5 ms·
Bacteria make major evolutionary shift in the lab
- mark-t 18y agoI posted a different version of this story a few days ago: http://scienceblogs.com/loom/2008/06/02/a_new_step_in_evolution.php http://scienceblogs.com/loom/2008/06/02/a_new_step_in_evolut...
- ntoshev 18y agoYour version is much better: it explains what happened in detail and it has much less noise. I guess the one currently on the homepage is more upmoddable because of the creationists reference.
- deathbyzen 18y agoInteresting read. The little snip at the though about creationists seemed a bit petty. Though I can understand why an evolutionary biologist might be a bit miffed at Creationist organizations. In any case, score one for science.
- timr 18y agoIt's not petty. The experiment itself is fairly boring; it's a variant of a routine genetic mapping that we've been doing since Mendel, and the form of the outcome is unsurprising. The only thing that makes this interesting is the length of the experiment, and how it clearly illustrates a basic principle of evolution that the creationists say is impossible. (Also, iirc, Lenski is one of the experts who testified at the Dover trial....)
- dhimes 18y agoI'm sure we'll now see the creationists' argument evolve (again) in another attempt to survive the deft hand of science.
- mynameishere 18y agoIn any case, score one for science. Science, 15. Religion, 4. GOOO hometeam!
- gscott 18y agoI am wondering why evolution happens here and not elsewhere. Every planet in our solar system has been hit by comets, has a cycle of night and day, etc. We should be seeing evolution on the planets near us. For example in the Russian nuclear reactor that failed there is a bacteria that has adapted to feeding off of radiation. So life can happen in the most extreme circumstances. Just because other planets of extreme circumstances doesn't exclude them from evolution.
- cstejerean 18y agoI assume that first life has to develop, and then it has a chance to evolve. So it's possible some places lack the necessary components for life to develop. But it's certainly possible for primitive life forms to exist in other parts of our solar system.
- natch 18y agoLife is tricky to define, but the most likely scenario is life does not develop first - it develops only after a process of evolution of replicating stuff that would not be considered alive by most definitions. Eventually, after billions of years with trillions of petri dishes worth of different little evolution experiments all happening in parallel on each of billions of planets, some of them gain replication mechanisms that are complex enough that they could be considered alive. Evolution leads up to this point, and continues after it.
- natch 18y agoWho said evolution happens only here and not elsewhere?
- gscott 18y ago
- wallflower 18y agoBased on a News.YC recommendation, I'm currently reading "The Selfish Gene" right now and in the book, Richard Dawkins, says at some point billions of years ago a critical fundamental evolution happened - a particularly remarkable molecule was formed by accident, a "Replicator" with the ability to replicate itself. He said the chance of that happening was "exceedingly improbable" and "but in our human estimates of what is probable and what is not, we are not used to dealing in hundreds of millions of years". Improbable accidents (like the one that probably occurred around generation 20,000 of the bacteria) can shape the future.
- username2 18y agoIt's like "Time of the Gaps" instead of "God of the Gaps". Just sprinkle some fairy time dust on it and anything is possible? You should look into the law of large numbers and gambler's fallacy.
- DTrejo 18y agoFrom the article: >In the meantime, the experiment stands as proof that evolution does not always lead to the best possible outcome. Wow, the author forgot something critical--there are no time constraints in this statement. It is as though the author tried a diet for a day and decided the diet did not lead to weight loss.
- eru 18y agoWhat is the best possible outcome?