3 ms·
When businesses won't be as profitable as desired by the owners, they are less likely to be started or to choose to make that expansion. If labor was plentiful
by sokoloff 7y ago
When businesses won't be as profitable as desired by the owners, they are less likely to be started or to choose to make that expansion.
If labor was plentiful and cost $1/hr, we probably wouldn't see nearly as many automated checkout stations or ordering kiosks. If low-skilled labor costs $100/hr, you can bet there's going to be a lot more automation in place.
It seems like most people can grasp the general slope of this demand curve, but seem to be unable (and I think in a lot of cases it's rather unwilling) to reason about whether the curve has a fundamentally different slope/shape in the $8-20/hr range.
- imtringued 7y ago>they are less likely to be started or to choose to make that expansion. You just showed us a counter example. The structure of the market changes toward automation or away from it but the businesses are still being started as usual.
- navigatesol 7y ago>The structure of the market changes toward automation or away from it but the businesses are still being started as usual. Whether this is possible will depend on the cost of capital and state of technology.
- Spooky23 7y agoWe don’t allow for slums like what you see in Brazil or India, so there is a high floor where wages essentially are less productive than not working. So when you push the value of labor to a leave where people cannot afford to live, folks in the US either end up on social services, social security disability, or are incarcerated. Whenever there are changes to minimum wage, the parade of chamber of commerce types bemoan the horrors that will befall them. Yet somehow burgers get flipped and shelves get stocked.
- bufferoverflow 7y ago> We don’t allow for slums like what you see in Brazil or India Many on the left are supporting open borders. Which is guaranteed to attract a huge amount of low skilled labor. Which guarantees low wages (simple supply-demand). And if you artificially control wages, it will result in unemployment of the unskilled. Why do you think we have tent towns all over California?
- mywittyname 7y ago> Many on the left are supporting open borders. No we aren't. > Which is guaranteed to attract a huge amount of low skilled labor. Which guarantees low wages (simple supply-demand). And if you artificially control wages, it will result in unemployment of the unskilled. Right now, the government is artificially suppressing wages by threatening to deport immigrants. Employers take advantage of government enforcement by promising to hide the worker in exchange for poor wages and living conditions. Giving immigrant workers visas, thus rights is a solution to this. No more artificially suppressed wages because the workers don't fear the government > Why do you think we have tent towns all over California? Because they won't allow for enough housing to be built.
- bufferoverflow 7y ago> No we aren't. Yes, you are. https://www.npr.org/2019/09/12/759442642/immigration-where-2020-democratic-candidates-stand-on-border-crossings-and-more?t=1572358546623 https://www.npr.org/2019/09/12/759442642/immigration-where-2...
- apacheCamel 7y agoJust quickly looking at this link, I don't see anywhere it says open borders.It does however say "Decriminalize illegal border crossings" which is not the same as open borders.
- wan23 7y agoThey only started charging people with a crime for crossing the border in 2005 under the Bush administration. I don't think you would say that we had open borders before then, and a return to that previous policy is what people mean by decriminalization.
- geofft 7y agoSure, but $1/hour is not a living wage, so in terms of benefit for workers, it's not obviously better than $100/hour. (And if you have obligations like taking care of your family, you might actively prefer to live off welfare/unemployment/voluntary private charity from the goodness of John Galt's heart/whatever than work a $1/hour job for most of your day.) The curve that's actually interesting is the expected value to an individual worker of the minimum wage, i.e., the wage multiplied by "how likely am I to be employed fully" (approximately 100% at $1/hour, quite a bit less at $100/hour). Obviously, that curve starts at zero, goes up linearly for a bit, then heads back towards zero in the limit. The question is where "a bit" is and what the argmax is.
- navigatesol 7y ago>Sure, but $1/hour is not a living wage No, it isn't. But neither is $0/hour because you don't have a job, and society doesn't get the product that the $1/hour job produces. Ideally, the system would pay the workers the marginal value of their input for the work done, and the government would "top up" the wages to whatever the living wage is. Everyone wins. Of course, this is hard to measure and apply.
- ahje 7y agoWouldn't that simply result in businesses paying as little as possible, which would then result in the need to tax the businesses harder?
- coldpie 7y agoYes. The thing opponents of a living wage don't realize is that the gov't has to make up the gap. The gov't indirectly subsidizes businesses who pay under a living wage, which actually incentivizes them to do so. Enforcing a living wage actually means fewer subsidies and a more efficient and level market.
- AJ007 7y agoIs the government indirectly subsidizing businesses, or are they indirectly subsidizing landlords and the lenders to whom the landlords owe debts? For the vast majority of the world, outside of ultra-expensive first world metropolises, $15 an hour is beyond a comfortable living wage.