emissions of activities and plants. - Environmental contamination as with lead, asbestos, pesticides, tobacco, sulfur dioxide ("acid rain"), and CO2. - Individual psychological and widespread sociological negative impacts of information overload, media saturation and manipulation, and computer systems overexposure. - Running extensive high-capacity electrical distribution systems through increasingly fire-prone landscapes. Or put another way: this is increasingly our future.
- RachelF 7y agoI'm not from the USA, is my understanding of this correct? The power utility is liable for fires caused if a branch blows into its power lines during high winds. So the power utility has chosen to turn off the power in high winds?
- rootsudo 7y agoThe other thing is not maintaining the lines or area surrounding them because of the NIMBY idealism of most Californians and/or graft.
- thrower123 7y agoRight. This is hugely a result of mismanagement and failure to invest properly, combined with disastrous forestry policy.
- nefitty 7y agoThat is a cynical conclusion, but the incentives are aligned for that it to be logical. The article framed the motive as to try "avoiding disaster". It seems like the most rational decision for PG&E to take considering the circumstances.
- newguy1234 7y agoCorrect. If a fire is started and the ignition of that fire is shown to be linked to a utility's assets (power lines, gas line etc.) then all the damage caused by the fire could become a lawsuit liability for the fire.
- Symmetry 7y agoAnd, importantly, in California utilities culpable for fires whether they acted negligently or not. https://www.counties.org/sites/main/files/file-attachments/inverse_condemnation_fact_sheet_league__csac.pdf https://www.counties.org/sites/main/files/file-attachments/i...
- kuschku 7y ago
- dawnerd 7y agoDon't see many people talking about the additional environmental impact this is causing from people running generators nonstop. PG&E should be buying everyone in their area solar panels and battery backups. That'd help alleviate a lot of the problems - and probably be cheaper in the long run.
- dredmorbius 7y agoMost grid-tied home solar installations cannot function without the grid. Depending on manufacturer and/or utility, you may simply not have the option to install free-standing solar capacity. That means generators are the only sustaining power option. For those medically-dependent on electricity, this has been a massive factor, with deaths reported as a consequence. Economic hardship and other impacts are also very real. Given the balance between this and the risk of tens of thousands made homeless through repeats of events such as last year's Camp Fire in Paradise, preemptive power cuts still seem defensible. But impacts really must be addressed.
- onetimemanytime 7y ago>>PG&E should be buying everyone in their area solar panels and battery backups. That'd help alleviate a lot of the problems - and probably be cheaper in the long run. How about e Tesla too? Just to be sure...
- acadien 7y agoTime to start burying the powerlines fellow Californians.
- dgfdsgdsgv 7y agoDo you have any idea how expensive that is?
- sagichmal 7y agoProbably a lot less expensive than multiple major fires per year + rolling multi-day blackouts for millions of households.
- j79 7y ago> It also includes families and individuals who live paycheck to paycheck and can barely afford the groceries currently in their fridge, which will likely spoil. In addition to the financial burden for these families, there's also the potential health impacts of eating spoiled food. Personally, I was hesitant to waste food that my wife had just purchased a few days prior. My stomach disagreed with that decision, and I spent most of my Sunday sitting in the bathroom with no power or cell service. We're now dealing with the question of WHEN to replenish our food. I've also considered purchasing a generator for just powering the fridge. But, this is all new and any advice would be greatly appreciated.
- dillonmckay 7y agoI have experience in hurricanes and other natural disasters. I purchased a decent size inverter (from Harbor Freight), and used that to power a full-size refrigerator. It is hooked up to the car, and running the car will charge the battery.
- ppf 7y agoCalifornia, leading the world in climate change activism, as its residents rush out to buy cheap generators and idle their cars to get power. Yay!
- dillonmckay 7y agoIt could be a diesel vehicle that is powered by vegetable oil.
- ppf 7y agoEven better! Let's deforest huge areas of virgin forest for crappy vegetable oil plantations, and then fill our own air with particulates that are awful for anything with lungs.
- throw0101a 7y ago> But, this is all new and any advice would be greatly appreciated. This video shows the three main ways to legally / safely connect a generator: * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CKwBBesUKA8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CKwBBesUKA8 Method 1 is the simplest and involves running an extension cord to the appliance(s) you want powered; or a power bar if you want multiple. Method 3 is the most expensive, and it involves buying a very big generator to power the whole house, making sure there is a mechanism that prevents power back-feeding into the grid. Method 2 is probably what you may want to look into. You purchase a small/medium generator as well as an electrical sub-panel. You then re-wire any appliances to the sub-panel. When the power goes out, you change the sub-panel's incoming feed from the main panel to the generator, which will then power your pre-selected appliances. A potato-quality video illustrating Method 2: * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lkbBt8hv8mQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lkbBt8hv8mQ
- methodiosmel 7y agoThis is due to poor power line maintenance by PG&E as well as bad policies pushed by the environmental lobby. It should be acceptable to clear all vegetation around power lines, yet due to pressure from environmentalists, PG&E is only allowed to trim trees up to a few feet from power lines.
- z92 7y agoThe question is : How many fires are there in CA yearly? It's like 2000 to 4000 different fires that start at different places in the same season. And how many of those were started because of PG&E? 2? 3? But PG&E has to pay for every fire they cause, because they can. And now they don't want to. The consequence.
- scottrogers86 7y agoRead the article... "The company was found responsible for 17 of the 21 major fires that blazed across California in 2017 alone. It was responsible for the deadliest fire in California history last year, the Camp Fire, where 86 people were found dead and more than 50,000 were displaced."
- tapland 7y agoI don't really understand this. You are making claims about causes and effects without having (ever?) read about california fires and why they are started? Isn't that the bare minimum expected to even have an opinion, let alone engage in a discussion about it?
- orf 7y agoNot anymore, unfortunately.
- noodlesUK 7y agoSurely at this point the state has emergency powers to nationalise PG&E and seize control altogether. Why hasn’t that happened yet?
- onetimemanytime 7y ago....and do what? Pay the bills for all the damage and keep starting new fires? No easy answer, taxes will have to be raised by a lot
- mschuster91 7y ago> No easy answer, taxes will have to be raised by a lot The alternative to raising taxes is to cut bullshit government spending and tax breaks for mega corporations, or enforcing taxes against the rich.
- delfinom 7y agoThe proper thing is the state gives towns emergency powers to start building fire breaks state wide as they should have been all these years. Any town refusing to build fire breaks because "mah property values" or "eyesore" should have their town charter dissolved.
- colechristensen 7y agoPG&E needs to be found liable and the bankruptcy judge needs to wipe out shareholders and break up the infrastructure assets and give them to local municipalities and the state. Shareholders need to face consequences sometimes, because they, the owners, are ultimately responsible, not rate-payers.
- TheHypnotist 7y agoThat sounds like a disastrous solution.
- Symmetry 7y agoHow would that help? Both the state and utilities are strictly liable for fires they cause in California and I don't see the state as being any more willing to assume that liability go bankrupt than PG&E is. It's already the state that decides how much gets spent on maintenance and the relevant regulatory agency hasn't been willing to let PG&E raise its rates. I guess if its nationalized they could raise taxes instead of raising electricity rates but that sounds equally politically infeasible.
- rayiner 7y agoThe level of political demagoguery surrounding this is really shocking. Gavin Newsom is blaming “dog eat dog capitalism” and “corporate greed” for the wildfires: https://www.sfchronicle.com/california-wildfires/article/Newsom-PG-E-SoCal-utilities-undermined-14560015.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/california-wildfires/article/New... Of course, PG&E is the kind of regulated entity people like Newsom wish all corporations were. Private investors put up the capital to build and maintain the electric grid. The government, through the California Public Utility Commission, tells them what to spend it on: https://www.pge.com/en_US/about-pge/company-information/regulation/general-rate-case/grc.page https://www.pge.com/en_US/about-pge/company-information/regu.... The CPUC reviews PG&E’s proposed expenditures and approves the resulting electric rates. The CPUC then allows PG&E to set rates high enough to recover a 10% profit on that expenditure.[1] Under that regime, PG&E’s incentive is to spend more money gold plating the electric grid. The more it spends, the more profit it makes. The reason PG&E didn’t spend more money on wild fire safety is because the CPUC is run by political appointees and they have strong incentives to keep electric rates low in the short term. (This is a common problem with rate regulated utilities. They underinvest in infrastructure because voters demand low rates for electric, water, etc.) Now of course, California doesn’t have the money to build its own electric grid. So Newsom is calling on Buffett to bail out PG&E. I.e. let different private investors take in the risk and expense of the CPUC’s years of short sighted behavior. And, of course, this is the kind of thing that only happens in America, and maybe some third world countries. Not because Europe doesn’t have investor owned utilities. They are common. Some of the largest grid operators in Germany are private companies. Rather, it seems to be the result of the unique political dysfunction in the US. American politicians and their voters live in a fantasy land where they can literally say the grass is blue and the sky is green because that fits into their narratives about the world. [1] That’s about what it works out to. It’s a more complicated rate return calculation: https://www.cpuc.ca.gov/uploadedFiles/CPUCWebsite/Content/About_Us/Organization/Divisions/Office_of_Governmental_Affairs/Legislation/2018/California%20Electric%20And%20Gas%20Utility%20Cost%20Report.pdf https://www.cpuc.ca.gov/uploadedFiles/CPUCWebsite/Content/Ab....
- taurath 7y agoAll this to say, it’s the governments fault for allowing PG&E to have the incentives it does. And I’d agree with you to an extent, but the solution being privatizing it and deregulating the power system is... maybe not the best. Corporations almost always have the same incentive structure as what you’re saying the CPUC has, short term profits over long term. The only difference is that rates would be higher along with PG&Es profits, since nobody would go in and build a second power grid and they’d have a de facto monopoly.
- delfinom 7y agoPG&E is being turned into a witch to hang on the stake. But people are seriously completely missing the real problem. California is a gigantic tinderbox of mismanaged forests, tons of dead and dry material laying around and with climate change, shit is even drier. California is going to catch fire whether the power is on or not. A fucking car trailer started one of the major fires last year. There's at least a decade of completely piss poor forest management responsible without controlled burns and fire breaks to plan for the _naturally destined to occur forest fires_.
- ransom1538 7y agoYes. And! this isn't new. The Japanese during world war ii figured it was their only shot to upset the war. The Japanese figured California was so dry that just igniting a few trees could cause a state wide fire. https://www.npr.org/sections/npr-history-dept/2015/01/20/375820191/beware-of-japanese-balloon-bombs https://www.npr.org/sections/npr-history-dept/2015/01/20/375...
- nostrademons 7y agoThis was also the target of the only submarine-launched air strike: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lookout_Air_Raids https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lookout_Air_Raids Their premise - or at least their navigation - ended up being incorrect though: they dropped their bombs in Oregon, and the fires were extinguished by rain before they could do serious damage.
- bluntfang 7y ago>PG&E is being turned into a witch...There's at least a decade of completely piss poor forest management Uh huh, so why are you looking for a witch in forest management? The forest is managing itself just fine, it just so happens that it doesn't benefit American suburban sprawl.
- throwawayhhakdl 7y agoThe forest is trying to manage itself but is being prevented by humans. Forests are supposed to burn occasionally. We have prevented this from happening. Now there’s far too much old dry foliage to burn, so when a fire starts, it gets crazy. Smoky the bear is the unintended enemy of the forest.
- jwilk 7y agoArchived copy without GDPR nag screen: https://web.archive.org/web/20191009215000/https://slate.com/business/2019/10/california-power-outage-pge-fires-new-kind-of-disaster.html https://web.archive.org/web/20191009215000/https://slate.com...
- collsni 7y agoI'm not sure what you expected, holding a company liable. Expect it to reduce its own liability.
- supahfly_remix 7y agoCould this disaster be turned into an opportunity? Could it spur decentralized approached to energy creation, such as solar with a power wall? California has so many inventive people and access to capital. Maybe this could be the impetus that would let them and us kick the hydrocarbon habit.
- bluGill 7y agoperhaps, but larger central power systems are in general better. They are cheaper because you can share generation ensuring that if one generator goes out the others can take over.
- takanori 7y agoThis was my thought as well. Nothing like a crisis to spur invention. I did the math on a power wall. It’s too expensive to be feasible. Two units with installation cost $20K. That doesn’t include the solar panels required to keep it charged. You can get a gas generator with similar capacity for $5K. Not to mention gas is typically readily available.
- supahfly_remix 7y agohow about coupling your BEV (if you own one) to your house to maybe require a smaller battery? not trying to solve this problem there, but rather to encourage people to view this as an opportunity. i know that if power outages were to become common, i would be willing to spend money to address this problem for me and my family.
- hcurtiss 7y agoExactly right. I got a Harbor Freight generator, installed a natural gas carburetor and plumbed in a quick release valve on our outside natural gas line. It will run the whole house, including the gas furnace and water heater. I love the idea of battery backup for our solar panels, but it's super expensive, and the payoff is so distant the NPV approaches zero.
- 7y ago
- takanori 7y agoHow does routing work in these power lines? Is it similar to a network where you can route around problematic hubs? So if there is a line going through 4 miles of trees, you can just turn that part off... not the whole county?
- etimberg 7y agoYou can turn off a line if you have capacity elsewhere. The problem is that as the current increases in a line the temperature of the line increases. This causes thermal expansion and if not well managed, a line can sag too low and have to be turned off. This was one of the causes of the 2003 northeast blackout. The other option is to have local generation that can supply local load but that is still quite hard to do with renewables.
- takanori 7y agoThat makes sense. This is a century old problem. Are there no viable technical solutions?
- shortandsweet 7y agoThere are. More paths (lines) or bigger, beefier lines with operational margin built in. Costs more money though.
- themaninthedark 7y agoYou could add more generators over an area to make grid more self sustaining but many people don't want power plants in their backyard and it is costly as you are paying for generating capacity that you don't use(often)
- dredmorbius 7y agoThat happened also in the Western US power blackouts of 1996, specifically the August 10 incident. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1996_Western_North_America_blackouts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1996_Western_North_America_bla...
- 7y ago
- danielfoster 7y agoA major part of the issue here is that although PQ&E is a private company, they're heavily regulated by the state. Price controls plus a political mandate to invest in green industry has left it with few resources for maintaining existing infrastructure.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Price controls plus a political mandate to invest in green industry has left it with few resources for maintaining existing infrastructure. But, until their long failure to invest in required maintenance started manifesting in massive liabilities for fires in 2017, plenty of money to return $billions to shareholders in dividends; clearly, in your understanding, those funds weren't a fungible resource that could have instead been invested in maintenance. (An understanding not shared by the federal judge overseeing their criminal probation for their felony conviction in the 2010 San Bruno gas explosion, who—in finding their actions leading to the 2017 and 2018 fires to be a violation of that probation—placed the blame for the fires squarely on PG&E’s decision to, for years, prioritize dividends over required maintenance.)
- hcurtiss 7y agoThose dividends are necessary to raise the private capital necessary to run PG&E. It's not a charity, and it's certainly not a "market." It's a state-sponsored monopoly. The only other ways to fund it are increased energy prices or tax dollars.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Those dividends are necessary to raise the private capital necessary to run PG&E. Private capital is only required to have someone to return dividends to. > It's not a charity Yes, exactly, because it's a for profit institution, it is structurally incentivized to return profits to investors. > It's a state-sponsored monopoly. Which makes it being a private, profit-making enterprise nonsensical, exactly.
- 7y ago
- m3kw9 7y agoBuilding powerlines that can cause fires if something this easy can cause it shouldn’t be legal. Would you be ok with having your electronic devices set on fire because you dropped it or something easy?
- williesleg 7y agoOh they'll be sued out of existence. And the smart will leave California like they have for years, leading to the Mexico takeover of the left coast.
- Bostonian 7y agohttps://www.wsj.com/articles/revolutionary-california-11572389585 https://www.wsj.com/articles/revolutionary-california-115723... Revolutionary California Wall Street Journal ^ | October 29, 2019 | Holman W. Jenkins ... The wildfire crisis is ultimately the product of a state politics controlled by interest groups whose agenda has drifted out of any cognizable relationship with the daily well-being of the state’s average citizen. Because California accounts for less than 1% of global emissions, nothing it does will make a difference to climate, but its ratepayers shell out billions for wind and solar that might be better spent on fireproofing. A generation of ill-judged environmental activism has all but ended forest management in favor of letting dead trees and underbrush build up because it’s more “natural.” At the same time, residents resist any natural or planned fires that would consume this tinder before it gives rise to conflagrations like those now menacing Los Angeles and San Francisco. An activist state Supreme Court imposed on utilities responsibility for any wildfires started by their equipment regardless of negligence. At the same time, state policy obliges them to extend their networks to support housing developments in areas the state designates as “very high fire risk.” California’s activist one-party government, with its penchant for pretending to be a national government in relation to the hot-button issues of the left, is where all these roads end. Elites subsidize electric cars for themselves while promoting zoning that forces lower-income workers to commute three hours to a job or live in their cars. PG&E can’t keep trees off its power lines but can supply exact numbers for how many LGBTQ workers it employs.
- imglorp 7y ago> every mile of power line that’s been shut off needs to be inspected visually, by foot or vehicle or air. [...] The work can’t be done in the dark. Can a sense current be run through the idle lines, to detect ground faults before going back to full power?
- Breefield 7y agoMy understanding is that these detection signals can cause fires themselves, as they need to be high enough voltage to traverse the entire length of the line—and as such can spark off said faults and cause fires...
- blondie9x 7y agoClimate change is worsening the droughts that cause fires as well as the winds that spread them. Turning off the electricity is one of the only ways until are the transmission lines are buried. But it might be safe to say every residence and apartment building etc should have a battery back up anyway and renewable energy installed. If this were so grid electricity would be a moot point and technically we would not be dependent on grid electricity.
- p1mrx 7y agoWhy would they install a battery backup, when a gasoline/diesel generator is cheaper? I see grid reliability as the cornerstone of fighting climate change. Who in their right mind would replace their furnace with a heat pump, or buy an electric vehicle, when doing so will likely leave them cold and immobile multiple times per year? We need a grid with more capacity and better reliability, if decarbonization is ever going to work.
- generalpass 7y agoWhat if the reason PG&E is turning off the power is not because they are concerned about their lines starting fires, but that they are being scapegoated by the state of California for damage resulting from poor public policy relating to fire dangers? The predictions of a future with large amounts of fires go back quite a ways, and there is some evidence to suggest that native Indians took measures to limit the spread of wildfires. Even if it is assumed that PG&E equipment starts a fire, the exceptional damage caused by the fire is the result of the poor management policies. I've drifted around on my opinions on this whole matter, but currently I find that PG&E is working to steer clear of lawsuits, nothing else.
- tzm 7y agoPre-emptive blackouts have now cost me over $1k.
- kbos87 7y agoYeah, it’s really going to suck as we come to the collective realization that the impact modern life has on the environment is going to encroach on - modern life. PG&E’s actions are the leading edge of what will be a growing trend of inconveniences. Demonizing them is living in denial. We are all culpable.