8 ms·
First, this is a great and original (AFAIK) post. Kudos to the author! Second, I actually find the most interesting fact to be completely unmentioned by the au
by crazygringo 7y ago
First, this is a great and original (AFAIK) post. Kudos to the author!
Second, I actually find the most interesting fact to be completely unmentioned by the author: that in the first chart (greatest absolute changes), of the 30 biggest swaps, only two were female->male, while the other 28 (over 90%!) were male->female.
It's a remarkable fact -- makes me think of how it's historically been much more acceptable for women to adopt men's styles of clothing, but much less accepted for men to adopt's women's styles of clothing. And with names being equally "fashionable", this fits the same trend.
This also explains what I'd observed but never articulated about late 19th- and early 20th-century fiction: how come so many men have what are to me "women's names"?
Utterly fascinating.
- jghn 7y agoI think it was the original Freakonomics book where I first saw this but it’s a known effect. Name switching is indeed almost purely a one way street
- mffnbs 7y ago> It's a remarkable fact -- makes me think of how it's historically been much more acceptable for women to adopt men's styles of clothing, but much less accepted for men to adopt's women's styles of clothing. This is still the case today. I feel like the two are entirely unrelated, actually. If anything, we’ve seen the opposite phenomenon happen in every market. Buffalo Wild Wings commercials that cater to masculinity, Dr Pepper marketing towards men who typically don’t drink diet soda, hair salons that play sports, scents that smell like trees, etc.
- elliekelly 7y agoHow interesting because from my perspective (a woman) I feel like I'm seeing significantly fewer products that are marketed to/cater to traditional notions of femininity and instead there seems to be a trend towards inclusivity. Tom Ford, Bvlgari, Calvin Klein, and Chanel all have uni-sex fragrances now. Chanel's is called "Boy" and CK's is very inclusively named "all". And there's a _huge_ trend in high-end cosmetics that makeup has no gender. CoverGirl even has a "CoverBoy" spokesmodel now. And of course, any company that dares to "pink it and shrink it" will feel the wrath of Ellen and r/pointlesslygendered.
- mlang23 7y agoThe feminist movement managed to make femininity almost a swear word. Fascinating and very sad. As a male, I was always turned off by unisex products. I wonder how much profit these big companies make with this new marketing strategy. Is it really profitable, or are they just changing their products to avoid public shitstorms, hoping that the shitstorm avoided would have been even worse?
- maldeh 7y agoYour musings here are legitimate, so long as you recognize your feelings as a single datapoint and don't mistake them for a general trend, or extrapolate them to the wider population. As a counterpoint, I don't know of any friends or close acquaintances who would consider feminism or femininity a dirty word. To me, it's a fairly straightforward proposition: Q: Are you pro- women having equal rights to men w.r.t. social structures, family responsibilities, economic opportunities, etc.? A: Yes? Q: And are you willing to take a second look at your social and professional conduct to make sure it doesn't put your female peers in difficult, awkward or uncomfortable positions? A: Sure, why wouldn't I. Hooray! you might be a feminist, it's not that hard. Also, personally don't see what's wrong with unisex products, and I think it may be possible companies might possibly occasionally find the odd not-shitty cause they can back because their employees collectively believe in the positive message and that also aligns well with their goals, and not solely because of a small group of cynical PR managers running focus groups.
- skocznymroczny 7y agoThat's a naive look at feminism. Unfortunately nowadays many other ideologies jump on the feminism bandwagon. It's rare to see someone who is feminist without being also anti-law enforcement, anti-white men, anti-capitalist.
- pavlov 7y agoThe post to which you replied seems to address your concerns: “Your musings here are legitimate, so long as you recognize your feelings as a single datapoint and don't mistake them for a general trend, or extrapolate them to the wider population.”
- hillz 7y ago> We’ve seen the opposite phenomenon happen in every market. Not really? If buffalo wings are like a man's name, or men's pants, the same trend would be for women to adopt those things (which we do). Similarly, if you market only towards women, it is seen as somewhat shameful for a man (and sometimes, even for a woman) to purchase that good.
- mffnbs 7y agoIs that not the exact phenomenon I'm talking about though? The markets exist because masculinity says it's otherwise embarrassing. The same thing doesn't always exist in reverse. It's not embarrassing for women to drink black coffee or a beer, but it defies social masculinity for a man to drink sugary coffee or a mixed drink. It's fine for women to wear jeans, flannel, basically all mens clothes but it's taboo for men to wear any feminine piece of clothing. You can probably come up with examples that betray this as a rule, which is why I'm not claiming it is one. It's a social influence that's pervasive to the degree that masculinity kills men who don't see a doctor or men that have their masculinity questioned and they retaliate with murder. You hardly see women committing crimes because they were perceived as masculine.
- madcaptenor 7y ago> Dr Pepper marketing towards men who typically don’t drink diet soda Don't forget Coke Zero, AKA "Diet Coke for men".
- jdashg 7y agoMany of those have the same root cause: Men are not supposed to be weak, and feminine is seen as weak. To encourage men to buy something, marketing teams are trying to manly it up. If you have a product men are sheepish about, declare loudly that "It's for men!". Or in Dr Pepper's case, "It's not for women"(tm).
- thrower123 7y ago> Dr Pepper marketing towards men who typically don’t drink diet soda I'm not sure that is how I would characterize the Dr. Pepper Lil' Sweet commercials, which appear to feature an extra campy mashup of Prince and peak glam-hair metal Axl Rose.
- bcrosby95 7y agoThey probably don't mention it because they aren't measuring that statistic. If you want to see how likely it is that people will name their male babies "female" names you could probably do that, but you couldn't do that by looking at the "most switched" names from a popularity standpoint. In particular, naming your male a "female" name (or vice versa) that has not switched would really do a better job at showing what society thinks of this. Especially because a singular event in pop culture can switch the public perception of the gender-ness of a name: e.g. the election of John F Kennedy turning "Jackie" into a "female" name practically overnight.
- fenomas 7y agoI don't have a specific source but I believe that masculine names shifting to become feminine, but not the reverse, is a common thing going back at least a few centuries. E.g. Leslie, Allison, Meredith, Lauren, Stacey were all predominantly male names until the 19th or 20th century. Often the shift seems to be due to a celebrity - the change in "Lauren" being generally attributed to Lauren Bacall, etc.
- maxerickson 7y agoLots of them have pretty likely explanations. For instance, Angel got quite a lot more popular when Buffy the Vampire Slayer had a character of that name. Or https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashley_(name) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashley_(name)
- magduf 7y agoI don't think Angel has anything to do with Buffy. Angel is a traditional Hispanic male name. It's become more poopular because there's a lot more Hispanics in the US now, and they have a lot of kids. Other Hispanic names have also been rising in the name-popularity lists. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angel_(given_name) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angel_(given_name) Now if you want to see some interesting effects in name popularity due to popular culture, look at the quick demise of "Jude" after The Beatles' song, and the quick demise of "Jeremy" after Pearl Jam's song.
- maxerickson 7y agoIf you look at the graph, there is a notable change in the growth slope a couple years before 2000, which coincides with the introduction of the character. There's also a decline a few years later.
- lultimouomo 7y agoI always find amusing that in many countries Andrea (which literally means "male") is a girl's name. Is there an equivalent for boys?
- tempguy9999 7y agoDoes it? Any links? Perhaps from the greek Andros? I'm curious.
- lultimouomo 7y agoYes, it comes from "aner" in Greek: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrea https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrea
- zajio1am 7y agoI do not think that is surprising, considering -a is feminine suffix in many languages, and there there is masculine version Andreas (with -as masculine suffix). And i understand literal meaning of Andrea / Andreas / Andrew more like 'manly' than 'male'.
- Technetium_Hat 7y agoyes there is definitely a double standard between a) masculinity in women and b) femininity in men