5 ms·
What the Internet is really doing away with is a giant industry that used to be useful, but now is merely parasitic. That can go both ways: the Internet
by bad_user 16y ago
What the Internet is really doing away with is a giant industry
that used to be useful, but now is merely parasitic.
That can go both ways: the Internet is also breeding a generation of customers that used to value and support music & books, but now is merely parasitic.
we can just give $1.50 to the author directly
I'm all for eliminating middle-men, but free is still a whole lot better than $1.50; and when downloading hundreds of songs from PirateBay, that's several hundreds of dollars versus free.
Musicians who embrace the new reality are doing fine.
Citation needed.
I would also love a functional gift economy, instead of one of scarcity ... but on the Internet a gift economy doesn't really work, because most users are not giving back. How many users of open-source software are giving back contributions and donations?
Even when your software is used by lots of corporations; you either have to beg, or your software has to be broken (in need of a fix).
And I quote from http://www.undeadly.org/cgi?action=article&sid=20060321034114 http://www.undeadly.org/cgi?action=article&sid=200603210... ...
OpenSSH is in use by millions around the world
however the revenue stream just simply isn't there.
Music, books, software: all of them require effort and lots of it.
Being able to work on such things full-time is wonderful; and if broken technologies/legislation like DRM are the only solution for it, then that will be the future.
- greyman 16y ago"and when downloading hundreds of songs from PirateBay, that's several hundreds of dollars versus free." No, it isn't several hundreds of dollars, since many people who are downloading from PirateBay would not buy the songs even if the free option wouldn't be available.
- anthonyb 16y agoThat's his point. The choice for a consumer (who knows about BitTorrent) is between paying hundreds of dollars, or paying nothing. Given that, most people will choose to pay nothing.
- greyman 16y agoBut I wanted to say something else. Many people how don't know about BitTorrent would still not pay.
- jimbokun 16y ago"Many people how don't know about BitTorrent would still not pay." And some would. So where does that leave the overall argument?
- mitcheme 16y agoIt leaves that "it isn't several hundreds of dollars, since many people who are downloading from PirateBay would not buy the songs even if the free option wouldn't be available." The average person who casually downloads a huge torrent with hundreds of songs would not realistically download all of those songs if they paid $1 each for them. That's not a matter of personality but basic economics -- there's far more demand for a song when the "price" is $0 than when it's $1. For $0, many people will download a given song even if they have no real intention of listening to it, simply because the interface to delete lots of files from your computer is easier than the one to exclude lots of individual items from a torrent download. And hey, you can listen to one or two of them for 15 seconds each, maybe you'll find a new song that you like. The first benefit goes away when you're sticking individual songs in your cart, and the second is not worth very much money at all. Take the option of torrenting away and those people would download only a few of those songs for a much more reasonable amount of money.
- bediger 16y agoYou're denying basic free market economics with an emotional argument. In a competitive market, the cost of a good tends towards its marginal cost of production. We get all excited as the cost of solar cells tends lower and lower, as the marginal cost of their production gets smaller. Do we "value" solar cells less because of this? "the Internet is also breeding a generation of customers that used to value and support music & books, but now is merely parasitic." To borrow a phrase, "Citation needed".
- robryan 16y agoWhat about the upfront cost of production? It's all well and good to say each additional copy has tended towards zero but that still doesn't cover the production costs.
- DennisP 16y agoSimple. Pay it up front, release the files for free afterwards. The files turn into advertisements for the next piece.
- davidw 16y agoEh? Who pays up front? I think it's anything but "simple". There's a big incentive to free ride and let someone else pay.
- _delirium 16y ago"Anyone who wants to" is one model, perhaps with some goodies thrown in for those who do. A bunch of musicians have been using that in various forms for the past decade or so (e.g. http://www.neubauten.org/?q=supporters-english http://www.neubauten.org/?q=supporters-english), and Kickstarter now sort of formalizes it.
- davidw 16y agoI'm not convinced that that sort of model can support as much production, and thus we might see a lower level of production of information goods, but I suppose only the future will tell. Musicians always have the fallback of concerts, as I mentioned in another comment.
- harshpotatoes 16y agoThis doesn't completely answer your question about certain music artists doing just fine, but might also be an interesting read. http://blog.tunecore.com/2010/10/music-purchases-and-net-revenue-for-artists-are-up-gross-revenue-for-labels-is-down.html http://blog.tunecore.com/2010/10/music-purchases-and-net-rev...
- Retric 16y agoFor cost books have been competing with at cost books for a long time. The reality is reading 50$ worth of books takes far longer than listening to 50$ worth of music. So while I could download 500,000 books tonight I can read them fast enough for that to be a meaningful activity. PS: At the sub 3$ a book range there is little reason to pirate. I tip waiters more than that let alone entertain me for a few hours.